Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Picking a jury will be particularly tough in Hulk Hogan sex tape case against Gawker (w/video)

Before the $100 million defamation trial between Terry Bollea, better known as Hulk Hogan, and gossip and news website Gawker can unravel this month, their attorneys must decide: who will be on the jury?

Whoever sits in the jury box will determine if Gawker violated Bollea's right to privacy when it published the video of the former professional wrestler having sex with his best friend's wife, which Bollea's attorneys say garnered 7 million views.

But attorneys will likely face several challenges, from Bollea's celebrity status to jurors' perceptions of sex, as they feud in a Pinellas courtroom to keep the six jurors, plus three alternates, that each side likes the most.

LIVE BLOG: Follow the latest from the Hulk Hogan vs. Gawker case

On the one hand, there's Gawker, a website that makes money by "peering in the virtual window of folks and putting private moments on display without permission," said Charles Rose, director of the Center for Excellence in Advocacy at Stetson University College of Law. On the other, there's Hulk Hogan betraying his former best friend, Tampa radio DJ Bubba the Love Sponge Clem.

"You've got competing lines across the board," Rose said. "It may very well be that the jury that's going to function the best for the trial is the one that dislikes you less than they dislike the other side."

Likability aside, some things professors and lawyers said Bollea's attorneys may be searching for this week: former pro wrestling fans. People who follow the lives of the rich and famous a la Kim Kardashian. Victims of privacy crimes. The middle-aged.

"Quite often, an older juror can also be more understanding about sexual issues because they've had more experience, they've kind of lived life," Rose said.

Divorced men could also sympathize with Bollea, a divorcee himself, said Joseph Hanna, a New York-based sports and entertainment lawyer.

Bollea, raised in Tampa, may also have a hometown advantage over Gawker, the corporate outsider from New York.

"Gawker is going to have to explain what they do, and that's where the hometown jury comes into play," Hanna said. "Who are you guys? You guys are a tabloid from Manhattan? Your conservative St. Petersburg people might view this as smut."

VIDEO: Hulk Hogan sues Gawker over sex tape

On Gawker's side, attorneys will likely be excluding any candidates who have negative opinions about the media and mining for tech savvy 20- and 30-somethings, experts said. Attorneys might pose questions like, do you own a smart phone, use apps like Snapchat, or record video with your phone?

"Younger people have a tendency to believe that anything that's newsworthy should be available to the public," Hanna said.

Potential jurors this week completed a 14-page questionnaire that includes questions about their knowledge of the case, Bollea, and Gawker. It will help attorneys get a better sense of the people within the pool. During jury selection, attorneys for each party also get a certain number of peremptory challenges that allow them to dismiss a potential juror for any reason. In this case, each side will have six, plus one for an alternate juror.

Among the first questions: "This case involves images depicting sex and nudity, and the use of profanity. Would receiving and viewing this type of content affect your ability to serve as a fair and impartial juror in this case?"

The "content" in question is the one minute and 41-second video excerpt of Bollea having sex with Clem's then wife. Jurors will have to watch the sex tape.

Carolyn Koch, a Virginia-based trial consultant, said the concept of a sex tape is not as shocking as it once was to the public.

"It's two consenting adults... People have a real problem looking at things that show violence or sex acts against children," she said. "This is more along the lines of rubbernecking."

Other factors will also weigh on who stays and who is dismissed from jury selection, like jurors who already deeply dislike Bollea or his use of the N-word during a racist remark made public last year.

"They might have already assumed the worst of Hulk Hogan," said Valerie Hans, a Cornell University law professor who focuses on jury research. "They knew a fair amount about him, about his blustery ways, his persona."

Another challenge: the length of the trial, expected to span three weeks.

"The longer the trial," said Steve Yerrid, a Tampa civil trial lawyer, "the more likely there is going to be hardship on a number of jurors."

Attorneys should also be mindful of people who might seem too eager or excited to be chosen as a juror due to "voyeuristic reasons or because of the potential of making a buck afterward," said Rose, the Stetson professor.

"Jury selection is the hardest skill for trial lawyers," he added. "It actually often has more impact than any other portion of the trial."

Times staff researcher Caryn Baird and staff writer Anna M. Phillips contributed to this report. Contact Laura C. Morel at Follow @lauracmorel.

Terry Bollea, also known by his professional wrestling name of Hulk Hogan, left, watches the questioning of  potential jurors by lawyers and the judge at the Pinellas County Courthouse in St. Petersburg as jury selection began in his case against. Gawker Media. [SCOTT KEELER | Times]

Terry Bollea, also known by his professional wrestling name of Hulk Hogan, left, watches the questioning of potential jurors by lawyers and the judge at the Pinellas County Courthouse in St. Petersburg as jury selection began in his case against. Gawker Media. [SCOTT KEELER | Times]

Picking a jury will be particularly tough in Hulk Hogan sex tape case against Gawker (w/video) 03/02/16 [Last modified: Wednesday, March 2, 2016 6:44pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Video: Trump shoves fellow NATO leader aside on his first summit


    President Donald Trump muscled himself to the front of the NATO pack during a photo opportunity in Brussels on Thursday, pushing aside the leader of soon-to-be member Montenegro.

    In this image taken from NATO TV, Montenegro Prime Minister Dusko Markovic, second right, appears to be pushed by U.S. President Donald Trump as they were given a tour of NATO's new headquarters after taking part in a group photo, during a NATO summit of heads of state and government in Brussels on Thursday. [NATO TV via AP]
  2. FBI probes fraudster's alleged church scam following Tampa Bay Times report

    Real Estate

    PLANT CITY — Once again, the FBI is investigating felon fraudster Victor Thomas Clavizzao.

    The FBI is investigating convicted mortgage fraudster Victor Thomas Clavizzao on new allegations following a Tampa Bay Times report.
[TImes file photo]

  3. See inside this Snell Isle home with an amazing chandelier and infinity pool

    Home and Garden

    When Elizabeth and David Samuelson started planning the house they built six years ago on Snell Isle, the couple envisioned a West Indies look with masonry stucco walls and a metal hip roof. As they moved forward, it evolved into something they describe as coastal contemporary.

    Elizabeth Samuelson and David Samuelson's at the entrance to their Snell Isle house which has numerous luxurious features yet is a comfortable home for a family of four. An infinity pool blends seamlessly from the terrace right into Tampa Bay. Doors surrounding the family room open and are then out of sight enabling the interior to seem more outside than inside. David designed and made a chandelier with hundreds of dangling, clear fish that hangs over the foyer.
  4. Appeals court deals blow to Trump administration travel ban


    WASHINGTON — A federal appeals court dealt another blow to President Donald Trump's revised travel ban targeting six-Muslim majority countries on Thursday, siding with groups that say the policy illegally targets Muslims.

    Donald Trump will likely appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court. [Stephanie Lecocq/Pool via AP]
  5. Bucs suspended RB Doug Martin breaks his silence and says his drug problem is 'definitely behind me.'


    He would not talk about the drug he abused. He didn’t identify the rehab facility he entered last January or how long he was there.

    Doug Martin was contrite but optimistic about returning to the form he demonstrated as the NFL's second leading rusher two years ago.