Tuesday, July 17, 2018
News Roundup

Court says Pinellas judge's system wasn't legal; public defender likens it to 'debtors prison'

In Judge Thomas Freeman's court, people sometimes spent years paying off fines and fees — even though misdemeanor probation is not supposed to last longer than 12 months.

The Pinellas County judge fashioned his own system called "the sentencing path," which could require people to stay under court supervision for much longer than a conventional sentence while they worked to pay their fines — with the threat of jail looming.

The judge would often put people in holding cells for an hour or more — with access to a phone — to encourage them to raise the money they owed.

Although courts can collect money from criminal defendants for fines and restitution, it's unconstitutional to have "debtors prisons" — jailing people simply because they don't have money.

"That's what it felt like that court was becoming," said Pinellas-Pasco Public Defender Bob Dillinger, who has been criticizing Freeman's program for more than a year.

Earlier this month, an appeals court struck down the practice.

"A sentencing path is not a sanction recognized in Florida law," the appellate judges stated.

Dillinger is now asking if money can be refunded to defendants who paid fees past the time they should have been on probation.

Freeman defended his program Tuesday, saying his system was designed to give people extra chances so they didn't have to go to jail or lose their drivers' licenses because they couldn't pay fines by the normal deadline.

"I was trying to help people out, that's what I was trying to do," Freeman said.

Freeman said he did sometimes place people in a holding cell for an hour or two, where they were allowed to make phone calls. He said it often helped motivate them to find money to pay their obligations.

"It was amazing how many times people had someone in the hall or in the parking lot, or they actually had money on them," Freeman said.

Dillinger said the program unfairly hurt the poor.

"It used the threat of jail to collect money from the indigent, and that's why the clients went along with it," he said. "The clients were deathly afraid of going to jail for owing money."

Another problem is that once people started down the sentencing path, they didn't know how long it would last, said Ngozi Acholonu, an attorney for the Office of Regional Conflict Counsel, who filed the successful appeal.

"Every citizen needs to know what the possible sentences are for the crime that they're charged with."

For one of her clients who admitted violating probation on a reckless driving charge, Freeman delayed his sentencing hearing 25 times over a 20-month period.

A memo prepared by Senior Associate Public Defender Kandice Friesen raised other allegations about the program, including:

• People who agreed to "the sentencing path" may not have been properly informed that they could have an attorney present. Freeman says he did inform them.

• People were not told the sentencing path could stretch on for months or years.

Freeman, a county judge for more than 30 years, presides in a court division that handles people who violate their probation sentences for misdemeanor crimes.

People on probation are usually asked to perform certain tasks, such as paying money to the victims of their crimes, paying money for court costs, getting drug and alcohol treatment, performing community service and so on.

If someone doesn't follow those rules, the judge has a few options. One is to send the person to jail for violating probation.

Freeman said he decided to let people admit to violating probation and then set a date for their sentencing a few weeks in the future. If they continued to violate, he had the option to jail them.

But really, Freeman said, he was trying to get them to comply. Hopefully, people would show up for their sentencing hearings with proof of drug treatment and evidence of paying court costs and other fees. By staying current, they could keep their drivers' licenses because licenses can be suspended when fees aren't paid. Overall, he said this helped people keep their jobs, keep their licenses and keep feeding their families — all of which can be destroyed if someone gets thrown in jail for 30 days.

"I was trying to do this as an alternative to jailing people," Freeman said, and "I absolutely, truly believed that I was following the law."

He added, "I was getting feedback from defendants that was very positive."

Some defense attorneys liked the program, too.

"We would agree that it was well-intentioned," said defense attorney Richard Watts. "Ninety-nine percent of my clients took the sentencing path because the alternative was being locked up."

"The benefits far outweighed the disadvantages," said attorney Robert Love.

Pinellas-Pasco Chief Judge Thomas McGrady said he was "absolutely" sure Freeman was trying to help. But both judges said they would comply with the new ruling.

"It just means that we'll have to make all efforts possible to make sure we get cases through the system within the probation period," McGrady said.

Curtis Krueger can be reached at [email protected] or (727) 893-8232.

Comments
Trains crashes into SUV in Dade City, injuring one

Trains crashes into SUV in Dade City, injuring one

DADE CITY — One person was seriously injured when a train struck a sport-utility vehicle on Tuesday along the train tracks near U.S. 301, according to Pasco County Fire Rescue.The incident took place near the 37900 block of Vitality Way. The incident...
Updated: 19 minutes ago

Updated: 22 minutes ago
Police: Clearwater man crashes stolen car, flees with liquor bottle

Police: Clearwater man crashes stolen car, flees with liquor bottle

CLEARWATER — A 21-year-old man was arrested Monday on allegations that he stole a car, ran a red light and crashed into another vehicle, according to Clearwater police.The crash took place at S Keene Road and Druid Road. After the crash, police said ...
Updated: 28 minutes ago
Clearwater man charged with using a forklift to pin his girlfriend against a bus

Clearwater man charged with using a forklift to pin his girlfriend against a bus

CLEARWATER — A 67-year-old man is accused of using a forklift to pin his girlfriend against a bus, according to Clearwater police.Colin Lee Showard, faces a charge of aggravated battery in connection with the Sunday night incident which took place al...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Rays Blake Snell ready for All-Star turn

Rays Blake Snell ready for All-Star turn

Rays LHP Blake Snell is ready for his first All-Star opportunity tonight, expected to pitch the third and possibly the fourth inning."I'm excited," he said on the field before the AL batting practice. "It's going to be fun. I've been looking forward ...
Updated: 1 hour ago
SEC media days: Can Dan Mullen fix Florida Gators’ broken foundation?

SEC media days: Can Dan Mullen fix Florida Gators’ broken foundation?

ATLANTA — When coach Dan Mullen evaluated the 4-7 Gators team he inherited, he saw a problem bigger than its quarterback play and more damning than a defense that produced the worst statistical season since World War II.He saw a program wi...
Updated: 1 hour ago

Updated: 1 hour ago
Pinellas County Commission shows support for CrossBay Ferry

Pinellas County Commission shows support for CrossBay Ferry

CLEARWATER –– The ferry that once linked St. Petersburg and Tampa downtowns took one step closer to returning in November.While the Pinellas County Commission didn’t approve spending money to help pay for the CrossBay Ferry during a meeting Tuesday, ...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Fired Hernando school superintendent Lori Romano finds a job in the county next door — Pasco

Fired Hernando school superintendent Lori Romano finds a job in the county next door — Pasco

Lori Romano, fired from the Hernando County superintendent post for "ineffective leadership" a month ago, has snagged a job in the neighboring Pasco County school district.She won’t be nearly as high up the administrative ladder in her new role.Subje...
Updated: 2 hours ago
Ybor City mainstay La Segunda opens second location, introduces seating

Ybor City mainstay La Segunda opens second location, introduces seating

TAMPA — It’s like stepping off Kennedy Boulevard right into Ybor City.From the exposed brick and wrought iron accents to the street lamp-styled globe lights hanging from the ceiling and the signage — blue and red divided by a ribbon of gold — the new...
Updated: 3 hours ago