Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Judge backs Florida drug possession law, but lawyers' fight goes on

BROOKSVILLE — Defense attorneys didn't win the battle in court Wednesday, but the war over the state's drug possession rule isn't over.

For the second time this month, lawyers from around the state presented motions in a Hernando County courtroom asserting that the Florida's Drug Abuse Prevention and Control law violates the due process clause of the U.S. Constitution's 14th Amendment. At least three Florida judges — one in federal court and two at the circuit level — recently ruled that the statute was unlawful.

Here, Chief Circuit Judge Daniel Merritt Sr. questioned the statute's constitutionality, but he ultimately denied the motions, noting that two of Florida's five District Courts of Appeal have decreed that the rule is constitutional.

In an interview before the hearings this month, prosecutor Donald "Sonny" McCathran said Merritt would be bound by those decisions.

Still, Brooksville attorney Jimmy Brown, among those who filed the motions, wasn't discouraged by the judge's decision.

"The judge said that he agrees with a lot of the points that I raised," Brown said. "And he has significant questions about the viability and the constitutionality of the statute."

Under the law, defendants can be convicted of a felony merely by possessing an illegal drug, regardless of what they mean to do with it or if they even knew what they had is illegal.

The law was created nearly 10 years ago in response to a Florida Supreme Court order that judges should always instruct juries to consider defendants' intent when deciding their guilt or innocence on drug possession charges. Lawmakers in 2002 amended the statute, becoming the only state in the nation to eradicate "guilty knowledge," also called mens rea.

The attorneys argue that stipulation makes the statute invalid, and two recent rulings supported their motions: one in August by South Florida Circuit Judge Milton Hirsch and the other on Friday by Tampa-area Circuit Judge Scott M. Brownell.

The statute "does not punish the drug dealer who possesses or delivers controlled substances. It punishes anyone who possesses or delivers controlled substances, however inadvertently, however accidently, however unintentionally," Hirsch wrote in his opinion.

"It reaches beyond those who willfully do wrong, beyond those who negligently do wrong, beyond those who carelessly do wrong, and includes within its wingspan those who meant no wrong."

Brownell further illustrated the point in his opinion, offering three feasible situations in which a person might inadvertently violate the law but still be convicted of the crime: A letter carrier who delivers a package containing unprescribed Adderall; a roommate who is unaware that the person sharing his apartment has hidden illegal drugs in the common areas of the home; a mother carrying a prescription pill bottle in her purse, unaware that the medication has been substituted for illegally obtained drugs by her teenage daughter, who placed them in the bottle to avoid detection.

"As the examples illustrate," Brownell wrote, "even people who are normally diligent in inspecting and organizing their possessions may find themselves unexpectedly in violation of this law, and without the notice necessary to defend their rights." Inevitably, the Brooksville attorney Brown said, the Florida Supreme Court will rule on this issue and, as an extension, determine whether the 97,000 people convicted of the crime since 2002 should be exonerated.

"We're going to get there," Brown said. "It's just a question of when."

John Woodrow Cox can be reached at (352) 848-1432 or

Judge backs Florida drug possession law, but lawyers' fight goes on 09/21/11 [Last modified: Wednesday, September 21, 2011 10:54pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Police: Uber driver's gun discharges during fight at Adventure Island in Tampa

    Public Safety

    TAMPA — An Uber driver's gun went off Sunday at Adventure Island during a fight between the driver and two passengers.

  2. Baker cautious on Pride politics


    Rick and Joyce Baker strode down Central Avenue Sunday amid rainbow flags, corporate booths, and blaring music of the St. Pete Pride Festival.

    St. Petersburg mayoral candidate Rick Baker chats Sunday with people at the St. Pete Pride Festival. As mayor, Baker did not sign a Pride parade proclamation, but now he says he would.
  3. Rays' bullpen stars lit up in loss to Orioles

    The Heater

    ST. PETERSBURG — Saturday it was the soft underbelly of the bullpen that let one get away from the Rays, incurring the wrath of the team's faithful followers, who wondered why the high-leverage guys weren't pitching.

    Rays closer Alex Colome, coming in with the score tied in the ninth, allows three runs in his second straight poor outing.
  4. Lightning among early suitors for defenseman Kevin Shattenkirk

    Lightning Strikes

    TAMPA — Lightning general manager Steve Yzerman said he planned to explore free agency for potential needs, which include bolstering his blue line and adding a wing or two.

    Defenseman Kevin Shattenkirk, who can be a free agent Saturday, counts the Lightning among his early suitors.
  5. Senate leaders try to appease members as support for health bill slips


    WASHINGTON — Senate Republican leaders scrambled Sunday to rally support for their health care bill, even as opposition continued to build outside Congress and two Republican senators questioned whether the bill would be approved this week.

    Sen. Rand Paul of Kentucky, speaking to reporters on Capitol Hill on Thursday, is one of the five Republican senators who announced they cannot support the health care bill as drafted.