Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Innocence Commission probes eyewitness mistakes in wrongful convictions

TAMPA — In a courtroom almost three decades ago, five victims identified Alan Crotzer as the man they saw rob them and rape a woman and a girl.

They were wrong.

But a jury believed them. He served 24 years in prison before DNA evidence set him free.

The lesson: Eyewitnesses make mistakes.

In Florida, 12 defendants have been exonerated by DNA. Nationally, the number is 261. In three-quarters of the wrongful convictions, misidentification played a role.

On Monday, a commission created by the Florida Supreme Court assembled in Tampa to dissect the problem. The Innocence Commission, made up of lawyers, legislators and judges, will spend two years tackling issues surrounding wrongful conviction and make recommendations that could become law.

The problem with eyewitness identification comes down to this, said Iowa State University psychology professor Gary Wells: Memory, like physical evidence, can be tainted.

One way that happens is through the standard police lineup. Traditionally, a witness will look at half a dozen mug shots at the same time and try to identify a suspect. People tend to pick the person who most resembles the culprit, Wells said, even if the actual criminal isn't depicted.

He said witnesses should get just one photo at a time. Studies show that forces people to dig deeper into their memories.

People are also influenced by cues they get from those showing the photos, he said. Detectives may unknowingly give nonverbal cues. Or they'll say things.

For example, "Now, take your time" might mean the witness is looking at the wrong face.

In one case, a witness said detectives applauded when she picked their suspect. That kind of affirmation can create an inflated sense of certainty in the mind of a witness, who will take it to trial.

The solution? Don't let detectives conduct the lineup, Wells said. Give the photos to someone who doesn't know which depicts the suspect.

Police departments across the country have started to use some of the techniques Wells mentioned. The Hillsborough County Sheriff's Office uses them both.

Cpl. Stephen Decatur said detectives give him photo lineups and he presents them one by one to witnesses without knowing which they're expected to choose.

Wells said Boston's conviction rate increased after the changes, and that more defendants in New Jersey are pleading guilty.

But there are critics.

Some at smaller police departments say they don't have the manpower to get an unrelated officer to conduct the lineup, much less testify about it in various stages of the legal case.

Bruce Bartlett, chief assistant state attorney for the Pinellas-Pasco State Attorney's Office, said he is troubled by what he sees as an unfair assumption.

"It suggests that your law enforcement is dishonest. And I'm sorry, but I'm not ready to accept that," he said. "I'm not saying mistakes don't happen, because they do. But I'm not ready to believe your cops are all crooked."

In most Tampa Bay police jurisdictions, case detectives with knowledge of the suspect are the ones to show lineups. Many department policies instruct them on what they can and can't say and do to avoid swaying witnesses.

Some show photos one at a time, including the Pinellas County Sheriff's Office, St. Petersburg police and Tampa police.

"We are always looking for ways to improve our process and stay on the cutting edge of law enforcement," said Tampa police spokeswoman Laura McElroy.

The Innocence Commission will have a January meeting in Jacksonville.

Times staff writers Ron Matus and Drew Harwell contributed to this report.

Innocence Commission probes eyewitness mistakes in wrongful convictions 11/22/10 [Last modified: Tuesday, November 23, 2010 5:22pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Florida education news: Solar eclipse, gender gap, new schools and more


    TOTAL ECLIPSE: More than 8,000 Hernando County students skip school after their school district gives them excused absences for the day. Students who …

    Students at Bayonet Point Middle School observe the solar eclipse Monday through their special eclipse glasses.
  2. Epilogue: Martin Giles a man of few, but strong, words for WFLA-AM 970


    As the story goes, his higher-ups at the Misawa Air Base in Japan were clear with their edict to Martin Giles: It was only the mid-1950s, not far enough away from World War II for the Japanese to be trusted.

    Martin Giles, a longtime radio news anchor for WFLA-AM 970, died last week at the age of 80.
  3. Forecast: Minimal rain, for now, as hot temperatures prevail across Tampa Bay


    Tampa Bay residents can expect a calm, rain-free start to Tuesday before showers arrive in the evening.

    Tampa Bay's 7 day forecast. [WTSP]
  4. Afghanistan reaction mixed on Trump's tough-talking speech


    KABUL, Afghanistan — Afghans on Tuesday welcomed U.S. President Donald Trump's harsh words for Pakistan in a speech outlining his strategy for the war-torn country that critics said offered little in the way of details and ruled out nation-building.

    President Donald Trump speaks at Fort Myer in Arlington Va., Monday, Aug. 21, 2017, during a Presidential Address to the Nation about a strategy he believes will best position the U.S. to eventually declare victory in Afghanistan. [Associated Press]