Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Charges reduced in Clearwater DUI death case because of sudden acceleration in Toyotas

Jonathan Grinsted, 53, received 12 months probation in the DUI case.

Jonathan Grinsted, 53, received 12 months probation in the DUI case.

CLEARWATER — On a summer night nearly three years ago, the roar of a racing engine reverberated on Clearwater Beach's Mandalay Avenue, and Jonathan Grinsted's Toyota Land Cruiser zoomed up onto the sidewalk, smashing into an office and killing a woman who was sitting on the curb.

Ashley Boyle, 44, a lifelong Clearwater resident, was sitting there with a friend to escape the rain.

It seemed likely that Grinsted, then 51, would spend many years in prison because of the crash. Tests showed his blood alcohol level was 0.14, well over the 0.08 level at which drivers are presumed impaired. He was arrested on a charge of DUI-manslaughter, a felony that carries a possible sentence of 15 years in prison.

But Thursday, in an unusual move, prosecutors allowed Grin­sted to plead no contest to a greatly reduced charge of misdemeanor DUI. Instead of prison, he will serve 12 months probation.

What makes this case different from so many others involving drunken driving and death?

Defense attorney Denis de Vlaming gave this answer: sudden acceleration problems in Toyotas.

The issue led to widespread news coverage in recent years as complaints mounted about Toyotas accelerating unexpectedly. It culminated last year when the auto giant agreed to a $1 billion deal to settle hundreds of lawsuits.

Grinsted did not dispute that he was intoxicated at the time of the crash. But his drinking was not the cause of the accident, de Vlaming maintained.

"If he was stone sober, this would have happened," de Vlaming said. "He individually as a person did not cause this accident."

De Vlaming explained the case this way:

Grinsted's Land Cruiser previously had problems with sudden acceleration. The year before, it accelerated suddenly and smashed through the garage door at his home.

Grinsted had the SUV fixed, but another time a warning light came on the dashboard concerning the acceleration. He took it in for repairs, but the problem seemed to come and go.

On a Sunday evening in July 2010, Grinstead got into the SUV, which he had parked near 604 Mandalay Ave.

Nearby, Boyle was sitting on the curb with a friend, after an afternoon on the beach. They had ducked under a nearby awning to get out of the rain.

Witnesses said they heard the Toyota's engine racing. Grinsted would later say "the car took off, it just took off," veering onto the sidewalk and striking Boyle, de Vlaming said.

After the crash, de Vlaming hired a forensic engineer to investigate. With a master mechanic and an expert brought in by the State Attorney's Office, they dismantled and examined the "throttle control module," and discovered problems that could lead to unusual acceleration.

Assistant State Attorney Holly Grissinger said prosecutors at first rejected the theory that sudden acceleration caused the accident. But as the criminal case progressed, so did the civil cases against Toyota. Toyota eventually issued recall notices related to that problem in the very same type of SUV Grinsted was driving.

That made it impossible for prosecutors to prove the cause of the crash was "the defendant's intoxication versus the unintended acceleration of the faulty vehicle," Grissinger said. In fact, similar decisions have been made in other criminal cases around the county, she said.

Both lawyers said to prove the charge of DUI manslaughter, it would not be enough to prove that Grinsted was driving drunk. It also would be necessary to prove his drunkenness caused the accident, as opposed to some other cause, such as a malfunctioning vehicle.

A friend of Boyle's spoke at the plea hearing on Thursday, displeased with the result. He could not be reached afterward.

Charges reduced in Clearwater DUI death case because of sudden acceleration in Toyotas 04/11/13 [Last modified: Thursday, April 11, 2013 9:20pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Search for missing Army helicopter crew suspended in Hawaii


    HONOLULU — Officials have suspended the search for five Army soldiers who were aboard a helicopter that crashed during offshore training in Hawaii last week.

    Water safety officials hand over possible debris from an Army UH-60 Black Hawk helicopter crash to military personnel stationed at a command center in a harbor, Wednesday in Haleiwa, Hawaii, a day after. an Army helicopter with five on board crashed several miles off Oahu's North Shore. Officials  suspended the search for five Army soldiers in a helicopter crash during offshore training in Hawaii on Monday. [Associated Press]
  2. Rubio praises Trump for 'excellent' speech on Afghanistan


    Sen. Marco Rubio praised President Donald Trump's "excellent" speech on Afghanistan. Sen. Bill Nelson was less effusive but agreed with the goal.

  3. Gov. Rick Scott blasts report of shifting words on Charlottesville


    Gov. Rick Scott, one of the most scripted politicians in modern Florida history, said Monday that "both sides” bear blame for Charlottesville.

  4. Record $417 million awarded in lawsuit linking baby powder to cancer


    LOS ANGELES — A Los Angeles jury on Monday ordered Johnson & Johnson to pay a record $417 million to a hospitalized woman who claimed in a lawsuit that the talc in the company's iconic baby powder causes ovarian cancer when applied regularly for feminine hygiene.

    A bottle of Johnson's baby powder is displayed. On Monday, Aug. 21, 2017, a Los Angeles County Superior Court spokeswoman confirmed that a jury has ordered Johnson & Johnson to pay $417 million in a case to a woman who claimed in a lawsuit that the talc in the company's iconic baby powder causes ovarian cancer when applied regularly for feminine hygiene. [Associated Press]
  5. Search under way for missing sailors; Navy chief orders inquiry


    SINGAPORE — The U.S. Navy ordered a broad investigation Monday into the performance and readiness of the Pacific-based 7th Fleet after the USS John S. McCain collided with an oil tanker in Southeast Asian waters, leaving 10 U.S. sailors missing and others injured.

    Damage is visible as the USS John S. McCain steers toward Singapore’s naval base on Monday.