Tuesday, August 21, 2018
News Roundup

Attorney appeals Hillsborough judge's order protecting a fellow jurist from questioning

TAMPA — For more than two decades, Hillsborough Circuit Court Judge Chet Tharpe has listened to testimony from some of the area's most hardened criminals. But a recent effort to require him to answer questions under oath about his role in an attempted murder case is not going as smoothly as his daily courtroom proceedings.

On Friday, a month after a judge rejected his demand to question Tharpe, Tampa lawyer Mark O'Brien said he has petitioned Florida's 2nd District Court of Appeal to reverse the decision. If he is successful, Tharpe could be forced to reveal the details of his out-of-court communications regarding the case.

Disagreement over whether Tharpe can be deposed — a legal demand that is almost never made of judges — stems from his unusual involvement in the case of Matthew Buendia, a former Marine who shot a Hillsborough sheriff's deputy in 2011. Although Tharpe was not the judge assigned to Buendia's case, or the judge on duty the weekend of his arrest, he intervened and called the jail to revoke Buendia's bond after Hillsborough Sheriff David Gee complained publicly that it was too low.

Tharpe's actions have led to criticism that he overstepped the bounds of Florida's Rules of Criminal Procedure. But they have also led O'Brien to wonder who the veteran jurist talked to, and what evidence was shared with him that would have led him to revoke the $65,000 bond. As Buendia's attorney, he says he has a right to this information.

O'Brien has previously tried to get Gee and Hillsborough State Attorney's Office spokesman Mark Cox to answer these same questions, but both men have successfully fought off his subpoenas. Tharpe has tried to do the same.

In August, Hillsborough Circuit Court Judge Lisa Campbell issued a decision rejecting O'Brien's request to depose Tharpe.

"This area of inquiry would require Judge Tharpe to testify about his thought process," she wrote, which "is prohibited by law."

In his petition to the court of appeal, O'Brien wrote that "he is not seeking Judge Tharpe's mental processes." Rather, he has four questions for the judge: Who did you talk to on Oct. 2, 2011? How did you talk to them? When? And what did they tell you?

Campbell did not take well to O'Brien's decision to appeal on Friday. After initially granting his request for a stay, she appeared agitated and quickly reversed herself before moving on to the next case.

Contact Anna M. Phillips at [email protected] or (813) 226-3354. Follow @annamphillips.

Comments
The Daystarter: Measles and parents who don’t vaccinate; immigration hardliner DeSantis’ great-great-grandmother nearly barred; preseason helps mend Bucs fans’ souls

The Daystarter: Measles and parents who don’t vaccinate; immigration hardliner DeSantis’ great-great-grandmother nearly barred; preseason helps mend Bucs fans’ souls

Catching you up on overnight happenings, and what to know today.• Watch out for more thunderstorms in the evening hours, but it’ll dry up by sunset, according to the National Weather Service. Highs will be in the low 90s.• As you head out for your m...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Standoff ends in Lutz after man stabs woman several times

Standoff ends in Lutz after man stabs woman several times

LUTZ — A man stabbed a woman multiple times before barricading himself in a Lutz home early Tuesday morning, according to the Hillsborough County Sheriff’s Office.The standoff ended about three hours later with Hillsborough County Fire Rescue crews t...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Romano: Draining the swamp can be dangerous in Florida

Romano: Draining the swamp can be dangerous in Florida

Drain the swamp. That’s the rallying cry, right?More term limits, fewer career politicians. A ruling class of regular folks. There’s just one small problem. The average Floridian is more dangerous than whatever you’ll run into in a swamp. Other place...
Published: 08/21/18
Leader of group behind transportation petition drive had his signature thrown out

Leader of group behind transportation petition drive had his signature thrown out

TAMPA — Tyler Hudson has become the face of the citizens group behind the Hillsborough County sales tax transportation initiative.The Tampa Heights attorney took the lead at news conferences and delivered boxes of signatures for the group’s petition ...
Published: 08/21/18
Largo looks for ways to cut use of plastics, without a ban

Largo looks for ways to cut use of plastics, without a ban

LARGO — Commissioners made a pledge recently to transition city operations to 100 percent clean energy by 2035, but Jamie Robinson had something a little more immediate in mind.So, the commissioner asked his peers on the dais if they thought the time...
Published: 08/21/18

Tuesday’s letters: Sculpture will be safe for the birds

Sculpture raises bird safety fears | Aug. 14Sculpture will be safe for the birdsIt’s gratifying and exciting to be moving ahead with the design of an outdoor sculpture for the Pier District in St. Petersburg. I want to thank the City Council, cit...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Rays defeat Royals thanks to pitching and replay

Rays defeat Royals thanks to pitching and replay

ST. PETERSBURG — That the Rays defeated the Royals 1-0 on Monday night — Tampa Bay's major-league-leading 51st one-run game — is not surprising. What is a bit unusual is how they did it.With two outs and runners on first and third i...
Updated: 7 hours ago
Rays journal: Seminole’s Brett Phillips returns home

Rays journal: Seminole’s Brett Phillips returns home

ST. PETERSBURG — Brett Phillips played at Tropicana Field in 2012 when he was a senior at Seminole High and a member of Team Pinellas in the annual Hillsborough vs. Pinellas All-Star Game. He was just weeks away from being picked in the sixth r...
Updated: 7 hours ago
Who says preseason doesn’t count for Bucs?

Who says preseason doesn’t count for Bucs?

TAMPA — Monday was a beautiful day out at One Buc Place.Sunny. Blue skies. Hot, but not a thousand degrees like it has been in recent weeks around here.The Bucs were finally back home after spending most of the past week in Nashville. And despi...
Updated: 7 hours ago
Rodney Page’s takeaways from Monday’s Rays-Royals game

Rodney Page’s takeaways from Monday’s Rays-Royals game

Replay played a big role in the game. The Rays got their run in the second when an out call at first was overturned. Then in the fourth, Kevin Kiermaier was picked off second with no outs after a replay showed his hand came off the base.Ryan Yarbroug...
Updated: 7 hours ago