Wednesday, September 19, 2018
News Roundup

Carlton: Is Hillsborough's new top prosecutor anti-death penalty? The answer might surprise you

The death penalty, and how we use it, is changing. Hey, it can happen, even in Florida.

Until recently, it was perfectly okay if only most people on a jury agreed that a killer should die. We have since come around to the idea that well, yes, perhaps unanimous is wiser given we're talking about taking a human life.

Meanwhile, a dramatic legal face-off is playing out between new Orlando-area state attorney Aramis Ayala — who refused to seek death for an accused cop killer, or anyone else for that matter — and Gov. Rick Scott, who promptly grabbed 23 death penalty cases away from her.

And here at home, newly elected Hillsborough State Attorney Andrew Warren has made clear that he believes the death penalty should be used for only "the most egregious cases, the worst of the worst." And that he believes this has not always been so.

So is Warren — if not another Ayala — at least a kindred spirit?

He is a former federal prosecutor who surprised a lot of people by ousting longtime State Attorney Mark Ober. Now courthouse lawyers, judges and cops are watching to see what kind of state attorney he turns out to be. And in the current climate, death cases are of keen interest.

After Ayala's stand, Warren and the rest of Florida's top prosecutors affirmed they would continue to seek death when appropriate. But he has also talked about the importance of an elected prosecutor's discretion.

Also interesting: Warren dropped the death penalty in the murder case against Carlos Rivas, citing his history of mental illness. Last week, Rivas was convicted and sentenced to life in prison for beating a homeless man to death in 2012.

This week, Warren confirmed the office will no longer seek death for Lawrence Robert Bongiovanni III, accused of hiding in a 7-Eleven bathroom before ambushing and repeatedly stabbing clerk Kenneth Lee Redding to death in 2013.

Bongiovanni's history of mental illness — reportedly in and out of hospitals since age 6 — and that he was 20 at the time of the slaying were factors, Warren told me this week.

Also worth noting: He says his office will not be using the threat of capital punishment to get a defendant to plead to life, a person's life not being "a bargaining chip."

So again: Is Warren's philosophy akin to Ayala's, except with a subtler, more defensible, slow drip method for avoiding death sentences?

The short answer: No.

The longer one is more considered.

Warren says his office is reviewing "from scratch" about 20 death penalty cases he inherited to make a fresh decision in each one. He calls a death sentence "the most serious and sobering component of our criminal justice system. The most important thing to me is that, as a society, we get it right."

In fact, he has already decided that death is appropriate for Steven Lorenzo, implicated in the horrific slayings of two men used as sex slaves. His office will also seek death for Keith Earl Davis, charged with murder in the death of nurse William Leslie McGoff.

Warren is still the new guy in a courthouse where lawyers and judges grew up together and police hold sway. But he seems more comfortable in the chair every day.

Comments
Top 5 at noon: Ron DeSantis and Andrew Gilium and how they differ on education; ‘Something fishy’ about a golf-course sale; and more

Top 5 at noon: Ron DeSantis and Andrew Gilium and how they differ on education; ‘Something fishy’ about a golf-course sale; and more

Here are the latest headlines and updates on tampabay.com.HOW ARE RON DESANTIS AND ANDREW GILLUM DIFFERENT? LOOK AT THEIR EDUCATION PLANS.What was once a personal dilemma for Gwen Graham — whether or not to publicly support the family company’s invo...
Updated: 15 minutes ago
Too many homeowners forced to tap home equity to pay for day-to-day expenses

Too many homeowners forced to tap home equity to pay for day-to-day expenses

Tapping home equity to pay for day-to-day expenses like groceries and utilities is a recipe for financial peril. It can work for a while, especially if home prices are rising. Eventually the spigot runs dry, bills pile up and your home can be lost to...
Updated: 27 minutes ago
Daniel Ruth: City owes Gonzmart and Princess Ulele more than a notice of code violation

Daniel Ruth: City owes Gonzmart and Princess Ulele more than a notice of code violation

This has to be height of bureaucratic pettiness, especially for a city whose track record in promoting quality public art falls somewhere between stick figures and finger puppets.Richard Gonzmart is a community treasure. As the force behind a number ...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Fitzmagic beer? Of course someone named a craft brew after Ryan Fitzpatrick

Fitzmagic beer? Of course someone named a craft brew after Ryan Fitzpatrick

The association between beards and brews is strong. Yes, craft beer lovers are a diverse and special group of men and women (don’t @ me on Twitter, beer people), but try visiting a local brewery and not finding at least one big, glorious beard ...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Sports Day Tampa Bay podcast: Why Blake Snell should win the AL Cy Young Award

Sports Day Tampa Bay podcast: Why Blake Snell should win the AL Cy Young Award

Rays pitcher Blake Snell becomes baseball's first 20-game winner and deserves to win the AL Cy Young Award, Rick Stroud says on today's podcast. Snell picks up the victory as the Rays  blank the Rangers to move 18 games above .500.Plus, Buc...
Updated: 1 hour ago
‘Something fishy’ about sale of a golf-course villa in Seminole

‘Something fishy’ about sale of a golf-course villa in Seminole

SEMINOLE — There were so many unusual aspects to the sale of a certain Seminole villa that it’s hard to know where to begin. Is it with the fact the villa sold for $100,000 despite a cash offer of $128,700? Is it that the buyer was a Realtor in the s...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Rays calling up Meadows, plus Hu, Milner, Pruitt but not Wong

Rays calling up Meadows, plus Hu, Milner, Pruitt but not Wong

With Triple-A Durham's season finally over after Tuesday's loss in the national championship game, the Rays are making four additional call-ups.The most interesting is OF Austin Meadows, the other prime piece, along with RHP Tyler Glasnow, acquired f...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Valet parking? A concierge? Midtown Tampa outlines plans for an amenity-rich office building

Valet parking? A concierge? Midtown Tampa outlines plans for an amenity-rich office building

TAMPA — A sudden boomlet in premium office space is getting boomier as developers detail their plans for the first of three office buildings planned at Midtown Tampa, a $500 million mixed-use development near Interstate 275 and N Dale Mabry Highway.M...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Watch this Florida man legally drive a motorized jet ski

Watch this Florida man legally drive a motorized jet ski

Jacksonville has become known for unique motorists as of late, with one seen lounging on a motorcycle while driving and another spotted driving a lawn mower on Interstate 95. Just when you think you've seen it all, however, a Jacksonville man was sp...
Updated: 1 hour ago
For starters: Rays at Rangers, playing for something

For starters: Rays at Rangers, playing for something

After the excitement of LHP Blake Snell earning his majors-most milestone 20th victory in Tuesday's 4-0 win over the Rangers, the Rays turn their attention back to a suddenly smaller number, the 5 1/2 games they trail the A's for the final AL playoff...
Updated: 1 hour ago