Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Is east Hillsborough crime up or down?

Ask residents around eastern Hillsborough County which way crime is going, and many will need only a one-word answer: up.

The singular question — Do you feel crime is on the rise? — produced a dozen replies with common themes.

Those who answered said crime in eastern Hillsborough had gone up or stayed the same. They had something else in common, too.

They're all wrong.

Crime during the first quarter of this year dropped in almost every major category in sheriff's Districts 2 and 4 compared to the same period in 2007, Sheriff's Office figures show.

The drop has been dramatic in some categories. Auto theft fell nearly 23 percent in District 2, which comprises areas north of Brandon's Lumsden Road. It also fell nearly 27 percent in District 4, which includes neighborhoods south of Lumsden Road. There were double-digit drops in robberies and burglaries of businesses in both districts.

Two exceptions to the downward trend: Home burglaries in District 2 jumped 7 percent and vehicle burglaries increased 2 percent in District 4.

The numbers from January through May look similar in Tampa, where residential burglaries dropped nearly 14 percent from a year ago, according to the Tampa Police Department. Auto theft and several types of robberies are also less frequent in Tampa so far this year.

"I think the perception is from everybody reading newspapers and watching television news," sheriff's spokeswoman Debbie Carter said. "A lot of times, people don't realize that they are listening to crime in other states, in other jurisdictions, or national news."

Some residents pointed to specific crimes. Margaret Hodgson of Seffner reported a "rash of crime" in her Parsons Pointe subdivision, including stolen lawn equipment from two homes.

Terry Moore of Brandon scans the weekly crime report published in newspapers.

"I try to get a feel for what is happening," Moore said. "Lately, incidents seem to have increased slightly."

Asked if it would surprise him to learn crime had gone down, Moore replied, "Probably."

In Sun City Center, Joye Gasser said she hadn't noticed a crime increase this year, but said the area is victimized seasonally by "professional gypsy thieves" who ransack seasonal residents' homes.

"They come in cars and dress where they look like they belong in the community," said Gasser, 77. "They're in and out very quickly."

As for the Sheriff's Office crime statistics, Gasser said, "I doubt very seriously if it's really going down."

Deputy Rob Thornton, who patrols Sun City Center, said most burglaries this summer have resulted from school-aged youths rifling through unlocked cars, not organized groups of criminals.

Rising gas prices have some residents worried about theft. Several people in Jerry Tootle's Apollo Beach neighborhood formed an informal crime-watch group to deter gasoline thieves. After someone siphoned the gas from his tank, Tootle said he had to drive to Brandon to find an auto parts store that had locking gas caps in stock.

He didn't bother to report the crime, and speculated that people shrugging off minor thefts could explain the apparent decrease.

"If there was real property damage I would report it," he said.

Jessica DeLeon of Advance Auto Parts in Ruskin said, "People are buying more locking gas caps in the last month."

But that could reflect a fear of crime as much as actual thefts. And why wouldn't residents fear crime, some might ask, given the ubiquitous signs along highways posted by the Sheriff's Office asking motorists to "Please help us," and a culture that seems obsessed with crime?

"Most people are not very knowledgeable about crime, but they have very strong opinions about it," said University of South Florida criminologist James Unnever,

Crime has been steadily dropping for the past decade, Unnever said, and hit record lows in the past few years.

Theories about why range from an aging baby-boom population to a stabilized crack cocaine market in the underworld.

Though the question to local residents only covered three months out of the year, the results mirror the national data.

"If you ask whether crime is going up or down," Unnever said, "close to half think it's increasing when it's decreasing."

He blames opportunistic politicians who drum up the fear of crime and an insatiable media appetite for it. He rejects the notion that tougher economic times cause more people to commit crimes.

His USF colleague, criminologist Richard Dembo, isn't so sure. "Economic downturns are associated with an increase in crime, particularly in property crimes," Dembo said.

If people feel engaged in society and that they have a stake in toeing the line for their advancement, they are more likely to be more social.

If they feel more disconnected and are having hard times, people who are at risk are more likely to go over the line and engage in criminal activity.

"We may see an increase in crime, if over time the economy doesn't improve," he said.

Times staff writer Saundra Amrhein contributed to this report. Andrew Meacham can be reached at (813) 661-2431 or

Only few categories show increase

Sheriff's District 2 (north of Lumsden Road)

Crime Jan.-May 2007 Jan.-May 2008 % change
Auto theft 476 367 -22.9
Burglary - business 234 200 -14.5
Burglary - residence 483 517 7
Burglary - vehicle 604 585 -3.1
Robbery - business 54 40 -25.9
Robbery -person 88 84 -4.5
Totals 1,939 1,793 -7.5

Sheriff's District 4 (Lumsden Road and south)

Crime Jan.-May 2007 Jan.-May 2008 % change
Auto theft 382 280 -26.7
Burglary - business 245 189 -22.9
Burglary - residence 772 556 -28
Burglary - vehicle 731 748 2.3
Robbery - business 44 37 -15.9
Robbery - person 61 48 -21.3
Totals 2,235 1,858 -16.9

Source: Hillsborough County Sheriff's Office

Is east Hillsborough crime up or down? 07/17/08 [Last modified: Monday, November 1, 2010 4:09pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Senate GOP leaders face tough job in selling health-care bill to their members


    WASHINGTON — Senate Republican leaders on Thursday moved swiftly to begin selling their health-care measure to substantially rewrite the Affordable Care Act to their wary members as they seek to garner enough support to pass the bill in an expected vote next week.

    U.S. Senate Republicans on Thursday unveiled a proposal to repeal and replace the Affordable Care Act. The bill's chief author, Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, has said "Obamacare is collapsing around us, and the American people are desperately searching for relief." [AP]
  2. Rick Scott eyes Patronis as CFO, but it may not help him in Panhandle

    State Roundup

    TALLAHASSEE — Gov. Rick Scott's expected pick of Jimmy Patronis as the state's next Chief Financial Officer would be a solid addition to the Republican Party ticket but may not do much to smooth some rough waters developing in the Panhandle over schools, area Republicans said this week.

    Former state Rep. Jimmy Patronis, left, is being considered by Gov. Rick Scott for the state's chief financial officer. Patronis, seen with Scott in 2011, is considered one of the governor's chief loyalists. 

  3. Marco Rubio says he's studying Florida impacts of health care bill


    Sen. Marco Rubio is declining to take a position for now on the health care bill, saying he'll take time to study the effect on Florida.

  4. Women of 'GLOW' talk heart of cheesy '80s wrestling and their favorite moves


    The Gorgeous Ladies of Wrestling are back this summer, this time as a fictionalized dramedy on Netflix.

    Sydelle Noel, left, and Kia Stevens in GLOW.
  5. Aubrey Plaza smokes marijuana with the "Weed Nuns" (w/ video)