Saturday, April 21, 2018
News Roundup

Carlton: USF football and the judge who judged (w/video)

Hillsborough County Judge Margaret Taylor, I feel your pain. I do.

Like you, I am a proud alum of the University of South Florida (Go Bulls!) Like you, I graduated pre-football. I spent years trudging to friends' games in Tallahassee, Gainesville and Miami, jealous of their traditions and their fun. (Though I never did get that whole painting one's face orange and blue thing.)

Maybe like me, judge, you were happy when we finally got a football team of our own. And all that comes with it, as it turns out.

I'm betting you too were outraged at the latest allegation of a sexual battery by a college athlete, this time by a player who wears green and gold — charges common enough on college campuses these days that people act like they come with the territory.

But your honor, here is where we part ways.

I'm an alum who can say whatever I want about my alma mater. You? You're a judge bound by judicial rules of fairness and impartiality that are critical if the justice system has a prayer of working.

This week, USF junior defensive end LaDarrius Jackson was arrested on charges of sexual battery and false imprisonment. He stands accused of forcing a woman he knew into a sex act in her dorm room.

So there was Jackson in jail scrubs and handcuffs Wednesday for what's generally a routine, even dull first-appearance proceeding to set bail — the first small step on a long road toward however a criminal case will one day end.

Nothing routine about this one.

RELATED STORY Judge rips into USF's LaDarrius Jackson, coach Charlie Strong

The judge told the accused that if the allegations are true, his behavior was "nothing short of outrageous." She said she was never ashamed of being a USF graduate until now. "Embarrassed and ashamed, Mr. Jackson," she said, in case you were wondering how she felt.

Then she took on new Bulls coach Charlie Strong. She referenced the recent arrest of a player accused in a violent road rage incident and implored Strong to "think long and hard" about whether he fit at USF "before any other members of this community have to suffer at the hands of one of your players." (Here's a recounting of Coach Strong's actual record on discipline .)

Video of the judge's dressing-down went viral. It caught the eye of ESPN and USA Today, among others. In the ensuing chatter, some people wondered if the judge had been reading prepared remarks as judges sometimes do at sentencing hearings. You know, after a defendant has had his day in court.

Judge Taylor declined to discuss the matter with the Times.

Now it's one thing for a bunch of crusty alums to sit around over beers lamenting, arguing and opining about the state of their school — particularly with charges as serious as these. It's quite another for a judge to sound like she's pre-judging, even if she softens it with a few "if-trues."

RELATED STORY USF football coach Charlie Strong's record on discipline defended

Perhaps sensing backlash — Public Defender Julie Holt's office planned to ask for Taylor to be disqualified and hoped to revisit Jackson's $102,500 bail with a new judge — Taylor voluntarily disqualified herself from the case Thursday.

The bottom line: Every person who gets arrested — the stone cold killers, the wrongly accused, the overcharged, the deserving of a break, the blatantly guilty and everyone in between — has a right to be presumed innocent until and unless proven guilty.

And the right not to be judged on defendants who came before him.

And the right to at least the appearance that the powerful person presiding is unbiased — no matter how weary or outraged we may be about the kind of allegations we think we've heard before.

That's at the very core of the privilege of wearing the robe — one that is pointedly and neutrally black and not green and gold.

Sue Carlton can be reached at [email protected]

Comments
Man, 20, arrested in killing of Durant High football player

Man, 20, arrested in killing of Durant High football player

Deputies arrested a man late Friday they say shot and killed Durant High School football player Grover Wills.Samuel Morrissey Jr., 20, was being held without bail Saturday at the Hillsborough County jail and faces a second-degree murder charge, accor...
Updated: 2 hours ago
Cops used dead man's finger in attempt to unlock his phone

Cops used dead man's finger in attempt to unlock his phone

Most people agree what the Largo detectives did at the funeral home was legal. What they diverge on is whether it was appropriate.
Updated: 2 hours ago
For starters: Rays vs. Twins, with a familiar look

For starters: Rays vs. Twins, with a familiar look

Not that Friday's game went as planned, but the Rays ended up with an 8-7 10-inning win, and they're going to trot out the same lineup tonight in hopes of doing it again.RELATED: Rays find a way to prevailLHP Blake Snell will be on the mound for the ...
Updated: 2 hours ago
A Florida school shooting suspect charged with terrorism says ‘sorry’ to injured student

A Florida school shooting suspect charged with terrorism says ‘sorry’ to injured student

The young man in a white jail jumpsuit, handcuffed and shackled, looked past the throng of reporters pointing microphones toward his face, barely opening his mouth as he answered questions."I shot through the door," he said, looking at a female repor...
Updated: 3 hours ago
Man who attacked woman and stole her shorts arrested, deputies say

Man who attacked woman and stole her shorts arrested, deputies say

Deputies arrested a man they said tackled a woman in February and removed her shorts before fleeing.Robert Mark Hembree Jr., 31, was arrested late Friday. He faces charges of sexual battery and petit theft.PREVIOUS COVERAGE: Detectives seek man who a...
Updated: 3 hours ago
Romano: Okay, now who sounds like a hysterical teen talking about guns?

Romano: Okay, now who sounds like a hysterical teen talking about guns?

The writer of the letter sounds hysterical. Perhaps a little desperate. And maybe that’s just who Marion Hammer is these days.Most of the world knows her as the take-no-prisoners maven of the National Rifle Association who directs Florida politicians...
Updated: 4 hours ago
Dade City man killed in early morning hit-and-run, police say

Dade City man killed in early morning hit-and-run, police say

A Pasco County man was struck and killed in an apparent hit-and-run early Saturday, police said.Thomas Michael Burdeshaw, 53, who lived on Sundance Drive in Dade City, was hit about 1:45 a.m. on the 36000 block of Blanton Road, police said.Witnesses ...
Updated: 5 hours ago
Some people are paying for cuddles. And it’s not what you might think.

Some people are paying for cuddles. And it’s not what you might think.

When Samantha Hess’s marriage ended five years ago, she felt she was lacking a basic human need: Physical touch. As a woman in her late 20s living in Portland, Oregon, she found plenty of men interested in dating, but sexual contact was not what she ...
Updated: 5 hours ago
Police searching for person who shot a man to death in Largo

Police searching for person who shot a man to death in Largo

CLEARWATER — Police are looking for a person who shot and killed a man late Friday at the Melrose on the Bay apartments on Bolesta Road. Ricardo Guzman, 32, called 911 just before midnight and told the operator he had been shot, said Lt. Randall Chan...
Updated: 5 hours ago
Motorcyclist dies after crash on Memorial Highway

Motorcyclist dies after crash on Memorial Highway

TAMPA — A motorcyclist driving north on Memorial Highway died after he crashed into a guard rail late Friday, police said."The man failed to negotiate a curve in the road and struck a guard rail," said Lt. Brett Owen. "No other vehicle was involved i...
Updated: 6 hours ago