Tuesday, April 24, 2018
News Roundup

Dontae Morris defense asks judge to toss video of police killings

TAMPA — Defense attorneys are asking a judge to toss out what is arguably the most compelling piece of evidence against Dontae Morris, the man charged with murdering two Tampa police officers in 2010.

In a motion filed with Hillsborough Circuit Judge William Fuente, Morris' attorneys assert that a video showing a man who appears to be Morris fatally shooting the officers should not be admitted as evidence in his upcoming trial.

The reason? The suspect was illegally detained as a passenger during the traffic stop that led up to the killings, and the video captured by a police cruiser's dashboard camera was thus not lawfully obtained evidence, the attorneys say.

"The passenger's subsequent behavior of attacking the police was the product of flagrant unlawful police action, and with every moment that the video was recording, seconds of tainted videographic evidence were being taken by the police's dash camera," the defense motion states.

Morris, now 27, was riding in a car driven by his girlfriend, Cortnee Brantley, in June 2010. Tampa police Officer David Curtis pulled over Brantley for driving without a license plate. During the stop, Curtis asked for Morris' name and discovered there were warrants for his arrest.

Curtis and a second officer who had arrived on scene, Jeffrey Kocab, then approached Morris' side of the car and asked him to exit. Within seconds of stepping out, Morris pulled a gun, shot both officers in the head and ran off, prosecutors say.

It later turned out that the arrest warrants for Morris — issued for writing bad checks — were invalid. That too renders the video of the shooting inadmissible as evidence, according to his defense attorneys.

In arguing that police error contaminated the evidence against Morris, his attorneys are falling back on a classic criminal defense strategy — albeit one applied to unusually wrenching circumstances.

"It's fascinating, because if the defense can persuade the judge that but for an illegal detention, the dash-cam (video) wouldn't exist, they might have an argument," said Jennifer Zedalis, director of trial practice at the University of Florida Levin College of Law.

But the argument could be complicated, Zedalis said, by the fact that the dashboard video was already being shot before officers questioned or tried to arrest Morris — and thus might not be viewed as a result of any effort to question or detain him.

The video was already played as evidence in a separate case against Brantley that sprang out of her failure to provide information to police about Morris.

Prosecutors have filed a response to the defense motion saying that Morris was not illegally detained but rather questioned in a "consensual encounter" during which he was free to leave at any time. They also state that Curtis and Kocab were "acting in good faith" in their efforts to serve the warrants, which they did not know were invalid.

Prosecutors also called attention to a curious incongruity in the defense motion — Morris' attorneys never acknowledge their client is actually in the video, and thus may not have standing to argue against it.

Laurence Rose, director of the litigation skills program at the University of Miami College of Law, said he doubted a judge would find the defense argument persuasive, since the traffic stop that preceded the video was reasonable and Morris was asked, and not ordered, to provide his personal information.

"He could have just said, 'I'm not telling you my name,' and it probably would have ended there," Rose said.

A jury found Morris guilty of first-degree murder earlier this year in a different 2010 shooting. He received a mandatory life prison sentence, but could face the death penalty if convicted of killing the officers.

Peter Jamison can be reached at [email protected] or (813) 226-3337. Follow him on Twitter @petejamison.

Comments
Troopers seek driver who ran from fatal crash in Trinity

Troopers seek driver who ran from fatal crash in Trinity

TRINITY — The Florida Highway Patrol said it is looking for a driver who ran from the scene of a fatal three-vehicle crash that took place Tuesday afternoon on State Road 54 at Duck Slough Boulevard.The crash took place at about 2:33 p.m., closing do...
Updated: 15 minutes ago
DNA, new plea set man free 17 years after Tampa murder

DNA, new plea set man free 17 years after Tampa murder

TAMPA — Almost 17 years ago, Dwight DuBose was condemned to spend the rest of his life in prison for a murder he says he didn’t commit.On Tuesday morning, he pleaded guilty to the crime in exchange for the promise that he would go free.DuBose, 45, wa...
Updated: 16 minutes ago
Pinellas County commits $41.7 million to Blue Jays Stadium

Pinellas County commits $41.7 million to Blue Jays Stadium

DUNEDIN — The Pinellas County Commission pulled the final trigger Tuesday on dedicating $41.7 million in bed taxes for upgrades to the Toronto Blue Jays’ stadium and spring training facilities, a pledge that amounts to covering more than half of the ...
Updated: 21 minutes ago
Hernando County to start neutering feral cats

Hernando County to start neutering feral cats

BROOKSVILLE — Hernando County will soon become a more cat-friendly community.The County Commission voted 4-0 Tuesday in favor of a policy to trap, neuter and vaccinate feral cats and return them to the wild. They hope to reduce the number of cats eut...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Days before graduation, crash kills Lakewood High senior, injures two others

Days before graduation, crash kills Lakewood High senior, injures two others

ST. PETERSBURG — A Lakewood High School student was killed and two others were injured when their car struck a tree just outside the campus on Tuesday afternoon, according to police.All three boys involved in the crash were 18 and seniors, officials ...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Rays-Orioles postponed, doubleheader planned for May 12

Rays-Orioles postponed, doubleheader planned for May 12

UPDATE, 6:06: The Rays will stay in rotation, so Faria will slide back a day and pitch Wednesday, vs. Cobb, and Archer will get an extra day's rest and pitch Thursday, against RHP Dylan Bundy.Also of note, Cash said 3B Matt Duffy (right hamstring str...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Monday meeting may determine fate of Brooksville Police Department

Monday meeting may determine fate of Brooksville Police Department

BROOKSVILLE — Brooksville City Council holds a special meeting at 6 p.m. Monday to consider an interlocal agreement proposal by Sheriff Al Nienhuis to take over law enforcement duties from the city police.The council has been struggling with an excep...
Updated: 1 hour ago
He tried to rob two pharmacies. Both times he left empty-handed.

He tried to rob two pharmacies. Both times he left empty-handed.

TAMPA — Police are looking for a man who failed to rob two pharmacies last week.No one was harmed during the botched heists, but the man may be armed with a handgun, police said.Detectives on Tuesday released surveillance video that showed the man in...
Updated: 1 hour ago
FHP: Riverview motorcyclist critically injured in crash on I-4

FHP: Riverview motorcyclist critically injured in crash on I-4

TAMPA — A 41-year-old motorcyclist was critically injured in a Monday night crash on Interstate 4, according to the Florida Highway Patrol.The crash took place at about 7:15 p.m. Cristobal Padilla, of Riverview, was riding a 2004 Suzuki motorcycle in...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Embattled Hernando County commissioner not present at Tuesday’s meeting

Embattled Hernando County commissioner not present at Tuesday’s meeting

BROOKSVILLE — Hernando County Commissioner Nick Nicholson was absent from Tuesday’s regular meeting, but he was still the subject of much conversation.Commissioners, stung by the nationwide publicity about Nicholson’s arrest last week on three prosti...
Updated: 1 hour ago