Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Are Florida's six-member juries constitutional?

Ever see the movie 12 Angry Men?

In Florida, a more accurate title most of the time would be Six Slightly Irritated Folks.

Florida, like most states, routinely uses juries of only six members. The exception is for first-degree murder, which gets a 12-member jury.

But to Alisa Smith, a University of Tampa criminologist who also works as a public defender, six of one is definitely not as good as a dozen of the other.

Smith argues that Florida's jury system is unconstitutional. This Friday, she'll get a long-shot chance at having the U.S. Supreme Court take up her claim.

"That Florida has only six-person juries in felony prosecutions," Smith says, "and one of the highest rates of wrongful conviction, is important."

This has come up before.

In fact, the landmark 1970 Supreme Court case that approved smaller juries in the first place comes from Florida. The court called the tradition of 12-member juries just a "historical accident."

But then in 1978, the court struck down the use of five-member juries in Georgia.

Got that?

Six is hunky-dory.

Five — nope, that's unconstitutional.

Even the Supreme Court knew that it was splitting hairs, saying: "We readily admit that we do not pretend to discern a clear line between six members and five."

I asked Smith why the court should reconsider its 1970 ruling. She said there is plenty of modern research showing that a six-member jury is fundamentally different — less deliberative, more subject to peer pressure, less diverse.

"Twelve jurors deliberate longer," she said. "They have better recall. There are six more sets of ears listening. If you're in the minority, you're more likely to have another person who agrees with you."

I asked: Well, even if 12 is better than six, so what? If 18 were even better, should that be our standard? Is there a "constitutional right" to have a 12-member jury?

Smith said the problem is the way that Florida uses both.

Those accused of one capital crime, first-degree murder, get 12 jurors, even though a lot of them end up getting life in prison instead of death.

Yet those accused of other crimes carrying an equally severe sentence of life in prison only get six jurors. In many states they would get 12.

"You can get life pretty readily in the state of Florida," Smith said, so those cases deserve 12 jurors too.

(By the way, the case Smith is appealing never got much press. It involves a Hillsborough man convicted of molesting his daughter years before. The case hinged especially on which testimony the jury believed.)

As I said, Smith's petition to the Supreme Court is a long shot. In fact, this is the third time Smith has tried in recent years. One of those times she at least got a nibble when the court asked the state to file an answer.

Attorney General Bill McCollum's office sent me the legal brief it put together last year. The state argues that the 1970 case is the established law of the land; that the 1978 Georgia case left Florida's situation unchanged; and that Smith's speculations hardly rise to the standard for the Supreme Court to take up the case.

I wouldn't throw out Supreme Court precedent every time somebody produces a new study. I doubt the court will take her case Friday. But, you know, it's an interesting question, and I'm glad there is an Alisa Smith in the world to raise it.

Are Florida's six-member juries constitutional? 01/07/09 [Last modified: Friday, January 9, 2009 10:26am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Astros rout Yankees to force Game 7 of AL Championship Series


    HOUSTON — Justin Verlander pitched seven shutout innings to outduel Luis Severino for the second time, and the Astros bats came alive in their return home as Houston routed the Yankees 7-1 Friday night and forced a decisive Game 7 in the American League Championship Series.

    The Astros’ Brian McCann, who has struggled during the ALCS, breaks a scoreless tie with an RBI double during the fifth inning off Yankees starter Luis Severino.
  2. Review: Faith Hill and Tim McGraw shower love, star power on Tampa's Amalie Arena


    Near the end of their potent new duet Break First, Tim McGraw stopped singing, and let Faith Hill's powerhouse voice take over.

    Faith Hill and Tim McGraw performed at Amalie Arena in Tampa on Oct. 20, 2017.
  3. Senate to take up AUMF debate as Trump defends reaction to Niger attack


    WASHINGTON — The Senate Foreign Relations Committee is taking up a long-awaited debate about authorizing military force against the Islamic State as President Trump comes under unprecedented public scrutiny for his treatment of dead soldiers' families, following an ambush on troops helping to fight Islamic …

  4. In fear and vigilance, a Tampa neighborhood holds its breath


    TAMPA — There was a time, not long ago, when Wayne Capaz would go for a stroll at night and Christina Rodriguez would shop whenever she wanted. Michael Fuller would go to his night job as a line cook, not too worried about his wife at home.

    More than 50 people gathered and walked in the Southeast Seminole Heights community Friday to pay respects to the victims of three shootings. The crowd took a moment of silence at the corner of 11th Street and East New Orleans where Monica Hoffa was found dead. [JONATHAN CAPRIEL  |  Times]
  5. Fennelly: What's not to like about Lightning's start?

    Lightning Strikes

    BRANDON — No one is engraving the Stanley Cup. No one has begun stuffing the league MVP ballot box for Nikita Kucherov.

    The Lightning, with a win tonight, would match the best start in franchise history, 7-1-1 in the 2003-04 Cup season.