Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Emotions run high during jury selection in Julie Schenecker murder trial

Julie Schenecker, second from left, watches potential jurors enter the courtroom on Thursday. Jury selection continues today. She is accused of killing her two teenage children.


Julie Schenecker, second from left, watches potential jurors enter the courtroom on Thursday. Jury selection continues today. She is accused of killing her two teenage children.

TAMPA — Emotions flared on Thursday as attorneys began to question a pool of 90 prospective jurors in the trial of Julie Schenecker, the New Tampa mother accused of murdering her two teenage children in 2011.

After three days of interviewing jurors individually to gauge their level of exposure to media coverage of the killings, attorneys began asking them about events in their lives that might bias them. Prosecutors wanted to know if the jurors had served in the military, how much schooling they'd had and whether they had any children.

The two victims in the case were 16 and 13 years old when they were killed, prosecutor Jay Pruner reminded the jurors. He asked if that fact would prevent anyone from being fair.

Two female jurors began to cry. Separately, they told Pruner that they wanted to have children, but hadn't been able to conceive.

"We don't have any children and not for lack of trying, just no luck," said one woman.

After jury selection ended Wednesday, she went home and thought about the case, she said. The prospect of spending two more weeks immersed in the story of a woman accused killed her own children was too much to handle.

Both of the women were excused.

By the end of the fourth day of jury selection, 69 potential jurors remained.

Many of those sent home said they had children and couldn't debate questions of Schenecker's guilt or innocence with an open mind.

"I mean no disrespect, but I'm not impartial to this case," said a father of two, who was later excused. "The last person children should have to look over their shoulder for is their parents."

Other potential jurors were dismissed after they told attorneys that they wouldn't support the insanity defense, which Schenecker's attorneys plan to use in the trial. Still more were removed from the pool when they said their experiences with mental illness made them more likely to support such a defense.

"I think I have more than the average sympathy for people with mental illness," said a man whose aunt committed suicide when he was young. Though defense attorneys argued that he should remain in the pool, he was ultimately excused.

Prosecutors also focused on potential jurors' military experience, asking whether anyone had served or had friends or family in the service. Pruner appeared particularly interested in whether jurors had moved frequently, as military families often do. Schenecker and her ex-husband former Army Col. Parker Schenecker were in the military for years.

Though the process of jury selection is time-consuming and the questioning is painstaking, there were moments of levity.

As the day drew to a close, the prosecutor shifted to asking jurors about their arrest histories and whether anyone they knew had been charged with a crime.

"I was arrested but found innocent in the '70s for growing a couple marijuana plants in my college dorm room," offered one man.

There was a pause. "That was a class project, wasn't it?" said the prosecutor.

The process of choosing 12 jurors and four alternates is likely to continue through today. Schenecker's trial is expected to begin on Monday.

Emotions run high during jury selection in Julie Schenecker murder trial 05/01/14 [Last modified: Monday, May 5, 2014 11:32am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Tiger Woods says medication, not alcohol, led to DUI arrest in Florida

    Public Safety

    Players arriving for a tournament this week at Muirfield Village might notice a framed picture of Tiger Woods with a resplendent smile and bright red shirt. He's posed there with the trophy, an image that embodies the excitement he once brought to golf.

    This image provided by the Palm Beach County Sheriff's Office on Monday, May 29, 2017, shows Tiger Woods. Police in Florida say Tiger Woods was been arrested for DUI.  [Palm Beach County Sheriff's office via AP]
  2. Manuel Noriega, Panamanian strongman toppled in U.S. invasion, dies at 83


    Gen. Manuel Noriega, the Panamanian strongman and onetime American ally who was toppled from power in a 1989 U.S. invasion and who spent more than two decades imprisoned on drug dealing and conspiracy convictions, died late Monday. He was most likely 83.

    Gen. Manuel Antonio Noriega waves to newsmen after a state council meeting, at the presidential palace in Panama City, where they announced the new president of the republic in 1989. Panama's ex-dictator Noriega died Monday, May 29, 2017, in a hospital in Panama City. He was 83. [Associated Press]
  3. Austin Mahone talks Pitbull, Taylor Swift, Ariana Grande, his pop evolution and more


    Austin Mahone has vivid memories from his childhood visits to see his grandparents in Tampa Bay.

  4. Motorcyclist killed in Pinellas Park crash, prompting road closures


    A motorcyclist was killed early Tuesday morning when he left the roadway and possibly struck a parked vehicle in Pinellas Park.

  5. Meet the five finalists for St. Petersburg College president


    ST. PETERSBURG — In the last month, five finalists for the job of St. Petersburg College president have taken campus tours and answered questions from students, faculty and staff.

    The Douglas L. Jamerson, Jr., Midtown Center of St. Petersburg College, opened in 2015, is considered a major accomplishment by outgoing SPC president William Law. [SOPHIA NAHLI  ALLISON  |   TIMES]