Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Father shares anguish in court over sentencing in son's death


Philip Cuthbertson took the witness stand Friday morning. In a mostly empty courtroom, he talked about the loss of his 19-year-old son, Andrew Cuthbertson, who was killed in a car crash last year.

The Army staff sergeant drove from Fort Bragg in North Carolina to attend. He was in Afghanistan when his son died.

Near Cuthbertson stood Rickey Scroggins, a 23-year-old Bushnell man, who last week pleaded no contest to charges of DUI manslaughter.

Scroggins dabbed his eyes with a tissue as the terms of his sentence were read by Circuit Judge Stephen Rushing: three years in prison, two years of house arrest and five years on probation.

It's a sad, and all-too-familiar courtroom setting.

Andrew Cuthbertson was a passenger in Scroggins' truck when he ran a red light, colliding with a freight truck at Powell Road and U.S. 41.

Scroggins faced at least 15 years in prison but Cuthbertson's mother, who is divorced from his father, agreed to the lesser sentence as the closest next of kin. Philip Cuthbertson believes he was not consulted enough about the eventual sentence.

The courtroom scene is best conveyed by those who lived the tragedy.

Here, in its entirety, is what Philip Cuthbertson told the court:

"Judge Rushing, ladies and gentlemen of the court, good morning. My statement will be brief and to the point.

"According to statistics released by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, in 2007 — the year in which my son was killed — the state of Florida (saw 1,049 deaths) on our state highways due to an accident in which the driver was impaired with a BAC (blood alcohol content) of 0.08 or higher. This accounts for the 27.7 percent of all deaths on Florida's highways. This number is keeping pace with the national average of 31.7 percent.

"I feel these numbers are so high in the state of Florida because of the often too-lenient plea deals like we see today. I was asked once several months ago if I felt the Florida state guidelines would be sufficient to receive a sense of justice and closure. I agreed that they would be.

"This plea deal is not even close to those sentencing guidelines as explained to me. I was not given a chance to voice my opinion on this deal prior to today. For that I feel abandoned by a system that I placed all my faith in to bring justice (and) closure to my family.

"Nothing makes a father prouder than to have his son follow in his footsteps — that's just what Andy did. He followed so closely in my footsteps to include the good and the bad. He joined the Army for the same reason I did: to get his life on track.

"I spent the better part of 15 years serving my country and for that service I missed a lot of Andy's growing up. But I remember clearly the day he called me and asked me about the Army. Well, there are no words to describe the pride I had in my son. Not only did I have pride in him, but so did his half brother Timothy and his stepmother, Jennifer.

"The last time I (saw) Andy was around Christmas 2006. He was on leave. I was so proud of the man he had grown to be. I met his girlfriend, Danika, and heard of their plans to make a life together. We made plans to spend time together as a family. He wanted to get to know the other family that he had in North Carolina after my return from Afghanistan and before his eventual deployment to Iraq. We were both looking forward to reconnecting with each other.

"On April 27, 2007, at 0500 that morning, Mr. Scroggins made an immature and negligent decision that robbed my family of that opportunity. Mr. Scroggins' actions have caused me and my family undue emotional trauma, anguish and stress.

"In the (months) that followed this incident, I have endured mental torment in the forms of nightmares for which I have had to seek professional counseling and have been prescribed medication that has caused significant degradation to my job performance at work.

"And finally, to Mr. Scroggins, in time the pain of your actions will fade and the heart you have shattered will heal and at that time, God willing, I will find the strength to forgive you.

"I will always carry with me, for the rest of my life, an Andy-shaped hole in my heart. Thank you."

Father shares anguish in court over sentencing in son's death 09/12/08 [Last modified: Monday, September 15, 2008 3:36pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Florida ranks high for workplace equality between men and women

    Working Life

    When it comes to the workplace, Florida ranks fifth in terms of gender equality, a WalletHub study released Tuesday found.

    Florida ranks high in terms of equality between men and women in the workplace. Pictured is Sandra Murman, county commissioner in 2015, talking about the differences in pay between men and women. | [Times file photo]
  2. Is Ed Sheeran sexy? An investigation

    Music & Concerts

    Start with the guitar. Guitars are sexy, right? Historically, anytime anyone straps on a guitar, it's only a matter of time before they come running.

    Ed Sheeran, who sold out three shows at Madison Square Garden last year, opened for Taylor Swift’s “Red” tour and now has a new album called “x” (as in multiply), at the Hammerstein Ballroom in New York, June 14, 2014.  ?  I don?  t look like your typical pop star,?   says the pint-size 23-year-old British folk singer with a mop of red hair and an unassuming mien. ?  I don?  t sing songs like your typical pop star.” (Jesse Dittmar/The New York Times) -- PHOTO MOVED IN ADVANCE AND NOT FOR USE - ONLINE OR IN PRINT - BEFORE JUNE 22, 2014.
  3. Dates and itinerary for Tampa City Council trip to Cuba finalized


    TAMPA — The dates are set and the itinerary is largely finalized for the Tampa City Council's first official trip to Cuba since the Cuban Revolution.

    Tampa City Council Chairwoman Yvonne Yolie Capin will be a part of the city council delegation to Cuba this October. [Credit: City of Tampa]
  4. Survey: Few consumers shop for lower prices on health care


    Despite having more financial "skin in the game" than ever, many consumers don't make any attempt to compare prices for health care services, a newly released study found.

    Photo illustration. []
  5. And the most-searched NFL player in Florida is ...


    The Bucs just faced the Jacksonville Jaguars in preseason, and open their 2017 season at the Miami Dolphins. So with the state's NFL competition ahead of and just behind the Bucs, who do you think is the NFL player most searched on Google by Floridians?

    Fans react with excitement moments after the Bucs announce their first-round pick at the team's 2016 NFL draft party. [LOREN ELLIOTT | Times]