Make us your home page
Instagram

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Cortnee Brantley pretrial motion seeks evenhanded justice

Episodes on Law and Order often have this dramatic moment that must make real lawyers roll their eyes.

The bad guy's been arrested, the trial is set, but wait — here comes the defense lawyer, oozing up to prosecutors with an Important Document in hand.

And they recoil from the piece of paper as if he is trying to give them a dead rat.

"What's this?" the prosecutors say, suspicious, shocked, angry — as if pre-trial motions to dismiss, or to keep out certain evidence, or to try the case without a jury, aren't part of the regular road to trial.

Ah, courtroom drama.

But even in the real, workaday world of your local courthouse can come pretrial maneuverings that can make all the difference when it comes to actual justice — messy, imperfect and unsatisfying as that justice may be.

As in, the emotional, tenuous federal case against Cortnee Brantley, soon to be retried.

No question, Brantley was in the thick of it that summer night in 2010 when a Tampa police officer pulled her over because her Toyota didn't have a tag.

After police checked out her boyfriend, Dontae Morris, in the passenger seat, investigators say, Morris opened fire rather than go to jail on what turned out to be a bad warrant.

Officers David Curtis and Jeffrey Kocab were killed, a horrifying scene captured on dashboard video camera. The gunman ran. Brantley drove away.

And there is no law on the books requiring a person to be a decent human being.

Today Morris is in jail, awaiting trial and facing the death penalty. But a lot of people angry at the violence and the pointlessness of what happened that night wanted to see her charged, too.

And she was. The feds came up with an unusual charge of "misprision of a felony," an obscure crime of failing to report that Morris was a felon in possession of a gun and ammunition. It is a charge so odd the jury that heard the case last month sent out several questions about it while deliberating before they deadlocked without a verdict.

It's also notable that U.S. District Judge James Moody himself had previously dismissed the case, saying he didn't see evidence that Brantley had actively concealed anything. An appeals court overturned him.

So, about that recent pre-trial motion.

Brantley's attorney, Grady Irvin, told the judge last week he wanted to try the case next time around with no jury, meaning the judge alone decides. Irvin cited publicity.

Here's another good reason: Separating grief, outrage and emotion, however understandable, from right and wrong. Overreaching for a criminal charge versus the limits of the law.

For a lot of us it would be a test to sit in that jury box and see that video of the two men who died and not want to hold anyone connected responsible.

Judges, on the other hand, we expect to be evenhanded and unemotional.

But, as lawyers like to say, both in real life and on TV, the point is moot.

Federal prosecutors had to agree to a non-jury trial for this to happen, and why would they, since it is their job to convict her?

And so Brantley will face a jury again.

Too bad even hard justice isn't easy, like on TV.

Cortnee Brantley pretrial motion seeks evenhanded justice 08/28/12 [Last modified: Wednesday, August 29, 2012 6:50am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times

    

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

Loading...
  1. NFL commissioner calls Trump remarks on national anthem 'divisive'

    Bucs

    HUNTSVILLE, Ala. — The commissioner of the National Football League says President Donald Trump's comments about players who kneel during the national anthem are "divisive" and show an "unfortunate …

    President Donald Trump walks off the stage after he speaks at campaign rally in support of Sen. Luther Strange, Friday, Sept. 22, 2017, in Huntsville, Ala. [Associated Press]
  2. Forecast: Tampa Bay's first fall weekend brings scattered showers

    Weather

    It may officially be fall, but Tampa Bay won't have any cooler temperatures this weekend.

    Tampa Bay's 7 day forecast. [WTSP]
  3. Romano: The choice does not have to be poverty or gentrification

    Local Government

    The memories must be protected. The music and the lore, too.

    The owner of Sylvia's Queen of Soul Food is refusing to give the city information on the restaurant's sales as required by his contract to occupy the city-owned Manhattan Casino. The information is needed to calculate whether the nonprofit Urban Development Solutions, headed by Larry Newsome, owes the city more than the $3,000 monthly base rent.
  4. Tests show North Korea earthquake not caused by nuclear test

    World

    SEOUL, South Korea (AP) — South Korea's weather agency said a magnitude 3.2 earthquake was detected in North Korea on Saturday close to where the country recently conducted a nuclear test, but it assessed the quake as natural.

    People watch a TV news program reporting North Korea's earthquake, at Seoul Railway Station in Seoul, South Korea, Saturday, Sept. 23, 2017. South Korea's weather agency said an earthquake was detected in North Korea on Saturday around where the country recently conducted a nuclear test, but it assessed the quake as natural. The signs read " The weather agency said a magnitude 3.0 earthquake was detected in North Korea." [Associated Press]
  5. New earthquake, magnitude 6.1, shakes jittery Mexico

    World

    MEXICO CITY — A strong new earthquake shook Mexico on Saturday, causing new alarm in a country reeling from two still-more-powerful quakes this month that have killed nearly 400 people.

    Locals play pool at a venue in Mexico City's La Condesa neighborhood, Friday, Sept. 22, 2017, four days after the 7.1 earthquake. The upscale Mexico City neighborhood was one of the hardest hit, with more than a half-dozen collapsed buildings in the immediate vicinity. The few Condesa residents who ventured out Friday night said they were anxious for relief from an anguishing week. [Associated Press]