Wednesday, May 23, 2018
News Roundup

Court considers new testimony in case of Pinellas man set for execution

LARGO — Thirty-two years after the fact, a witness appeared in court on Tuesday and contradicted the official account of what Robert Waterhouse did on the night Deborah Kammerer was murdered.

But it's not clear if Tuesday's testimony will make a difference for Waterhouse, who is scheduled to be executed next month.

Leglio Sotolongo came forward to tell what he recalled about that 1980 night, saying he felt it was his responsibility to set the record straight.

But the condemned man chose not to listen in on the hearing that could help decide how long he lives. Waterhouse is in prison, but he spoke briefly by telephone with Senior Circuit Judge Robert Beach and said he did not wish to participate.

Sotolongo, now 55, was a doorman at the ABC Lounge on Fourth Street in St. Petersburg in 1980 and knew Waterhouse as a regular patron. He saw Waterhouse on the night of the murder and says he told a detective that Waterhouse left the bar with two men that night.

That's significant because at trial, a bartender testified she saw Waterhouse leave the bar with the victim — a more incriminating version. Kammerer was raped and beaten to death and found in St. Petersburg's Lassing Park.

Now, based partly on Sotolongo's testimony, defense attorney Robert Norgard is seeking to throw out the death penalty and win a new trial for Waterhouse. A decision from Beach is expected later this week.

Sotolongo said that after he saw a recent Tampa Bay Times story recounting the case, he felt it was important to come forward and say Waterhouse left the bar that night with two men, not with the woman who was killed. He says he spoke to a friend who told him, " 'It's a serious issue.' I agreed.''

But the next person on the stand was Gary Hitchcox, the former detective who took Sotolongo's statement 32 years ago. He flatly denied Sotolongo ever told him that Waterhouse left with two men, instead of with the victim.

"I say it's false," Hitchcox said Tuesday, speaking of Sotolongo's account. He said if Sotolongo had told him about Waterhouse leaving with two men, he not only would have made notes and written it up in his police report, he would have considered it an exciting new wrinkle in the investigation.

"If that had been told to me, it would have been in the report," said Hitchcox, now an investigator with the Pinellas-Pasco Public Defender's Office.

There also was testimony on Tuesday about an incident that purportedly happened months after the time Hitchcox interviewed Sotolongo.

Sotolongo said he and a friend were at a different bar one night when Hitchcox approached the two of them and criticized them both for trying to help a murderer with their comments.

Sotolongo said he was so upset he later filed an internal affairs complaint against Hitchcox. But Hitchcox later responded from the witness stand: "Never happened." He said there was no such confrontation, and no such investigation.

Norgard said that although Sotolongo has been a known witness for decades, it was only discovered recently that his version of events contradicts others.

But Chief Assistant State Attorney Bruce Bartlett said he considered Sotolongo's account a "fabrication." He also said there would have been enough evidence to charge Waterhouse with the murder even without testimony about who left the bar with whom.

Also on Tuesday, Beach denied the defense's motion to overturn Waterhouse's death sentence because evidence in the case was destroyed after the trial. If that evidence still existed, such as blood samples, modern DNA testing methods might have exonerated Waterhouse, his attorney said.

Times staff writer Curtis Krueger can be reached at [email protected] or (727)893-8232.

Comments

Updated: 6 minutes ago
Ex-wife said heart attack, but court record says Hillsborough developer was strangled in North Carolina home

Ex-wife said heart attack, but court record says Hillsborough developer was strangled in North Carolina home

A prominent Hillsborough County developer who died last month in North Carolina was strangled and police are investigating his death as suspicious, court records show. William "Bill" Bishop died in a hospital three days after his 16-year-old son repo...
Updated: 1 hour ago
For starters: Rays vs. Red Sox, with Archer facing Price

For starters: Rays vs. Red Sox, with Archer facing Price

The Rays are set to take on the Red Sox again tonight with a bit of a student-mentor framing as Chris Archer takes on former Tampa Bay ace David Price.The Rays announced they are putting RHP Jake Faria on the 10-day DL due to the oblique strain he su...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Stock up for hurricanes, Buckhorn warns, or ‘we may be coming for you in a body bag’

Stock up for hurricanes, Buckhorn warns, or ‘we may be coming for you in a body bag’

TAMPA — Stuff that hurricane kit full of batteries, pen that emergency plan and, for goodness sake, get as many gallons stored in the garage as possible while the skies are blue and clouds are fluffy white. That was the message Tampa Mayor Bob Buckh...
Updated: 1 hour ago
‘I didn’t care if they cut my leg off or not’: Kilauea lava bomb survivor describes agony

‘I didn’t care if they cut my leg off or not’: Kilauea lava bomb survivor describes agony

The sheer force of the lava bomb was what Darryl Clinton remembered feeling first, more powerful than any waves he had ever encountered in the ocean surrounding Hawaii.It knocked him backward on the third-floor lanai of his neighbor’s home on the eas...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Mother fatally struck while pushing stroller on Bayshore Boulevard in Tampa

Mother fatally struck while pushing stroller on Bayshore Boulevard in Tampa

TAMPA— A mother was killed Wednesday when she was struck by a vehicle while pushing a stroller on Bayshore Boulevard, according to the Tampa Police Department.The mother and 2-year-old girl were struck by a northbound car around 11:43 a.m. near W Kni...
Updated: 1 hour ago
State softball: Land O’Lakes advances to second straight title game

State softball: Land O’Lakes advances to second straight title game

VERO BEACH — Land O'Lakes had just finished a hard-fought 5-0 victory over Clay in the Class 6A state semifinal. Callie Turner threw a no-hitter. Jolene Bodner had a two-run single.The win was big, clinching the Gators' second straight champion...
Updated: 1 hour ago
State baseball: Carrollwood Day comes up a run short in semifinals

State baseball: Carrollwood Day comes up a run short in semifinals

FORT MYERS — One swing.That's all it took for Carrollwood Day's historic season to come to an end.With two outs and two runners on in the third inning of the Class 3A state semifinal against Tallahassee North Florida Christian, Patriots starter...
Updated: 2 hours ago
No. 2-seeded USF falls to Wichita State in AAC tourney opener

No. 2-seeded USF falls to Wichita State in AAC tourney opener

Second-seeded USF was greeted Wednesday morning at the American Athletic Conference tournament by a bright sky and bracket poised to burst.Yet on a day the Bulls (32-19-1) could've made real noise in this eight-team event, their bats elicited nary a ...
Updated: 2 hours ago
NFL policy: Players can stay inside during anthem if they won’t stand

NFL policy: Players can stay inside during anthem if they won’t stand

NFL owners passed a new policy Wednesday with the hopes of moving on from boycotts and political turmoil related to some players protesting by not standing during the national anthem before games.Under the new policy, NFL players are not required to ...
Updated: 2 hours ago