Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Judge's decision in Brantley case unpopular but right

Hang around criminal courtrooms long enough, and you'll likely witness a kind of judge with a certain attitude on justice.

It goes like this: A decision has to be made before a high-profile case goes to trial. Are the charges too harsh? Should they have even been filed?

This particular brand of judge tends to shrug and say, "Let a jury sort it out." He does not say, "I wouldn't want anyone thinking I'm soft on crime," at least not out loud.

Which might make you wonder why we have judges, or prosecutors, since hard calls are in the job description.

U.S. District Court Judge James Moody just handed down a tough decision in a case as impassioned and inflamed as it gets, because it is tied to this summer's murders of two Tampa police officers, David Curtis and Jeffrey Kocab.

Moody — who, by the way, is nobody's idea of a pink-bellied, bleeding-heart guy — threw out the case against the sometime-girlfriend of Dontae Morris, who can get the death penalty if convicted of killing the two officers. It's the kind of call judges need to be able to make.

Police say Cortnee Brantley was driving a car that night with Morris in the passenger seat when they were pulled over. As the officers were arresting Morris on a bad check warrant, there were gunshots. She sped off. Morris ran in a different direction. He was on the lam for days before he was arrested.

There isn't much to like about what Brantley, who is 22, did that night. She traded phone messages with Morris and agreed to "stay loyal." Though she answered some questions over several hours with police, she refused to name her passenger.

But the rarely sighted "misprision of a felony" charge she faced in federal court was such a stretch, you could almost see the duct tape holding it together. It goes like this: She knew he was a felon with a loaded gun, didn't report it and "willfully" concealed the crime.

But the judge said it was not enough for her to intend to conceal it or talk about concealing it — she had to take an actual, affirmative step to hide his crime to be guilty.

So where's the concealing? There was no evidence she cleaned or hid the car. And doesn't she have the same fundamental right to remain silent as you or me?

In the more than four months since the officers were killed, state prosecutors have declined to charge Brantley with anything, such as being an accessory after the fact, presumably because there is no evidence she did anything to directly help Morris.

Despite how some people feel about her role that night.

Maybe now you're thinking of Bernice Bowen, who went to prison after her boyfriend, Hank Earl Carr, used a hidden handcuff key to escape arrest and ultimately killed three police officers.

Notably, the appeals court that threw out some of her convictions said she "had no legal duty to volunteer to the police any knowledge she possessed about Carr's handcuff key." Even if it would have made all the difference.

What happened that night in June is a tragedy and a horror. Hard to blame those who want Brantley to pay for something, anything.

But in a courthouse in the cold light of day, a judge decided it would be wrong to hold her responsible when someone else killed two good cops.

The judge did his job.

Judge's decision in Brantley case unpopular but right 11/02/10 [Last modified: Tuesday, November 2, 2010 8:14pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. The Iron Yard coding academy to close in St. Petersburg


    ST. PETERSBURG — The Iron Yard, a code-writing academy with a location in downtown St. Petersburg, will close for good this summer.

    Instructors (from left) Mark Dewey, Jason Perry, and Gavin Stark greet the audience at The Iron Yard, 260 1st Ave. S, in St. Petersburg during "Demo Day" Friday, Oct. 7, 2016, at The Iron Yard, which is an immersive code school that is part of a trend of trying to address the shortage of programmers.  The academy is closing this summer.  [LARA CERRI   |   Times]
  2. Florida's unemployment rate drops for fourth straight month


    How low can Florida's unemployment go? Pretty low, according to the state's latest unemployment numbers. The Sunshine State's unemployment rate dropped to 4.1 percent for June, down from 4.3 percent in May, state officials said Friday morning.

    Florida's unemployment level dropped to 4.1 percent in June from 4.3 percent in May. |  [Times file photo]
  3. 20 great images from around the globe for July 14 to July 21


    Photos of the week for July 14 - July 21: A giant sinkhole swallows homes in Florida, a desperate rescue attempt in Karachi, synchronized swimmers competing in Budapest, a rainy rugby match in Australia, a smiling O.J. Simpson in Nevada and more.

    A lobsterman's boat leaves a gentle wake as he motors out of a harbor on a foggy morning, Friday, July 21, 2017, in Boothbay, Maine. (AP Photo/Robert F. Bukaty)
  4. Is sinkhole damage sinking Tampa Bay property values?

    Real Estate

    On a scale of desirability, the house for sale on Whittner Drive in Land O' Lakes would rank fairly low. It's a short sale; it sits on an unstabilized sinkhole and it's within a few miles of two houses that collapsed into a gargantuan hole July 16.

    A gated community in Hernando's Spring Hill area, Pristine Place has long been susceptible to sinkholes with nearly a third of its houses with documented sinkhole damage by 2012. Today, however, many houses with repaired sinkhole damage are selling for more than houses without any issues. [WILL VRAGOVIC   |   Times file photo]
  5. Disabled Tampa man takes his story to center of health care debate


    Michael Phillips was hunting demons Monday night when the news broke: The Senate health care bill was dying.

    (Left) Karen Clay, 64, operates a medical ventilator to help her son Michael Phillips, 36, breath. Michael has spinal muscular atrophy and is confined to his bed. He can breath only with the aid of a machine. Here, they are photographed at their Tampa home Wednesday, July 19, 2017. Michael and his family have been closely watching the upcoming health care vote and how it would affect them.