Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Pinellas judge: New process may be needed to screen jurors

ST. PETERSBURG — Jurors who withhold information about their own legal history have always messed up trials. If a juror withholds important facts that bias them, the losing side sometimes finds out and gets a new trial.

Now, online searches let lawyers learn about jurors with ease and root out biases before trials begin. Maybe, a Pinellas judge has declared, it's time to change the rules.

Circuit Court Judge Anthony Rondolino made his observations in April while denying a motion for a new trial in the case of an 84-year-old South Pasadena woman who fell and died in the stairwell of an assisted living facility.

Her estate asked for $15 million, but the jury found that the home bore no blame. After trial, her estate combed public records and discovered that all six jurors had failed to mention their own involvement with bankruptcies, foreclosures and other litigation — so the lawyers could not explore possible biases.

Though Florida law allows such post-verdict searches, "There was plenty of time to gather the information'' during the two-week trial, Rondolino wrote. "There was actually a three-day period when the court was recessed during which these public records could have been obtained.''

If lawyers detected potential bias, they could have challenged that juror before knowing the verdict, Rondolino wrote.

Plaintiff and defense lawyers in the case were unavailable for comment, but the estate has already appealed. Lawyers noted that Florida courts have held that even if a juror didn't intend to be untruthful, that can constitute "juror misconduct sufficient to support a motion for a new trial."

Pinellas-Pasco Chief Judge Tom McGrady would not comment on the stairwell case but said online searches have made motions for new trials common because juror backgrounds are readily available.

"In the old days, the losing side would have to send out a private investigator and snoop around,'' McGrady said. Now, technology offers lawyers "a gotcha card. They can wait and see how the verdict stands and then pull it out.''

A big problem, said McGrady, is that lawyers and judges questioning jurors about their histories often use terms that lay people may not understand.

For instance, lawyer might ask potential jurors if they had ever been involved in litigation.

"What does that mean to them?'' McGrady said. "I do not think they are trying to hide things. I just think they do not understand what we are getting at."

The stairwell jurors were asked if they had ever been sued or had a claim made against them. One juror who had gone through bankruptcy didn't raise his hand.

"That was not litigation,'' he later told the Tampa Bay Times "We went to a bankruptcy lawyer and he handled the whole thing. We did not go in front of a judge.''

John Mills, a Tallahassee appellate attorney, said the courts face a difficult balance in such cases.

"The losing party can be looking for a second bite at the apple,'' Mills said. "But to have a juror not telling the truth — especially if they affirmatively lied — is no good.''

In his order, Rondolino determined that missing information about jurors and litigation was not relevant enough to merit a new trial. The estate's attorneys did not pose a lot of extra questions when other potential jurors did mention bankruptcies or other litigation, Rondolino said.

In an earlier interview, estate attorney Bennie Lazzara explained that overly vigorous questioning might offend all jurors. Lawyers need to explore possible biases on a case-by-case basis without being too heavy handed, he said.

During a January hearing on the new trial motion, Rondolino came up with a possible fix: Maybe recess tough cases right after jury selection and require lawyers to run background checks and raise objections before the trial. It would be up to the appellate court to decide if such a procedure is legal, he said.

Contact Stephen Nohlgren at

Pinellas judge: New process may be needed to screen jurors 07/08/14 [Last modified: Tuesday, July 8, 2014 10:02pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Southern heritage groups sue to keep Confederate monument at old Tampa courthouse

    Local Government

    TAMPA — Groups that say they support Southern heritage filed a lawsuit late Friday trying to halt the removal of a Confederate statue from downtown Tampa.

    Workers place boards around a Confederate monument on Hillsborough County property in Tampa on Thursday, August 17, 2017. It took 24 hours to raise private funds in order to move the statue from its current location.
  2. Bucs mull options at right tackle as Dotson awaits MRI


    Right tackle Demar Dotson, the Bucs' most experienced offensive lineman, will undergo an MRI on his injured groin Saturday, three weeks before the season opener.

    Tampa Bay Buccaneer Demar Dotson, offensive tackle, brought his coffee and breakfast to One Buc Place, 7/31/15, as he reported to training camp.
  3. For starters: Rays vs. Mariners, with another new look


    Having lost 11 of their last 14 games and dropping to a season-worst four games under .500 at 60-64, the Rays continue to search for ways to get out of their extended offensive slump.

    And with the M's starting LHP Ariel Miranda today, that means another new look to the lineup, which includes having struggling …

  4. Chasing 125: Bucs hope to hit rushing goal more often


    Ever so often, Bucs coach Dirk Koetter pulls back the curtain a bit and shares some of the stats that matter to him most as a coach.

    Tampa Bay Buccaneers head coach Dirk Koetter walks the field during the second day of mandatory minicamp at One Buccaneer Place in Tampa, Fla., on Wednesday, June 14, 2017.
  5. Two Boca Ciega students arrested on charges they brought gun to high school football game


    PINELLAS PARK — Two Boca Ciega High School students were arrested for having a loaded semi-automatic handgun with them at a Friday night football game at Pinellas Park High School.

    Two Boca Ciega High School students were arrested for bringing a weapon on school property on Friday night at a high school football game at Pinellas Park High School.