Wednesday, December 13, 2017
News Roundup

Cortnee Brantley pretrial motion seeks evenhanded justice

Episodes on Law and Order often have this dramatic moment that must make real lawyers roll their eyes.

The bad guy's been arrested, the trial is set, but wait — here comes the defense lawyer, oozing up to prosecutors with an Important Document in hand.

And they recoil from the piece of paper as if he is trying to give them a dead rat.

"What's this?" the prosecutors say, suspicious, shocked, angry — as if pre-trial motions to dismiss, or to keep out certain evidence, or to try the case without a jury, aren't part of the regular road to trial.

Ah, courtroom drama.

But even in the real, workaday world of your local courthouse can come pretrial maneuverings that can make all the difference when it comes to actual justice — messy, imperfect and unsatisfying as that justice may be.

As in, the emotional, tenuous federal case against Cortnee Brantley, soon to be retried.

No question, Brantley was in the thick of it that summer night in 2010 when a Tampa police officer pulled her over because her Toyota didn't have a tag.

After police checked out her boyfriend, Dontae Morris, in the passenger seat, investigators say, Morris opened fire rather than go to jail on what turned out to be a bad warrant.

Officers David Curtis and Jeffrey Kocab were killed, a horrifying scene captured on dashboard video camera. The gunman ran. Brantley drove away.

And there is no law on the books requiring a person to be a decent human being.

Today Morris is in jail, awaiting trial and facing the death penalty. But a lot of people angry at the violence and the pointlessness of what happened that night wanted to see her charged, too.

And she was. The feds came up with an unusual charge of "misprision of a felony," an obscure crime of failing to report that Morris was a felon in possession of a gun and ammunition. It is a charge so odd the jury that heard the case last month sent out several questions about it while deliberating before they deadlocked without a verdict.

It's also notable that U.S. District Judge James Moody himself had previously dismissed the case, saying he didn't see evidence that Brantley had actively concealed anything. An appeals court overturned him.

So, about that recent pre-trial motion.

Brantley's attorney, Grady Irvin, told the judge last week he wanted to try the case next time around with no jury, meaning the judge alone decides. Irvin cited publicity.

Here's another good reason: Separating grief, outrage and emotion, however understandable, from right and wrong. Overreaching for a criminal charge versus the limits of the law.

For a lot of us it would be a test to sit in that jury box and see that video of the two men who died and not want to hold anyone connected responsible.

Judges, on the other hand, we expect to be evenhanded and unemotional.

But, as lawyers like to say, both in real life and on TV, the point is moot.

Federal prosecutors had to agree to a non-jury trial for this to happen, and why would they, since it is their job to convict her?

And so Brantley will face a jury again.

Too bad even hard justice isn't easy, like on TV.

Comments
The Bucsí problem isnít how they finish; itís how they start

The Bucsí problem isnít how they finish; itís how they start

For the second straight week, the Buccaneers had the ball in the final minutes of a tie game.For the second straight week, they could not finish.As disappointing as that might be, they have a larger problem, and one that has existed all season: The B...
Updated: 3 hours ago
Lightning opens road trip with shutout of Blues

Lightning opens road trip with shutout of Blues

ST. LOUIS ó This showdown was supposed to be about the best team in the East versus the best in the West. In reality, the Lightningís 3-0 win over the Blues on Tuesday night pretty much came down to this:Andrei Vasilevskiy is one of the best goalies ...
Updated: 3 hours ago

Lottery resultsLottery numbers drawn after 9 p.m. are no longer available by our deadlines. For results, go to tampabay.com/lottery.Pick 2, 3, 4, 5Tues., Dec. 12, midday:90 578 4984e_SRit30459Tues., Dec. 12, evening:85 659 2558e_SRit95745Fantasy 5Tue...
Updated: 3 hours ago

High school scoreboard for Dec. 12

Tuesdayís scoreboardGirls soccerCountryside 5, Tarpon Springs 0Palm Harbor U. 8, Alonso 0Boys soccerShorecrest 2, Indian Rocks Chr. 0Palm Harbor U. 3, Alonso 0Girls basketballNortheast 65, Dixie Hollins 25...
Updated: 4 hours ago
Defendant asks jurors: Do I look like Charles Manson?

Defendant asks jurors: Do I look like Charles Manson?

LARGO ó Daniel Richards, on trial in the murder of his 83-year-old mother, began his own criminal defense on Tuesday by asking a few questions to the pool of prospective jurors."If you were accused of killing your mother, would you want to represent ...
Updated: 4 hours ago
Career Q&A: Two bosses who donít care for each other

Career Q&A: Two bosses who donít care for each other

Q: I seem to be caught between two high-level managers who really donít like each other. One is a director, the other is a vice president, and I am an assistant to both. Whenever the director stops by my desk to chat, she makes critical remarks about...
Updated: 4 hours ago
St. Pete losing two assistant police chiefs; one will join Rays

St. Pete losing two assistant police chiefs; one will join Rays

ST. PETERSBURG ó Two assistant police chiefs are stepping down next month, leaving two of the three second-in-command jobs vacant at the St. Petersburg Police Department.Assistant Chief Jim Previtera announced this week that he will resign from the d...
Updated: 5 hours ago

Winter meetings journal: Rays add more infield depth, claim it isnít prelude to a trade

LAKE BUENA VISTA ó The Rays on Tuesday adding their third infielder in the past two weeks would sure look like a precursor to trading front-liners such as 3B Evan Longoria or 2B Brad Miller.But GM Erik Neander insisted that was not the case and that ...
Updated: 5 hours ago
Tax package would lower top tax rate for wealthy Americans

Tax package would lower top tax rate for wealthy Americans

WASHINGTON ó Congressional Republicans on Tuesday rushed toward a deal on a massive tax package that would reduce the top tax rate for wealthy Americans to 37 percent and slash the corporate rate to a level slightly higher than what businesses and co...
Updated: 5 hours ago
GMs-turned-pundits believe now may be the time for Rays to sell

GMs-turned-pundits believe now may be the time for Rays to sell

LAKE BUENA VISTA ó The Rays have been doing a lot of talking, making another small deal Tuesday while still working toward bigger ones of a still-being-determined degree.And there have been a lot of baseball people at the winter meetings talking abou...
Updated: 5 hours ago