Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Defense takes aim at veracity of baby's mother in McTear murder trial

TAMPA — Jasmine Bedwell says she knows that Richard McTear Jr. killed her infant son five years ago, when she was a teenager living under the watch of Hillsborough County's foster care agency. But that's not what a former caseworker remembers her saying at the time.

Attorneys representing McTear, 26, worked to dismantle Bedwell's version of events Tuesday, calling on her former placement specialist with Camelot Community Care, a contract foster care agency. Keshia Coffie told jurors that Bedwell called her from the hospital on May 5, 2009, the day her son was killed. She was crying hysterically and screaming into the phone.

"I remember her saying, 'My baby dead, my baby dead, my uncle beat me up and killed my baby,' " Coffie said. "She asked me to help."

From the start of Mc­Tear's murder trial a week ago, his attorneys have tried to discredit Bedwell, their client's main accuser, by saying she is an unreliable witness who has given different accounts of what happened. Questioned about Coffie's statements days ago, Bedwell, 22, told the jury that she does not have an uncle and has never used the word to refer to anyone. She pointed at McTear when asked to identify her assailant.

The defendant's father, Richard McTear Sr., took a brief turn on the witness stand Tuesday, when he testified that several times before her 3-month-old son, Emanuel Murray, was killed, Bedwell sent him ominous text messages.

"She was talking like she would harm herself or harm the baby," he said, his voice as flat and affectless as his son's demeanor throughout the trial. Not knowing what to do, he showed the message to his son, he said, who assured him everything was okay. "He would say, 'Oh, she just tripping, she just tripping.' "

But when McTear Sr. presented his cellphone to defense attorneys months after his son's arrest, they were unable to recover any messages. A likely "coincidence," a prosecutor said Tuesday.

Over prosecutors' objections, defense attorneys questioned one of Bedwell's former teachers, Thomas Scaglione, who became a mentor to her as she worked toward a high school diploma in the GED program. Scaglione said he remembered overhearing Bedwell's phone conversation as she walked out of his class on May 4, a day before her son was killed.

"She said, 'Give me my baby back, m----- f-----,' " he recalled. When he confronted her, Bedwell told him her son had been taken from her at the mall a day before. Later that day, he pressed her further and she told him, "I lied, Mr. Tom. That's what I do."

In her testimony, Bedwell said she couldn't remember this conversation taking place; her baby had never been kidnapped in a mall, she said.

Cross-examined by prosecutors, Scaglione said there was more to his conversation with Bedwell. She had told him that her baby had been taken from her because her boyfriend didn't want her to go to court and get a restraining order against him. Court records show that Bedwell was seeking a permanent domestic violence injunction against McTear, but missed a court hearing to follow up.

To counter prosecutors' claims that McTear viciously attacked Bedwell in the hours before her son was killed, the defense hired a Georgia-based expert in forensic dentistry and flew him to Tampa. In several hours of testimony, Dr. Thomas David said he had analyzed the same evidence as the prosecution's expert witness, and concluded that it was impossible to definitively say McTear bit Bedwell.

Defense attorneys rested their case Tuesday. Both sides are expected to make closing arguments today.

Contact Anna M. Phillips at or (813) 226-3354. Follow @annamphillips.

Defense takes aim at veracity of baby's mother in McTear murder trial 07/29/14 [Last modified: Tuesday, July 29, 2014 9:38pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. UF's move to deny white nationalist Richard Spencer a venue sets up a First Amendment court fight


    In denying a notorious white nationalist his request to speak on campus, the University of Florida has brought a thorny legal battle to Gainesville in the name of keeping its students safe.

    Legal experts say the University of Florida will have an uphill battle in court proving that fears of violence from an appearance by white nationalist Richard Spencer will override the First Amendment. "There's a fine line between inciting lawlessness and engendering a situation where lawlessness arises," said Peter Lake, higher education law professor at Stetson University College of Law. [Getting Images]
  2. Kenya opposition says it will challenge election in court


    NAIROBI, Kenya — Kenya's opposition will challenge the results of last week's presidential election in Supreme Court and wage a campaign of civil disobedience, its leader announced Wednesday, saying they intend to expose a "computer-generated presidency."

  3. Kriseman and Crist rally troops for final push in St. Pete mayor's race


    Elections have consequences. Donald Trump. Charlottesville.

    Rick Kriseman and Charlie Crist pose for a group photo Wednesday evening with progressive activists at Allendale United Methodist Church
  4. The FHP trooper behind quota on speeding tickets will retire Sept. 5

    State Roundup

    TALLAHASSEE — A Florida Highway Patrol official's call for troopers to meet ticket quotas has cost him his job.

    Major Mark D. Welch, Troop Commander of Troop H, wrote an email asking his employees that he wants them to write two citations each hour. "This is not a quota," he wrote. His resignation is effective Sept. 5. [Florida Highway Patrol]