Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Child abuse charges are fleeting in Pasco County DUI cases

NEW PORT RICHEY — Alicia Idadawn Kirsch's car swung like a pendulum across the blacktop lanes of U.S. 19, just after 1 a.m. Nov. 22. A deputy, suspecting she was drunk, pulled her over. A breath test showed her blood-alcohol level at three times the threshold for a DUI arrest.

In the car with her, according to her arrest report, were two small children, ages 2 and 4.

Kirsch, 25, was arrested on charges of DUI and child abuse.

When Cathy Dothe was pulled over Oct. 9 on U.S. 19 with four kids in her car, her blood-alcohol level was 0.29 — also far above the 0.08 threshold for a DUI arrest — according to her arrest report. She was charged with DUI and child neglect.

Four other arrests examined by the Times from the last few months arose from the same circumstances and yielded the same charges.

But in each case, the State Attorney's Office declined to pursue the child neglect and child abuse charges, which are felonies, instead sending the cases to misdemeanor court to prosecute the women only for DUI.

Mike Halkitis, chief of the west Pasco division of the State Attorney's Office, said in each case just the act of driving while impaired with a child in the car did not amount to neglect or abuse that a prosecutor could prove beyond a reasonable doubt.

"We have to prove a serious risk of personal injury or mental injury to the child. That's neglect," he said. "Legally (these cases) are not sufficient."

Halkitis said that the danger to the children does not go ignored. Arresting officers are supposed to call the state's child abuse hotline. Halkitis said his office notifies the Department of Children and Families, which can do its own investigation into the children's safety and even seek to have the children taken into state custody.

He also said that Florida law provides a sentence enhancement against people who are caught impaired with a child in the car: a $1,000 fine.

"Hopefully that will cure the problem of the parent being just plain stupid and putting the kids in the car with alcohol," Halkitis said. "But stupidity doesn't equate to neglect."

• • •

A child abuse or child neglect charge triggers alarms in the system. DCF gets involved. The Sheriff's Office's child protection investigation unit does, too.

That's reason enough for deputies to continue making those arrests, even if the charges get dropped later in the process, the Sheriff's Office said.

"Generally speaking, if someone is driving under the influence with children in their car, chances are pretty good that child neglect charges will be added," said Doug Tobin, spokesman for the Sheriff's Office. The charges could be more serious if a child is injured in a car accident.

Laws protecting children's privacy prohibit officials from speaking about any cases specifically. That's also why law enforcement reports don't denote the relationships between the children and the defendants.

The arresting deputy calls the abuse hotline, which puts the case on the radar of the Sheriff's Office's child protection investigation unit.

DCF gets involved too. These investigations are separate from the criminal one and the burden of proof is different. A case aimed at removing a child from a dangerous home can still move forward even if the child neglect criminal case stops, said DCF regional director Nick Cox.

"They (prosecutors) are looking at a violation of a criminal law with the highest burden in the legal system," Cox said. "We're looking at the safety and best interests of the child with different standards of proof. We may still be able to prove ours."

He said it may be more difficult to proceed with a dependency case without the underlying criminal charge, but it's not impossible.

"We still can go forward and often do," Cox said.

• • •

Lena Maki struck another car while driving a child to Chasco Elementary School around 9:30 a.m. Feb. 1. A Florida Highway Patrol report said the child appeared traumatized by the crash and was taken out of school for the day.

Maki, the report said, had burn marks on her fingers — telltale signs of smoking drugs. She nodded off while talking to authorities and urinated in her pants when she got out of her car, the report said.

She didn't perform field sobriety exercises because she couldn't stand on her own, the report said.

The trooper charged her with DUI, DUI with property damage, leaving the scene of an accident and child neglect.

Her case is pending in the courts. The public defender was appointed to represent her. The state is prosecuting Maki, 39, for DUI, leaving the scene of an accident involving injury, reckless driving with property damage or injury and two counts of leaving the scene of a crash with property damage.

The child neglect charge was dropped.

Molly Moorhead can be reached at or (727) 869-6245.

Kids in car, but no abuse or neglect charges

Cathy Dothe, 46, of Hudson

Pulled over Oct. 9, 2009, on U.S. 19 with four kids in her pickup, one riding in the bed. Her blood-alcohol level measured 0.29, according to sheriff's reports.

Charges: DUI (her third), four counts child neglect

Outcome: DUI case is pending. All child neglect charges dropped.

Phyllis Taylor, 50, of Whitleyville, Tenn.

Two deputies investigating a domestic dispute on Villa Rosa Drive in Holiday on Oct. 14 saw a blue Mazda pull up. An 8-year-old climbed out of the back. Authorities said Taylor, who was driving, had booze on her breath, her eyes were glassy and she slurred when she talked. Her blood-alcohol level tested above 0.17.

