Make us your home page
Instagram

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Judge's decision in Brantley case unpopular but right

Hang around criminal courtrooms long enough, and you'll likely witness a kind of judge with a certain attitude on justice.

It goes like this: A decision has to be made before a high-profile case goes to trial. Are the charges too harsh? Should they have even been filed?

This particular brand of judge tends to shrug and say, "Let a jury sort it out." He does not say, "I wouldn't want anyone thinking I'm soft on crime," at least not out loud.

Which might make you wonder why we have judges, or prosecutors, since hard calls are in the job description.

U.S. District Court Judge James Moody just handed down a tough decision in a case as impassioned and inflamed as it gets, because it is tied to this summer's murders of two Tampa police officers, David Curtis and Jeffrey Kocab.

Moody — who, by the way, is nobody's idea of a pink-bellied, bleeding-heart guy — threw out the case against the sometime-girlfriend of Dontae Morris, who can get the death penalty if convicted of killing the two officers. It's the kind of call judges need to be able to make.

Police say Cortnee Brantley was driving a car that night with Morris in the passenger seat when they were pulled over. As the officers were arresting Morris on a bad check warrant, there were gunshots. She sped off. Morris ran in a different direction. He was on the lam for days before he was arrested.

There isn't much to like about what Brantley, who is 22, did that night. She traded phone messages with Morris and agreed to "stay loyal." Though she answered some questions over several hours with police, she refused to name her passenger.

But the rarely sighted "misprision of a felony" charge she faced in federal court was such a stretch, you could almost see the duct tape holding it together. It goes like this: She knew he was a felon with a loaded gun, didn't report it and "willfully" concealed the crime.

But the judge said it was not enough for her to intend to conceal it or talk about concealing it — she had to take an actual, affirmative step to hide his crime to be guilty.

So where's the concealing? There was no evidence she cleaned or hid the car. And doesn't she have the same fundamental right to remain silent as you or me?

In the more than four months since the officers were killed, state prosecutors have declined to charge Brantley with anything, such as being an accessory after the fact, presumably because there is no evidence she did anything to directly help Morris.

Despite how some people feel about her role that night.

Maybe now you're thinking of Bernice Bowen, who went to prison after her boyfriend, Hank Earl Carr, used a hidden handcuff key to escape arrest and ultimately killed three police officers.

Notably, the appeals court that threw out some of her convictions said she "had no legal duty to volunteer to the police any knowledge she possessed about Carr's handcuff key." Even if it would have made all the difference.

What happened that night in June is a tragedy and a horror. Hard to blame those who want Brantley to pay for something, anything.

But in a courthouse in the cold light of day, a judge decided it would be wrong to hold her responsible when someone else killed two good cops.

The judge did his job.

Judge's decision in Brantley case unpopular but right 11/02/10 [Last modified: Tuesday, November 2, 2010 8:14pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times

    

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

Loading...
  1. Florida ethics board to hear Go Hillsborough complaint against Buckhorn, Hagan, Murman

    Blogs

    TAMPA — Two years after complaints accused Tampa and Hillsborough County elected leaders of steering a transportation contract to a politically connected firm, the state’s ethics police will finally hear the case.

    Florida Commission on Ethics will hear complaints next month against Tampa Mayor Bob Buckhorn and Hillsborough County Commissioner Ken Hagan, as well as Commissioner Sandy Murman.
  2. Don't expect to see protests in college football any time soon

    College

    The whispers have segued to chatter. In time, it may evolve into rumblings, or even a groundswell.

    Following the national anthem, helicopters fly over Ohio Stadium in a missing-man formation in tribute to John Glenn before a game between Army and Ohio State in Columbus, Ohio, on Saturday, Sept. 16, 2017. (Barbara J. Perenic/Columbus Dispatch/TNS)
  3. AAA expects gas prices in Tampa Bay will continue to fall

    Autos

    Ticking slowly and steadily, regular gas prices have receded for the last 10 consecutive days. The average unleaded gas price in Florida is $2.67 this morning, a nickel cheaper than a week ago. In Tampa Bay, the current average unleaded gas has dropped 7 cents from a week ago to $2.62. The national average for regular …

    Gas prices for regular gas continue to decline. In Tampa Bay, the current average unleaded gas is down 7 cents from a week ago at $2.62 a gallon. [Times file photo]
  4. Restaurant review: Mortar & Pestle in Seminole Heights should focus on mom-and-pop pharmacy vibe

    Food & Dining

    By Laura Reiley

    Times Food Critic

    TAMPA

    Sometimes, the more time you have with a project, the more complicated it gets. I started hearing about Mortar & Pestle in Seminole Heights about 18 months ago. It was the vision of Ujwal Patel, a pharmacist;

    Mortar & Pestle opened in Seminole Heights in Tampa in August. [MONICA HERNDON   |   Times]
  5. Snap Judgment's Glynn Washington on growing up in a 'cult' and how to tell a good story

    Events

    Glynn Washington spent much of his last visit to Tampa preparing his soul for the impending apocalypse. He was assured it was coming any day.

    Glynn Washington, the creator and host of NPR's "Snap Judgment," will bring his live show to the Tampa Theatre on Sept. 29. 
Photo courtesy Snap Judgment