Make us your home page
Instagram

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Carlton: USF football and the judge who judged (w/video)

Hillsborough County Judge Margaret Taylor, I feel your pain. I do.

Like you, I am a proud alum of the University of South Florida (Go Bulls!) Like you, I graduated pre-football. I spent years trudging to friends' games in Tallahassee, Gainesville and Miami, jealous of their traditions and their fun. (Though I never did get that whole painting one's face orange and blue thing.)

Maybe like me, judge, you were happy when we finally got a football team of our own. And all that comes with it, as it turns out.

I'm betting you too were outraged at the latest allegation of a sexual battery by a college athlete, this time by a player who wears green and gold — charges common enough on college campuses these days that people act like they come with the territory.

But your honor, here is where we part ways.

I'm an alum who can say whatever I want about my alma mater. You? You're a judge bound by judicial rules of fairness and impartiality that are critical if the justice system has a prayer of working.

This week, USF junior defensive end LaDarrius Jackson was arrested on charges of sexual battery and false imprisonment. He stands accused of forcing a woman he knew into a sex act in her dorm room.

So there was Jackson in jail scrubs and handcuffs Wednesday for what's generally a routine, even dull first-appearance proceeding to set bail — the first small step on a long road toward however a criminal case will one day end.

Nothing routine about this one.

RELATED STORY Judge rips into USF's LaDarrius Jackson, coach Charlie Strong

The judge told the accused that if the allegations are true, his behavior was "nothing short of outrageous." She said she was never ashamed of being a USF graduate until now. "Embarrassed and ashamed, Mr. Jackson," she said, in case you were wondering how she felt.

Then she took on new Bulls coach Charlie Strong. She referenced the recent arrest of a player accused in a violent road rage incident and implored Strong to "think long and hard" about whether he fit at USF "before any other members of this community have to suffer at the hands of one of your players." (Here's a recounting of Coach Strong's actual record on discipline .)

Video of the judge's dressing-down went viral. It caught the eye of ESPN and USA Today, among others. In the ensuing chatter, some people wondered if the judge had been reading prepared remarks as judges sometimes do at sentencing hearings. You know, after a defendant has had his day in court.

Judge Taylor declined to discuss the matter with the Times.

Now it's one thing for a bunch of crusty alums to sit around over beers lamenting, arguing and opining about the state of their school — particularly with charges as serious as these. It's quite another for a judge to sound like she's pre-judging, even if she softens it with a few "if-trues."

RELATED STORY USF football coach Charlie Strong's record on discipline defended

Perhaps sensing backlash — Public Defender Julie Holt's office planned to ask for Taylor to be disqualified and hoped to revisit Jackson's $102,500 bail with a new judge — Taylor voluntarily disqualified herself from the case Thursday.

The bottom line: Every person who gets arrested — the stone cold killers, the wrongly accused, the overcharged, the deserving of a break, the blatantly guilty and everyone in between — has a right to be presumed innocent until and unless proven guilty.

And the right not to be judged on defendants who came before him.

And the right to at least the appearance that the powerful person presiding is unbiased — no matter how weary or outraged we may be about the kind of allegations we think we've heard before.

That's at the very core of the privilege of wearing the robe — one that is pointedly and neutrally black and not green and gold.

Sue Carlton can be reached at carlton@tampabay.com.

Carlton: USF football and the judge who judged (w/video) 05/05/17 [Last modified: Friday, May 5, 2017 6:20am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times

    

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

Loading...
  1. These two documents illustrate how Florida has made it harder to access inspection reports of nursing homes, heavily censoring what the public can see. In the foreground is a document obtained from a federal agency that details the findings of a Feb. 2016 inspection at the Rehabilitation Center at Hollywood Hills, where 10 patients died after Hurricane Irma. Behind it is the state's version of the same document, showing how it has been redacted before being released to the public. [Miami Herald]
  2. Amber Alert canceled after Bradenton siblings found in Alabama

    Public Safety

    An Amber Alert was canceled early Friday morning for four Bradenton siblings who were taken by their mother, who authorities said does not have custody of the children.

    An Amber Alert has been issued for four Bradenton siblings who were taken by their mother, who does not have custody of the children. [Florida Department of Law Enforcement]

  3. Cue the Scott Frost to Nebraska speculation

    Blogs

    Nebraska shook up the college sports world Thursday afternoon when it fired athletic director Shawn Eichorst.

    And that should scare UCF fans.

  4. Oh, Florida! Irma's gone, but she left behind plenty of lessons for us

    Columns

    I don't want to make light of the misery and death that Hurricane Irma inflicted on Florida this month. A lot of it was ugly, and some of it was downright criminal. We saw greed and pettiness on display, and it brought illness and death.

    Tampa Bay Times staff writer Craig Pittman.