Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Defense lawyers say a Florida drug law is unconstitutional

BROOKSVILLE — Just weeks after a pair of court decisions deemed a Florida drug law unconstitutional, a judge soon will rule on an issue that could overturn thousands of convictions and exonerate hundreds of people recently charged with drug crimes.

On Wednesday, defense lawyers from across the state will present motions in Hernando County asserting that the state's drug abuse prevention and control law violates the due process clause of the U.S. Constitution's 14th Amendment.

Under the statute, defendants can be convicted of a felony merely by possessing an illegal drug, regardless of what they mean to do with it or if they even knew what they had is illegal. The attorneys argue that stipulation makes the statute invalid.

Officials with the Hernando State Attorney's Office adamantly disagree and say that when Chief Circuit Judge Daniel Merritt Sr. considers the defense motions in the coming weeks, he'll have no choice but to deny them.

Since the Florida Legislature passed the changes to the law in 2002, two of Florida's five District Courts of Appeal have decreed that the rule is constitutional. Even though Merritt doesn't preside in either of those districts, prosecutor Donald "Sonny" McCathran said Merritt should be bound by those decisions.

Brooksville defense lawyers Jimmy Brown and Peyton Hy­slop, a former judge, say that's not true. They point to a recent ruling in Miami that bucked the district court decisions and determined the statute was unlawful.

The upcoming motions will largely be based on the Aug. 17 ruling by South Florida Circuit Judge Milton Hirsch.

The statute "does not punish the drug dealer who possesses or delivers controlled substances. It punishes anyone who possesses or delivers controlled substances, however inadvertently, however accidently, however unintentionally," Hirsch wrote in his opinion. "It reaches beyond those who willfully do wrong, beyond those who negligently do wrong, beyond those who carelessly do wrong, and includes within its wingspan those who meant no wrong."

The law was created in response to a Florida Supreme Court order that judges should always instruct juries to consider defendants' intent when deciding their guilt or innocence on drug possession charges. Lawmakers, now nearly 10 years ago, amended the statute, becoming the only state in the nation to eradicate "guilty knowledge," also called mens rea.

Defense lawyers say a Florida drug law is unconstitutional 08/31/11 [Last modified: Wednesday, August 31, 2011 11:54pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Wisniewska: I protected our students and USFSP campus


    Throughout my tenure in academia, my focus has always been on putting students first.

    The USF St. Petersburg Campus, Thursday, June 19, 2014.
  2. Bucs defensive end Chris Baker (90) is seen during training camp last month at One Buc Place. [LOREN ELLIOTT   |   Times]
  3. Bucs' defensive attributes in opener included flexibility


    TAMPA — It's a blink-and-you-miss-it nuance, but in Sunday's opener against Chicago, on their very first defensive snap, the Bucs lined up in a 3-4 defense.

    Tampa Bay Buccaneers head coach Dirk Koetter shakes hands with cornerback Brent Grimes (24) before an NFL game between the Chicago Bears and Tampa Bay Buccaneers at Raymond James Stadium in Tampa, Fla., on Sunday, Sept. 17, 2017. LOREN ELLIOTT   |   Times 

  4. Along the Alafia River, the grateful extend a hand to the Irma-sodden weary


    LITHIA — The things that make a house a home dried in the afternoon sun Thursday in a front yard on Williams Street.

    Volunteers from FishHawk Fellowship Church helped Brian Hood (left) clean up debris from his yard in Valrico, Fla. Last week the Alafia River reached a depth of almost 23 feet, about 10 feet above its flood stage. Many homes were damaged, some became uninhabitable. Hood's home is 6 inches above Lithia Pinecrest Road, and did not sustain flood damage, though not all of his neighbors were as lucky.   [MONICA HERNDON   |   Times]
  5. What to watch this weekend: 'Star Trek: Discovery,' 'DuckTales' returns


    Boldly go: Star Trek: Discovery

    It's been more than 50 years since the original Star Trek premiered, but the new CBS series is set 10 years before Kirk and Spock. Star Trek: Discovery explores the war between the Federation and the Klingons while following the USS Discovery, an exploratory …

    Sonequa Martin-Green in Star Trek: Discovery on CBS.