Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

For 16 hours of freedom, man could get 15 years in prison.

LARGO — The chief judge came to court on Wednesday — not to hear a case, but to sit in the witness stand and testify.

That's just one of the quirks in the escape trial of Nydeed Nashaddai, who is accused of using phony paperwork to spring himself out of the Pinellas County Jail last year.

Nashaddai, 45, was in jail last October awaiting trial on forgery charges. He somehow created a phony judge's order that looked realistic enough to get him released, prosecutors said.

The ruse, if that's what it was, won him 16 hours of freedom. It could cost him up to 15 years in prison if he's convicted.

Defense attorney Steve Bartlett said Nashaddai was erroneously released because of a mistake in the State Attorney's Office. But prosecutors said Nashaddai orchestrated the plan.

As evidence, they played recordings of Nashaddai's conversations with his wife and a friend from jail visits and phone calls. In one, Nashaddai pleaded with his wife to send him documents similar to the bogus one that later got him released. Doctored documents were later found in a jail computer that Nashaddai had access to. And the bogus document that was ultimately filed in the court system had Nashaddai's fingerprints on it, prosecutors said.

In one recording, Nashaddai talked to a friend who said he had filed some paperwork for Nashaddai at the Pinellas County Clerk's Office. "You're a lifesaver. I'll call you when I get out," Nashaddai told him, laughing. His friend said: "I was scared as s---, man." In another, Nashaddai got his wife to transfer a call to the Clerk's Office, and he then posed as an attorney, trying to make sure the paperwork had been properly filed.

The bogus document that got Nashaddai released appeared to be signed by Pinellas-Pasco Circuit Judge Thomas McGrady. He testified that he did not preside in any hearing in Nashaddai's case and certainly never ordered his release.

"The signature kind of looks like my signature, but this is not my order," McGrady said.

Bartlett asked if McGrady might have signed the document thinking it was genuine. McGrady said for that to happen, someone would have needed to present the order to him and told him that attorneys on both sides agreed to the order.

When Bartlett asked if that were possible, McGrady said in a skeptical tone, "It's possible."

McGrady later told a reporter this was the first time he had taken the witness stand because of his duties as a judge. He acknowledged feeling "a little anxiety" as he was questioned.

"I think that is a good lesson for the court," he said. "Judges and lawyers should know that people do get anxiety when they testify."

An assistant public defender and an assistant state attorney previously testified in the case, also saying the document that let Nashaddai out of jail was bogus.

For 16 hours of freedom, man could get 15 years in prison. 10/27/10 [Last modified: Wednesday, October 27, 2010 10:15pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Ex-daughter-in-law accused of $80,000 shopping spree with family Sam's Club account

    Human Interest

    TAMPA — Plenty of people have in-law horror stories. But perhaps not as vexing as the one Thomas and June Simpson tell.

    Police said Mishay Simpson shot Andrew Noll in 2014 after he entered her Davis Islands home. An investigation found the two had been having an affair. Now she is accused in a civil lawsuit of charging $80,000 to her ex-husband's Sam's Club card, which was linked to his parents' bank account. [Hillsborough County Sheriff's Office]
  2. Posh Guy Harvey RV park to open in Tampa Bay with $250,000 cottages


    Love those Guy Harvey T-shirts with the soaring marlins? In the not too distant future, you might be able to kick back in your own Guy Harvey cottage in the first-ever Guy Harvey RV park.

  3. Hard to believe NFL overtime change is about player safety


    If someone's house was engulfed in flames, would you hand him a fire extinguisher?

    Of course not.

    Fans await the beginning of overtime between the Patriots and Falcons in Super Bowl LI in February. [Associated Press]
  4. Winning high school essays urge balance in U.S. foreign, domestic spending


    Three winners were selected by a panel of judges from among 250 entrants to receive a $1,200 scholarship in the R.F. "Red" Pittman Tampa Tribune Scholars essay contest.

  5. Tampa Tribune scholarships inspire students to keep digging for facts



    When the Tampa Tribune launched a scholarship for Hillsborough County's top high school seniors more than 50 years ago, no one could have guessed it would one day be turned over to the newspaper's rival, now called the Tampa Bay Times.