Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Dentist gets 12 years for DUI deaths on Harbour Island

TAMPA — For the first time since he slammed into their children with his car three years ago, instantly killing them on the Harbour Island Bridge, the parents of Douglas Kozar, 23, and Kate Kohlier, 24, got to see the Riverview dentist who did it.

In court Thursday, 37-year-old Matthew Moye wore a black suit and blue tie, a stark contrast from the ghoulish crime scene photos from Oct. 30, 2010, that show him with white Halloween makeup still on his face.

Investigators say he had a 0.13 blood alcohol level, far exceeding the 0.08 threshold at which the state presumes impairment. They say he was going 89 mph when his tire hit the median, sending him careening toward the right, then left — straight into the pair walking to their cars after work at the Marriott Waterside Hotel.

He had come to court on Thursday for a plea agreement: 12 years in prison, followed by 10 years' probation for two counts of DUI manslaughter. With good behavior, he could be out in about 10.5 years.

"Of course we're disappointed," Douglas Kozar's mother, Kathy Kozar, told reporters later.

The sentence was too short, her family said. Hillsborough has seen many others sentenced to more — sometimes 20 to 30 years — for the same charges.

"But in the end, it was all out of our control," she said. "So we had to accept it."

Douglas' brother, Matt Kozar, called it "some sort of justice."

Though the sentence was set, the victims' families still had the chance to share memories and tales of loss in court. And they did, bringing framed family photos to the lectern.

Douglas Kozar was a mechanically minded young man who loved fishing and wanted to get into law enforcement. He was quiet, introspective and artistic.

Kate Kohlier was a people person majoring in psychology. More than 300 came to her memorial. One said he was only there because of Kate — because she had talked him out of suicide.

Douglas' father, Russ Kozar, sounded shaky as he read a letter addressed to his son the day before his funeral, signed "I'll never stop loving you, Dad."

His voice hardened when he turned to Moye.

"I have no forgiveness for you, and I have no sympathy," he said.

Kate Kohlier's mother, Cindy Collins, spoke softly about her only daughter. When Kate was young, Collins would sing You Are My Sunshine to her each day. Even in her 20s, Kate would text her mom each morning: "Morning, mama."

It was her way of letting her mother know everything was okay.

Halloween and Christmas were Kate's favorites. Each year, when Collins sees the decorations in the store for the first time, she cries.

"Knowing it's another year of loss," she said.

The Kozar family criticized Moye for not showing up in court before now. They had traveled from New York about 15 times for various proceedings. He needed to "man up," Kathy Kozar said.

Moye's attorney, Steve Romine, later told the Tampa Bay Times that he had advised his client, who was out on $119,000 bail, not to attend because Moye had received some "disturbing threats" after the highly publicized crash.

He continued to run his business, Big Bend Dental, after he bailed out of jail. On Thursday, he looked directly at each family member who spoke, his expression never changing.

Russ Kozar said he doubts Moye has remorse. And though Douglas will never come back, the father got an ounce of satisfaction from one thing:

Hearing the click of the handcuffs as a bailiff slipped them around the dentist's wrists.

Times staff writer Dan Sullivan contributed to this report. Jessica Vander Velde can be reached at or (813) 226-3433.

Dentist gets 12 years for DUI deaths on Harbour Island 11/07/13 [Last modified: Friday, November 8, 2013 12:08am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Estimated 5,000 people marvel at MOSI over solar eclipse

    Human Interest

    Packing pinhole cereal box viewers, cardboard glasses and curiosity, solar gawkers gathered outside Tampa's Museum of Science and Industry on Monday for a show that required no ticket.

    At center, Sophia Butter, 8, and Kristina Butera, both of Valrico, watch the sun through eclipse viewing glasses during a solar eclipse party Monday at the Museum of Science and Industry in Tampa. MOSI will reopen after renovations on November 18. [MONICA HERNDON   |   Times]
  2. Florida State sees plenty of upside in Dade City native Jacob Pugh


    TALLAHASSEE — No, Florida State senior Jacob Pugh is not as versatile as teammate Derwin James.

     Florida State Seminoles linebacker Jacob Pugh (16) and Florida State Seminoles defensive end DeMarcus Walker (44) celebrate after sacking the Miami quarterback Saturday October 8, 2016 at Hard Rock Stadium in Miami Gardens.
  3. Tampa officer treated for knee injury after police truck, police SUV collide


    Times staff

    TAMPA — A Tampa police officer was treated and released for a knee injury when his unmarked police truck collided with a patrol SUV while the officers were tracking a stolen car, a police spokesman said.

  4. Waiting for the eclipse: 'Everyone thinks this is cool'

    Human Interest

    ST. PETERSBURG — Hunter Holland came to school Monday with a NASA space T-shirt and solar viewers in his button-up shirt pocket. But he'd rather be in Missouri.

    Jayda Hebert (front, center), 11, uses her protective glasses to watch Monday's solar eclipse with her cousin, Judah Adams (back left), 11, and her brother Jake Hebert (right), 9, while with their family at St. Petersburg Beach. "We're skipping school for the eclipse," her mom, Sarah Hebert, said. [DIRK SHADD   |   Times]
  5. Second person resigns from Hillsborough diversity council after Confederate activist appointed


    TAMPA — A second person has resigned symbolically from the Hillsborough County Diversity Advisory Council after the appointment of a known activist of Confederate causes to the panel. 

    Two people have resigned from the Hillsborough County Diversity Advisory Council after the inclusion of David McCallister, a leader of the local branch of the Sons of Confederate Veterans.