Monday, June 25, 2018
News Roundup

Even in police deaths, the law can't mandate decency

In the end, a deadlocked jury perfectly defines the divide running down the middle of the criminal case against Cortnee Brantley.

On one side is emotion, understandable anger and a push for some scrap of justice.

It is two Tampa police officers, Jeffrey Kocab and David Curtis, making a bad-check arrest during a traffic stop two years ago, then getting gunned down in a split second caught on police video.

It is Brantley, the suspect's girlfriend in the driver's seat, hearing the shots and driving away without calling for medical help, without cooperating the way police wanted her to in the investigation of Dontae Morris.

And then there's the other side, the cold, hard, necessary requirements of the law.

State prosecutors who are seeking a death sentence for Morris in the murders of the two officers did not find evidence to charge Brantley with a crime.

Federal prosecutors, however, charged her with "misprision of a felony," which means that if you know someone committed a felony and you conceal it and don't tell authorities, it's a crime.

Brantley is accused of failing to tell authorities Morris was a felon who had ammunition and a gun.

"Misprision" sound confusing? Jurors on the case this week might have felt the same.

Despite having been instructed on the law, they sent a question from the jury room asking the definition of "misprision."

The jury tried to reach a unanimous verdict and couldn't, and then tried again with a nudge from the judge. In the end, they could not agree on whether what Brantley did or didn't do was a crime. Mistrial.

At one point U.S. District Court Judge James Moody stated a basic truth here: "This is not an easy case because it carries so much emotion," he said. "It's hard to separate out the evidence from the emotion."

Moody ruled that during the trial, police officers could not come to court in uniform unless they were testifying. A sea of crisp and somber midnight blue uniforms, a wall of solidarity among officers, could well influence a jury's decision.

This may not have made him the No. 1 judge with every cop in town. But it's in the job description for him to see past emotion, to hold steady, and to be as impartial as is humanly possible.

Maybe there are those out there who hoped the case would send a message that stonewalling investigators when the stakes are this high could get you charged.

But that's not what the law is supposed to be about, either.

Prosecutors said Thursday that despite the mistrial, they intend to pursue a charge against Brantley. It isn't surprising.

The judge — who notably at one point told the lawyers he thought Brantley had no duty to give Morris' name or "say anything in an interview" with police — could grant an acquittal.

No matter what comes next in terms of the legal wrangling, here is a bottom line and a hard truth:

In the end, the law can't tell someone to be a decent person. Someone can be wrong, morally wrong, can have shrugged off the duty to act like we believe a human being should act — and still be not guilty of a crime.

Comments
USF considering former Arkansas athletic director Jeff Long

USF considering former Arkansas athletic director Jeff Long

While Tom Jurich remains the preferred choice among several prominent USF boosters (and some coaches) for the Bulls' athletic director gig, our intel has revealed another former Power Five AD also is getting a serious look.Jeff Long, who spent nearly...
Updated: 3 minutes ago
Driver who caused crash that damaged Hillsborough deputy’s patrol car was drunk, authorities say

Driver who caused crash that damaged Hillsborough deputy’s patrol car was drunk, authorities say

TAMPA — Panfilo Hernandez Saldana’s drive came to an abrupt end Friday night when he caused a crash that damaged a Hillsborough County sheriff’s vehicle, according to a Sheriff’s Office news release.Saldana, 30, rammed into the back of another car th...
Updated: 10 minutes ago
Top 5 at noon: What’s taking FDLE so long in Jack Latvala investigation? court dismisses suit by Tampa man who claims William Shatner is his father; and more

Top 5 at noon: What’s taking FDLE so long in Jack Latvala investigation? court dismisses suit by Tampa man who claims William Shatner is his father; and more

Here are the latest headlines and updates on tampabay.com.IN JACK LATVALA INVESTIGATION, WHAT’S TAKING FDLE SO LONG?It has been nearly six months since the Florida Department of Law Enforcement launched an investigation of former Sen. Jack Latvala o...
Updated: 20 minutes ago
Seffner man killed by lightning strike on Siesta Key

Seffner man killed by lightning strike on Siesta Key

A Seffner man was killed Sunday afternoon in a lightning strike on Siesta Key.According to the Sarasota County Sheriff’s Office, deputies responded after receiving a call around 2:15 p.m. of a person struck by lightning in the 6000 block of Midnight ...
Updated: 27 minutes ago
Watch: Gator that visited Brandon stores gets free ride in deputy’s patrol car

Watch: Gator that visited Brandon stores gets free ride in deputy’s patrol car

It’s not rare to see gators lurking around areas across Tampa Bay.What is rare, though, is seeing one slither out of a deputy’s cruiser.Hillsborough County sheriffs handled and removed an alligator that visited a CVS and Speedway at Lumsden Road in B...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Restaurant review: Viva Napoli lovingly recreates Italian cuisine’s greatest hits

Restaurant review: Viva Napoli lovingly recreates Italian cuisine’s greatest hits

TAMPAAccording to Nation’s Restaurant News, Italian continues to be the country’s most beloved ethnic cuisine. I’ve fallen out of love and then gotten moony-eyed again several times over the past decade or so. It’s a cuisine that is manhandled, jerry...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Ex-Bucs DE Keith McCants arrested, facing cocaine charge

Ex-Bucs DE Keith McCants arrested, facing cocaine charge

Former Alabama star and Bucs defensive end Keith McCants was arrested in St. Petersburg early Monday morning and is facing a felony charge of possession of crack cocaine, according to arrest records.McCants, 50, was arrested by the Pinellas County Sh...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Burgeoning trade war takes a toll from Tampa to Turkey

Burgeoning trade war takes a toll from Tampa to Turkey

Associated Press WASHINGTON — A Tampa boat builder absorbs $4 million in lost business and expects more pain. An Ohio pork producer is losing access to a vital export market and fears the damage will last years. A motorcycle shop near Cologne, German...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Harley-Davidson moving some production from U.S. because of EU tariffs

Harley-Davidson moving some production from U.S. because of EU tariffs

Harley-Davidson, the U.S. motorcycle manufacturer, said Monday that it was shifting some of the production of its bikes outside the United States to avoid European Union tariffs imposed as part of a widening trade dispute.The announcement, made in a ...
Updated: 1 hour ago
No Tropicana Field return for Evan Longoria in 2019

No Tropicana Field return for Evan Longoria in 2019

The Rays take their once-every-three- years turn playing NL West teams in 2019. But, based on an early draft of the schedule, won't get to welcome back traded franchise cornerstone 3B Evan Longoria.The Rays will face Longoria's new team, the Giants, ...
Updated: 1 hour ago