Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Pasco jury awards $13 million in pink eye lawsuit

Arcadio Hernandez was wrongly diagnosed with having pink eye.

Arcadio Hernandez was wrongly diagnosed with having pink eye.

NEW PORT RICHEY — A jury awarded more than $13 million to a Pasco man in a negligence lawsuit over a misdiagnosis of pink eye.

Arcadio Hernandez, 21, went to the emergency room at Morton Plant North Bay Hospital on July 10, 2010, complaining about pain on or around his eye.

He was seen by the nursing staff and a physician's assistant, Bethany Berghoffer, who diagnosed him with a form of conjunctivitis, commonly known as pink eye. A supervising doctor named Helene Harper never examined Hernandez, but signed off on Berghoffer's diagnosis. They gave him a prescription for antibiotics and sent him on his way.

That November, an aneurysm in his head burst, and Hernandez, who lives in the New Port Richey area, had emergency surgery. Had they properly diagnosed his condition in July, Hernandez's lawyer Steven Deutsch argued during the two-week trial, Hernandez would not be permanently disabled — mentally and physically — as he is today.

"This money is needed by Arcadio to provide the medical services he's going to need for care for the rest of his life," Deutsch said Monday. "It was a clean, exemplary case. The jury did its duty, and justice was done."

Jurors began deliberating Friday afternoon and reached their verdict that evening.

Deutsch originally sought damages between $8.5 million and $9.5 million to cover care for Hernandez and to match his potential lifetime earnings.

Lawyers representing the hospital, Berghoffer and Harper contended Hernandez's diagnosis was correct, given the circumstances and symptoms.

Attorney Andrew Efaw claimed Hernandez's symptoms changed over time to better fit the lawsuit. He grilled Hernandez about inconsistencies in his testimony, including how he described his symptoms as both a headache and eye pain.

A spokeswoman for the hospital said it's deciding what to do next.

"Right now we're in the process of reviewing the verdict and determining if there are any next steps we're going to take," spokeswoman Beth Hardy said.

She also said the hospital no longer uses EmCare — one of the companies named in the suit — to provide staffing for its emergency room. That decision, she said, was not related to the lawsuit.

In court, Hernandez said he had trouble remembering things. He has seizures regularly, he said, that felt like "getting electrocuted and jumping like a fish on the floor."

He walks with a cane and permanently lost the use of one of his hands.

The jury found that Berghoffer, Harper and the hospital were each 30 percent negligent. They also found Hernandez was 10 percent negligent. What that means, Deutsch said, is the award will be reduced by 10 percent, to somewhere around $12 million.

Pasco jury awards $13 million in pink eye lawsuit 12/16/13 [Last modified: Monday, December 16, 2013 10:15pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Tampa Repertory's 'Flying' soars in some places, sputters in others


    TAMPA — Tampa Repertory Theatre has always insisted on putting on plays that mean something. Several shows over the last couple of years have zeroed in on the social and cultural baggage that comes with being female (The Children's Hour, Silent Sky and Grounded come to mind). None of those …

    The Southeastern premiere of Flying, Sheila Cowley's play at Tampa Repertory Theatre about veterans of the Women's Air Force Service Pilots, includes (from left) Holly Marie Weber, Rosemary Orlando, and Becca McCoy. Photo by Megan Lamasney.
  2. Bucs-Vikings: What could make Tampa Bay's defense elite again


    TAMPA — The last time the Bucs had a top-five defense also happens to be when they last appeared in the postseason.

    Bucs outside linebacker Lavonte David (54) celebrates after recovering a fumble by Chicago Bears quarterback Mike Glennon (8) during the first half. [LOREN ELLIOTT   |   Times]
  3. Top 5 at noon: Detours, delays on I-75 in Pasco; last call for New World Brewery; and more


    Here are the latest headlines and updates on

    Road crews clean up a mess of crash debris - and pumpkins - left behind after a fiery semitrailer truck crash on Interstate 75 in Pasco County on Sept. 22, 2017. [Florida Highway Patrol]
  4. Trumps travel ban to be replaced by restrictions tailored to certain countries


    WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump's ban on travelers from six majority-Muslim countries is set to be replaced as soon as this weekend with more targeted restrictions on visits to the United States that would vary by country, the New York Times reports, citing officials familiar with the plans.

    President Donald Trump's ban on travelers from six majority-Muslim countries is set to be replaced as soon as this weekend with more targeted restrictions on visits to the United States that would vary by country, officials familiar with the plans said Friday. The new restrictions, aimed at preventing security threats from entering the United States, could go into effect Sunday after the conclusion of a 90-day policy review undertaken as part of the administration's original travel ban. Though the restrictions would differ for each country, people living in the targeted nations could be prevented from traveling to the United States or could face increased scrutiny as they seek to obtain a visa. [Associated Press]
  5. New World Brewery is closing. Where will all its concerts go now?


    Ever since it was announced that New World Brewery was closing its beloved Ybor City location and relocating to a spot farther north, there’s been an outpouring of nostalgia from artists, promoters and fans throughout the Tampa Bay music scene.

    Allison Weiss performed at New World Brewery in 2015.