Charges: DUI, child negelct

Outcome: Pleaded no contest to DUI, sentenced to a year of probation, had her license revoked for a year, 50 hours of community service, monetary fines. Child neglect charge dropped.

Karen Hanratty, 27, of New Port Richey

Pulled over Nov. 17 while driving 69 mph on U.S. 19, almost hitting other cars. An 8-year-old was in the car, according to police reports. The officer noted Hanratty was disoriented and failed field sobriety tests, but her blood-alcohol level registered zero. The officer concluded she was under the influence of drugs.

Charges: DUI, child abuse

Outcome: DUI is pending. Child abuse charge dropped.

Alicia Idadawn Kirsch, 25, of Jacksonville

Pulled over Nov. 22 after police saw her swerving on U.S. 19 with a 4-year-old and 2-year-old in the car. Police say she failed field sobriety tests and her blood-alcohol level measured 0.233 and 0.216.

Charges: DUI, child abuse

Outcome: Pleaded no contest to DUI, sentenced to a year of probation, had her license revoked for six months, 50 hours of community service, DUI school and monetary fines. Child abuse charge dropped.

Jaime Tyson, a.k.a. Jaime Luby, 42, of Hudson

Pulled over after striking a guardrail on East Road Nov. 26 with two children in the car. She failed field sobriety tests, according to a Highway Patrol report, and acknowledged being on methadone, which is used to treat withdrawal symptoms from narcotics.

Charges: DUI with property damage, child abuse

Outcome: Pleaded no contest to DUI, sentenced to a year of probation, license revoked for six months, DUI school, car impounded for 10 days, monetary fines. Child abuse charge dropped.

Lena Maki, 39, of Port Richey

Struck another car while driving a child to Chasco Elementary School about 9:30 a.m. Feb. 1. Maki had burn marks on her fingers, glassy eyes and dried saliva in the corners of her mouth, according to highway patrol reports. She could not perform field sobriety exercises and fell asleep on the way to jail.

Charges: DUI, DUI with property damage, leaving the scene of an accident and child neglect.

Outcome: DUI and traffic charges, including leaving the scene of a crash involving injury, are pending in felony court. Child neglect charge dropped.

Child abuse charges are fleeting in Pasco County DUI cases 03/13/10 [Last modified: Saturday, March 13, 2010 2:02pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Senate GOP set to release health-care bill (w/video)


    WASHINGTON -— Senate Republicans on Thursday plan to release a health-care bill that would curtail federal Medicaid funding, repeal taxes on the wealthy and eliminate funding for Planned Parenthood as part of an effort to fulfill a years-long promise to undo Barack Obama's signature health-care law.

    From left, Uplift Executive Director Heidi Mansir, of Gardiner, Maine, former West Virginia State Rep. Denise Campbell, Elkins, W. Va., University of Alaska-Anchorage student Moira Pyhala of Soldotna, Alaska, and National Farmers Union President Roger Johnson appear before Democratic senators holding a hearing about how the GOP health care bill could hurt rural Americans, at the Capitol in Washington, Wednesday, June 21, 2017. Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell was expected to push for a vote next week on the legislation, which would eliminate much of Obama's 2010 overhaul and leave government with a diminished role in providing coverage and helping people afford it. [Associated Press]
  2. Pasco fire station reopens after hundreds of bats forced crews out

    Human Interest

    Fire crews have returned to a Hudson fire station nearly two weeks after they were forced out by possibly thousands of bats.

    Fire crews returned to Station 39 in Hudson on June 21, 2017, nearly twoo weeks after the building was closed due to a rat infestation. [Times files]
  3. Church of England head says it 'colluded with' sex abuse


    LONDON — The Church of England "colluded" with and helped to hide the long-term sexual abuse of young men by one of its former bishops, the head of the church said Thursday.

  4. Looking Back: St. Petersburg does the Calypso with Jacques Cousteau (July 15, 1975)


    This story appeared in the pages of the St. Petersburg Times on July 15, 1975. What follows is the text of the original story, interspersed with photos of the event taken by Times staff photographer Weaver Tripp.

    Jacques Cousteau (center), Sen. John T. Ware, R-St. Petersburg (left) and an unidentified man (right) speak to the media about potentially moving the Cousteau Society to the city of St. Petersburg.

TIMES | Weaver Tripp
  5. Hernando commissioners question sheriff's accounting of federal inmate dollars

    Local Government

    BROOKSVILLE — As Hernando County Sheriff Al Nienhuis and his staff presented his proposed 2017-18 budget earlier this month, county Commissioner Steve Champion threw out an unexpected question.

    Sheriff Al Nienhuis and the county fought over his department’s budget last year.