Saturday, November 17, 2018
News Roundup

Life sentence for Julian Ospina-Florez, Avila murderer

TAMPA — A jury Friday voted to spare the life of a 35-year-old man convicted of a double murder, recommending that he serve life in prison for gunning down his wealthy employer and her husband in 2012.

Although he had struggled to contain his emotions throughout the three-week trial, Julian Ospina-Florez barely registered the jury's recommendation.

In the gallery behind him, his mother clung to her youngest son and wept. Family members of the victims walked out quietly, later releasing a statement asking for privacy and saying they were "relieved that this chapter of our family tragedy has concluded and justice has been served."

Under state law, it fell to Hillsborough Circuit Judge Samantha Ward to decide whether to sentence Ospina-Florez to death or to follow the jury's recommendation, which she quickly did, sentencing him to life in prison without parole. Unlike in most other states, in Florida the jury's role is advisory, and the state does not require that it be unanimous in voting for a death sentence. A majority of seven jurors is sufficient to recommend execution.

For over a week, jurors listened as prosecutors laid out their case against Ospina-Florez, who they said was solely responsible for the shooting deaths of Debra Rivera, 55, and her husband, retired physician Dr. Hector Rivera, 76, at their mansion in Avila.

On Tuesday, the 12-member jury pronounced him guilty of two counts of first-degree murder.

Since then, prosecutors and the public defenders representing him have debated his fate, presenting the jury with testimonials about his character designed to sway their vote and, ultimately, the judge's decision.

Prosecutors, emphasizing the significant amount of planning that went into the killings, and the fact that there was more than one victim, argued that Ospina-Florez should join the four other men Hillsborough judges have sent to death row since 2013.

They detailed how Debra Rivera had tried to flee from her attacker with such urgency that her shoes left skid marks on the kitchen's tile floor. Cornered in a bathroom by her "trusted driver," as prosecutors referred to Ospina-Florez, she was shot three times — twice in the mouth. Her husband was found lying dead in the driveway, where he had also been repeatedly shot.

"The evidence supports the imposition of the death penalty, the law allows for it, and simple justice cries out for it," said Assistant State Attorney Jay Pruner.

But jurors ultimately rejected this argument, aligning with defense attorneys who said that while the Rivera's deaths were tragic, the death penalty is for "the worst of the worst" offenders, and Ospina-Florez plainly did not meet that standard.

Referring to the state's own time line of events, defense attorneys said that his attack on the couple was quick — at most, 10 minutes — and that the Riveras had not died a prolonged and suffering death. They argued that Ospina-Florez was lacking many of the traits associated with people who commit heinous crimes worthy of the death penalty: he had no criminal record, no history of drug or alcohol abuse, and was not afflicted by mental illness.

"He's a nice guy," said Assistant Public Defender Theda James. "He doesn't have the history of someone who deserves to die."

Contact Anna M. Phillips at [email protected] or (813) 226-3354. Follow her @annamphillips.

Comments
The end of the Bucs’ Dirk Koetter-Jameis Winston partnership

The end of the Bucs’ Dirk Koetter-Jameis Winston partnership

It's hard to imagine the head coach and the quarterback both back with the Bucs in 2019.
Updated: 3 hours ago
Sound-Smarter-Than-Your-Friends Guide to Buccaneers-Giants: How Tampa Bay can lose if it wins

Sound-Smarter-Than-Your-Friends Guide to Buccaneers-Giants: How Tampa Bay can lose if it wins

The Bucs are in a race, just not the one you hoped they would be in.
Updated: 4 hours ago
Football playoffs: Jefferson 34, Lakewood 23

Football playoffs: Jefferson 34, Lakewood 23

ST. PETERSBURG — Jefferson continues to prove that seedings don't matter in Class 5A. A week after upsetting top seed Hardee, the No. 8Dragons took down No. 4 seed Lakewood 34-23 in the region semifinals.Niko Duffey scored two first-half rushin...
Updated: 9 hours ago
Football playoffs: Bloomingdale 21, Palmetto 14

Football playoffs: Bloomingdale 21, Palmetto 14

VALRICO — In the offseason, Bloomingdale coach Max Warner told his players the goal was to play on Thanksgiving weekend.That left a lot of perplexed looks from the Bulls."They didn't know what that meant," Warner said.Bloomingdale had neve...
Updated: 9 hours ago
Football playoffs: Plant 39, Viera 18

Football playoffs: Plant 39, Viera 18

VIERA — Once again, the Plant Panthers proved they're the kind of team that can take a little momentum … and run you over with it.That was the case in Friday night's Class 7A, Region 2 semifinal as the Panthers rallied from an 18-10 halft...
Updated: 9 hours ago
Football playoffs: Seffner Christian 27, Carrollwood Day 16

Football playoffs: Seffner Christian 27, Carrollwood Day 16

DOVER – Isaiah Knowles connected with Christian Helms on a pair on 10-yard touchdown tosses as Seffner Christian defeated Carrollwood Day 27-16 on Friday, giving the Crusaders their first playoff win in school history. The win, a rematch o...
Updated: 9 hours ago

Sunday’s letters: Guardian ad litem advocates for neglected children

Sunday’s letters to the editor
Published: 11/17/18

Football playoffs: Nature Coast 17, Baker County 16

BROOKSVILLE — Nature Coast, an easy winner most of its past 10 games, really never had the need to attempt a field goal this season. Nor did the Sharks need to throw much, despite quarterback Fabian "2 Fabe" Burnett possessing a talented arm.Bu...
Updated: 9 hours ago

Football playoffs: Admiral Farragut 40, Cambridge Christian 14

ST. PETERSBURG — Admiral Farragut's Courtney Eubanks came out for his first home playoff game ready to play.Early in the first quarter, Eubanks had an interception on defense and followed that play with a touchdown on offense as the Blue Jacket...
Updated: 9 hours ago

Football playoffs: Citra North Marion 40, Zephyrhills 21

ZEPHYRHILLS — Zephyrhills' perfect season is imperfect now that it is over. A 40-21 loss to Citra North Marion in Friday night's Class 5A region semifinal ended the Bulldogs' season at 11-1. They were ousted in the second round for a second str...
Updated: 9 hours ago