Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Widow's suit: Couple didn't do enough to save choking man's life

NEW PORT RICHEY — Andreas Pieri died in the company of friends.

His wife, Thelma, was overseas. So friends Phillip and Andamanatia Rivers had him over for dinner.

Then their guest started choking.

What happened next is the reason Thelma Pieri filed suit Friday against the Riverses.

The couple didn't try the Heimlich maneuver to dislodge the food blocking his airway, according to the lawsuit.

And the law says they didn't have to.

But Thelma Pieri isn't suing the Riverses because they did nothing to help — but because they didn't do enough.

• • •

The dinner was June 22, 2006, at the Riverses' Gulf Harbors home, according to the suit filed in Pinellas-Pasco circuit court.

When Andreas Pieri began choking, the lawsuit said, the couple gave him a glass of water. Then they called 911.

Paramedics came and managed to clear his airway, according to Thelma Pieri's attorney, Jim Magazine. But it was too late.

Andreas Pieri was already brain dead, the lawyer said. He died in a Pasco hospital July 8, 2006, at age 67.

• • •

A person's moral obligations, said University of Florida law professor Lars Noah, are not the same as his legal ones.

If someone is in trouble, and you did nothing to harm them, then the law says you don't have to do anything to help them.

There are exceptions. Babysitters are legally responsible for their charges, for example. Or if you're choking in a restaurant, the staff has to help you.

But otherwise, the law says we can help — and not help — whomever we wish.

"It may be crass, it may be conduct we would all frown upon," the professor said, "but you don't have to lift a finger." Otherwise, Noah said, everyone would be obliged to help — and be second-guessed by the law.

"You would have this constant meddling," the professor said, "these do-gooders getting in your way."

But to sue someone for not helping?

"That's why it's rare," Noah said. "Lawyers don't bring those cases because they know from first-year torts, those never work.

"Unless you can find some other angle."

• • •

This might be that angle: the glass of water the Riverses tried to give to the choking man.

"Our argument is that once you attempt to help somebody you have to do it in a reasonable manner," Magazine said. "The aid they attempted to render was to provide him with water, and when that doesn't work, then it's our argument that it's unreasonable not to try and help him further by performing the Heimlich maneuver."

The lawsuit is seeking thousands of dollars for medical and funeral expenses and loss of companionship. The Riverses' homeowners' insurance would cover any losses.

But the professor sees the lawyer's argument as half full.

"You ask 50 people on the street and I'm sure the vast majority would say sure, a reasonable person would do that," Noah said, referring to the Heimlich. "But as a matter of tort law, you don't have an obligation to act reasonably in the first place."

Jamal Thalji can be reached at or (727) 869-6236.

Widow's suit: Couple didn't do enough to save choking man's life 06/13/08 [Last modified: Monday, June 16, 2008 11:43am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Photo gallery: 20 mugshots of pro athletes arrested in Florida - 1994 to 2017


    In light of today's arrest of Tiger Woods in Jupiter, Florida on DUI charges, here are 20 booking mugs of professional athletes who have been arrested in Florida, from 1994 (Jennifer Capriati) to today (Woods).

    Desmond Bryant - 2005 - Oakland Raiders defensive tackle Desmond Bryant was arrested in Miami on charges of criminal mischief after allegedly "going to a neighbor's house inebriated and causing a commotion." 

  2. For starters: Rays at Rangers, with Erasmo on the mound again


    Coming off Sunday's 6 1/2-hour, 15-inning marathon win over the Twins, the Rays will have the pitcher who finished that game, Erasmo Ramirez, start tonight's game in Texas, first pitch 8:05 Tampa Bay time.

    Ramirez threw only 12 pitches on Sunday so the Rays decided to let him make his planned start tonight, …

  3. Curlew Hills Memory Gardens honors Memorial Day (w/video)


       Curlew Hills Memory Gardens honored those that served during their 31st annual Memorial Day Service on Monday (5/23/17) in Palm Harbor. The event featured guest speakers, live choral performances by the Palm Harbor United Methodist Church choir and live music by Bones South, an area trombone ensemble with …

    Eight-year-old Piper St. Jean, of Tampa, uses a brush to clean the grave of her grandfather, Henry St. Jean, who served with the United States Air Force during the Korean and Vietnam wars. at Curlew Hills Memory Gardens on Monday moments after the conclusion of their 31st annual Memorial Day Service on Monday (5/23/17) in Palm Harbor.
  4. Authorities release name of Tampa woman killed in Temple Terrace apartment fire


    TEMPLE TERRACE — Authorities have released the name of a woman who died in a fire that destroyed a dozen units in an apartment complex here Sunday.

    Firefighters battle an early-morning fire Sunday that claimed the life of 28-year-old Tenecia Renee Brannon and left about 30 others homeless. [Temple Terrace Fire Department]
  5. New Port Richey restaurant worker shoots attacker


    NEW PORT RICHEY — A restaurant kitchen worker shot and injured a man who entered the business and began beating him Saturday, according to New Port Richey Police.

    Vince Angelety, 29, of New Port Richey faces a charge of burglary with simple battery. He remained in the Land O'Lakes Detention Center on Monday, held without bail. [Photo courtesy of the Pasco County Sheriff's Office]