Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Fasano letter to judge prompts mistrial

NEW PORT RICHEY — State Sen. Mike Fasano's letter to the judge started out like this: "I realize I cannot get involved in the Eloise Mudway case."


He's involved now. The senator's letter led the judge to recuse himself Thursday from the trial of a New Port Richey couple accused of bilking the 91-year-old woman out of her home and savings.

That resulted in a mistrial for Joseph and Cynthia Clancy, who each face up to 30 years in prison if convicted of 2005 charges of exploitation of the elderly and grand theft from a person 65 years or older.

But state law and judicial canons gave Circuit Judge Jack Day no choice.

This was a bench trial, not a jury trial, meaning Day was both judge and jury. If even the possibility that the letter could influence the judge existed, he had to remove himself from the case.

Fasano accepted responsibility Thursday for the mistrial. He was relieved that there will soon be a retrial in front of a new judge.

"It is my fault," Fasano said. "I reacted and should have waited."

• • •

Like many judges, Day said he doesn't usually read correspondence from the public about cases before him.

That's because it's ex parte communication — Latin for "from one party." The court cannot accept direct contact about a case away from the interested parties.

The judge said his judicial assistant mistakenly showed him the senator's letter Thursday because it was from Fasano, a powerful Pasco County legislator.

"If (the Clancys) have done even half of what they are alleged to have done," Fasano wrote, "they should get the strongest possible sentence. Too often we read of deadbeat individuals in this state taking advantage of our elderly residents. Enough is enough!"

The senator even offered to propose "stronger" laws in these types of cases. It was that language, and Fasano's spot on the Senate Judiciary Committee, that led the defense to ask the judge remove himself.

"The Defendant(s) reasonably believes that (they) will not receive a fair and impartial trial," said the defense's motion.

Would the letter have had the same effect had this been a jury trial? Probably, surmised prosecutor Mary Handsel. If the Clancys were found guilty they would still be sentenced by this judge.

The silver lining in all this, Handsel said, is that the new trial can go forward even if the victim becomes incapacitated because of her age or condition.

If Mudway can't testify again, her testimony from Wednesday will be admissible in the retrial.

• • •

Judge Day saw the senator's letter in a larger light: legislative cuts of the judiciary's budget.

"I don't question Sen. Fasano's interest in the case," the judge said. "But it's a shame. … It's an important case and it's been treated as an important case by the state. Thousands of dollars of resources have been expended to get it in this week.

"So it's really ironic that this case is forced (to end), especially at times when we have concerns expressed by the Legislature about our efficiency."

• • •

The senator said he often writes letters to judges in cases, usually about deadbeat dads who owe child support.

But Eloise Mudway's plight caught Fasano's attention long ago. He said he wrote the letter Thursday and faxed it to the judge because he just got so angry reading a St. Petersburg Times article about the victim's testimony.

At first the Clancys called her "mother," Mudway told the judge on Wednesday, when they moved into her house. Then the victim testified that the couple tore through her bank accounts, had her unknowingly sign over her $370,000 home to them and then stuck her in an assisted living facility.

The Clancys have not only denied the allegations but are suing Mudway.

"When I saw the article that was written this morning, I was just outraged," Fasano said Thursday. "Once you start reading it in print … about what those two individuals did, robbing her blind, throwing her out of her own house, I guess I reacted."

Mudway isn't happy about the mistrial. But her caretaker said she has no hard feelings for Fasano.

"She feels like he's her hero," said Jeff Kores, "because he took the time to care about her case."

Jamal Thalji can be reached at or (727) 869-6236.

Fasano letter to judge prompts mistrial 09/04/08 [Last modified: Tuesday, September 9, 2008 12:19pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. USF eliminated by UCF in AAC baseball; Florida, FSU, Miami win


    CLEARWATER — Roughly 16 hours after a ninth-inning collapse against East Carolina in the American Athletic Conference's double-elimination baseball tournament, USF returned to Spectrum Field presumably set for a reboot.

    It simply got booted instead.

    ’NOLES win: Tyler Holton gets a hug from Drew Carlton after his strong eight innings help Florida State beat Louisville.
  2. Pinellas licensing board executive director settled hundreds of cases without getting his board's approval

    Local Government

    By Mark Puente

    Times Staff Writer

    Eleanor Morrison complained to the Pinellas licensing board in 2015 that her contractor installed crooked walls and windows and poured too much concrete for her carport.

    Eleanor Morrison poses at her home in Treasure Island, 5/26/17. Morrison filed a complaint with the Pinellas County Construction Licensing Board and later learned that its former Executive Director, Rodney Fischer, dismissed the case in a private meeting with the contractor.
  3. Report: Kusher wanted secret communications channel with Kremlin


    Jared Kushner and Russia's ambassador to Washington discussed the possibility of setting up a secret and secure communications channel between Donald Trump's transition team and the Kremlin, using Russian diplomatic facilities in an apparent move to shield their pre-inauguration discussions from monitoring, U.S. …

    The name of Jared Kushner, President Donald Trump's White House senior adviser, has come up as part of the Russia investigation. [Associated Press]
  4. Rays pitchers rave about Twins pitching coach, ex-mentor Neil Allen

    The Heater

    MINNEAPOLIS — There have been a lot of coaches who have had a hand in helping Chris Archer get to the big leagues and to the front of the Rays rotation, and as he took the mound Friday night at Target Field, he had reason to nod appreciatively toward the home dugout.

    In their third year with pitching coach Neil Allen, the Twins have been one of the surprises of the American League.
  5. Swan sculpture deputies say was stolen by naked man found near Lakeland pond


    A $25,000 swan sculpture that Polk County sheriff's deputies say was stolen by a naked man last weekend was found near a pond in Lakeland on Thursday.

    A swan sculpture that was stolen in Lakeland on May 19 was recovered by the Polk Sheriff’s Office on Friday.