Wednesday, December 13, 2017
News Roundup

Judge rules man accused of killing University of Tampa student mentally fit for trial

TAMPA — Despite expert testimony that David Earl Williams Jr. is mentally retarded and possibly a paranoid schizophrenic, a judge ruled Friday that Williams is competent to stand trial in the 2009 murder of a University of Tampa student.

Williams, 23, is competent to proceed to trial on charges of first-degree murder and robbery, Hillsborough Circuit Judge Christopher Sabella said. Williams is accused of fatally shooting Ryan McCall, 21, as he walked home with a friend along Boulevard Bridge on the night of Aug. 19, 2009.

"It is a very serious issue," Sabella said. Mental competency — different from insanity, which can be invoked as a defense at trial — means that a defendant can understand the legal proceedings against him and assist in his own defense.

Kevin McCall, Ryan's father, attended the hearing and welcomed the judge's ruling. The criminal justice system has moved slowly on the case: Three years passed after Ryan's death before Williams was arrested, and more than a year to get him in front of a judge to determine competency.

"It's been a long time," McCall said, adding that the judge's ruling was "what it should have been." The testimony of the four experts who weighed in on Williams' competency, McCall said, "was very professionally done."

Two of those experts said they did not believe Williams was competent to stand trial, based on mental and emotional problems that appear to be legion.

This year, Williams' IQ was measured at 59. Those with IQs below 70 are generally considered to be mentally retarded.

During an interview with a psychologist last month in jail, he complained of hearing voices telling him to cut himself and seeing "demons and devils," according to Tampa psychologist Valerie McClain. Hired by Williams' defense team, McClain said he was not competent to proceed.

Monica Epstein, another psychologist who found him incompetent to stand trial, said jail personnel reported seeing Williams unexpectedly begin jumping up and down, laughing, or banging his head into a wall. In one interview, Epstein said, Williams "indicated that the prosecutor wanted to kill him and had gone so far as to send people into the jail to poison his food."

Yet two other experts, while acknowledging that William has low intelligence and emotional issues, said they did not believe some of his statements about not understanding what was happening to him in court.

Psychiatrist Donald Taylor Jr. said Williams clearly expressed odd views of the court system.

"When I asked him what the role of the jury was, he said, 'Their role is to kill somebody,' " Taylor recounted.

However, he said this was likely just "an immature outlook on what the legal process is" rather than a "delusional belief system."

Psychologist Richard Carpenter said that while Williams might be "in the high range of mild mental retardation," he did not see evidence that Williams was psychotic to the point that he could not stand trial.

"He's not the most gifted defendant. He could be challenging for his defense counsel," Carpenter said. "But I think he has the basics to be judged as competent to proceed."

Williams, a somber-faced young man with a shaved head, stood up for the first moments of the hearing. He sat only when the judge informed him, "You don't have to stand during this entire proceeding."

He then sat placidly as the lawyers and doctors discussed his mind, leaning forward at times to stare at his attorneys or rocking back and forth in his seat.

Staff writer Dan Sullivan contributed to this report. Peter Jamison can be reached at [email protected].

Comments
Hometown Pasco for Dec. 15

Hometown Pasco for Dec. 15

We want your news!Hometown Pasco is devoted to everyday life in our county, whether it’s snapshots from your family reunion, recreational sporting event, news from your last club meeting or just a few lines thanking someone for a job well done. You ...
Updated: 16 minutes ago
Top 5 at Noon: Home flipping starts flopping in Tampa Bay; Gasparilla Music Fest lineup is big; Free McDonald's McNugget Day

Top 5 at Noon: Home flipping starts flopping in Tampa Bay; Gasparilla Music Fest lineup is big; Free McDonald's McNugget Day

Our top stories today at noon.
Updated: 18 minutes ago
Pasco Business Digest for Dec. 15

Pasco Business Digest for Dec. 15

Business digestWho’s newsHOSPITAL APPOINTS ASSISTANT CHIEF NURSING OFFICER: Registered nurse Courtney Stephenson, board certified nurse executive advanced, was recently appointed assistant chief nursing officer at Medical Center of Trinity. Stephenso...
Updated: 22 minutes ago

Hernando Vendors for Dec. 15

Vendors are needed for the following nonprofit events:• Vendors and volunteers are being sought for a National Homeless Persons’ Memorial Day event from 8 a.m. to 3 p.m. Dec. 21 at Crescent Community Clinic, 5244 Commercial Way, Spring Hill. During t...
Updated: 24 minutes ago
Tampa airport ranks No. 4 for most affordable parking rates

Tampa airport ranks No. 4 for most affordable parking rates

TAMPA — Holiday flight prices may be high, but parking rates at Tampa International Airport are a little more manageable. TIA has the fourth-cheapest parking rates in the country, a study by travel and expense app company TravelBank said. TIA, the st...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Dunedin City Commission punts decision on paid parking

Dunedin City Commission punts decision on paid parking

DUNEDIN — At 1 a.m. Wednesday, after seven hours of public input and back-and-forth discussion on the dais, the City Commission failed to agree on a path forward for the downtown paid parking trial program that was scheduled to expire Tuesday.Instead...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Hernando could be next stop for PACE Center for Girls

Hernando could be next stop for PACE Center for Girls

BROOKSVILLE — The new year could bring about new beginnings for at-risk girls in Hernando County.Pending a vote by the School Board next month, PACE Center for Girls, an alternative education program for middle- and high-school students, could open a...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Hometown Hernando for Dec. 15

Hometown Hernando for Dec. 15

We want your news!Hometown Hernando is devoted to everyday life in our county, whether it’s snapshots from your family reunion, recreational sporting event, news from your last club meeting or just a few lines thanking someone for a job well done. Y...
Updated: 1 hour ago

Hernando Government Meetings for Dec. 15

Here is a listing of public meetings scheduled for this week:MondayBrooksville City Council, 7 p.m., council chambers, City Hall, 201 Howell Ave., Brooksville.TuesdayBrooksville Housing Authority Board Meeting, 5 p.m. council chambers, City Hall, 201...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Pinellas sheriff to announce findings of excessive force investigation

Pinellas sheriff to announce findings of excessive force investigation

Pinellas County Sheriff Bob Gualtieri will announce Wednesday the findings of an internal investigation sparked by dashboard camera video that appears to show deputies beating, choking and yanking the hair of a 25-year-old man during an arrest.Gualti...
Updated: 1 hour ago