Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Judge seats jury in Dontae Morris trial

Dontae Morris’ murder trial in the slaying of two police officers will start next week in Tampa.

Dontae Morris’ murder trial in the slaying of two police officers will start next week in Tampa.

ORLANDO — A jury was sworn in Thursday to decide whether Dontae Morris is guilty of killing two police officers, setting the stage for a trial next week in one of the Tampa Bay area's most closely watched murder cases.

The jury — an eclectic group that includes a physical therapist, an airline pilot and a retired trucker — was seated despite serious concerns expressed by defense attorneys, and even one prospective juror, about irregularities in the selection process. Those problems could linger over the rest of Morris' trial, since they would likely form the basis of an appeal if he is convicted.

Morris, 28, faces two counts of first-degree murder for the deaths of Tampa police officers David Curtis and Jeffrey Kocab. Authorities say Morris shot the officers in the head during a routine traffic stop in 2010. If the jury of eight men and four women finds him guilty, they will have to recommend whether he should be executed.

Over four slow-going days, prosecutors, defense attorneys and Hillsborough Circuit Judge William Fuente grilled a group of 150 prospective jurors, all of them from the Orlando area on topics ranging from their professions to their views of capital punishment. The judge was seeking out-of-town jurors who had not seen or heard news reports of the case.

The process went awry — irretrievably so, according to defense attorneys — on Wednesday afternoon. While being questioned about her willingness to impose the death penalty, an 80-year-old woman blurted out that she would have no problem delivering a death verdict for someone who was being convicted of murder for the second time.

"I have a little theory," said the juror, Gloria Kaasa of Orlando. "If you are in court and you have been charged and found guilty of first-degree murder, you are wasting our taxpayers' money to do another performance and another performance."

She added, "If you are sentenced for one thing and brought in for another crime, if you are wasting taxpayers' money, you are guilty, guilty, guilty."

Her comments were made in front of the 75 remaining jurors in the pool, including those who were ultimately selected for jury service. Questioned alone after other potential jurors were led out of the courtroom, Kaasa admitted she knew the details of Morris' case and had been referring to his conviction in March for an unrelated murder.

Fuente dismissed Kaasa from jury service, but said selection could continue because her remarks were too vague to have been understood by her fellow jury candidates. Defense lawyers argued on Wednesday, and again on Thursday, that the damage had been done.

"She was specifically referencing a repeat performance, coming back and coming back after a conviction," attorney Chris Boldt said. "Clearly those are references to an unrelated homicide conviction."

The judge has ruled that all information about Morris' earlier case is off-limits in the upcoming double-murder trial. In the intensely detail-oriented world of death penalty litigation, the risk that Kaasa's comments might have prejudiced the jury is almost certain to be a central issue in Morris' appeal if he is sentenced to death.

"This is not only going to be raised, it's going to be talked about extensively in an appellate brief," said Tampa criminal defense attorney Lyann Goudie, who is not involved with the case. "Because you have this whole specter hanging over it."

Goudie said she was surprised that Fuente, whom she praised as a careful and fair-minded judge, did not choose to start over with a fresh pool of jurors. Proceeding on the current course, she said, opens the possibility that after a time-consuming and emotionally fraught trial, Morris' case might have to be relitigated — another jury, another trial, another verdict — if he is convicted only to have his sentence reversed.

"Do you want to do this all over again?" Goudie said. "Better safe than sorry."

Another, less serious snag in jury selection occurred Thursday when a male juror asked to speak to the judge alone after lunch. He said he worried that a comment one of his fellow jurors had made in front of the entire group had prejudiced the jury.

The woman said in court that after watching TV coverage of the case, "In my heart right now, I believe he is guilty."

The man who addressed Fuente said he worried about "somebody coming back later and saying it was a tainted jury pool" because of the woman's remark. He added, "Over the lunch break, I kept hearing that in my mind. It wasn't influencing me, but it just seemed like something that shouldn't have been said in this setting and could be prejudicial."

After the juror assured Fuente that the comment had not influenced him personally, the judge again said jury selection could continue.

Arguments and testimony in the trial begin Tuesday. On Monday, the 12 jurors and four alternates will be taken to Tampa and placed under guard in a hotel, where they will remain until the trial is over. Fuente said this week he hopes that the trial will take five days or less.

Judge seats jury in Dontae Morris trial 11/07/13 [Last modified: Thursday, November 7, 2013 11:17pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Lightning approaches decision time for Mikhail Sergachev

    Lightning Strikes

    COLUMBUS, Ohio — Mikhail Sergachev had dinner with his host family from juniors Monday.

    The Lightning has to decide, as early as this weekend whether Mikhail Sergachev will stick in the NHL or return to juniors for another season. [DOUGLAS R. CLIFFORD | Times]
  2. Tampa man charged in hit-and-run crash that killed bicyclist on I-4 exit ramp in Tampa


    TAMPA — A 44-year-old Tampa was arrested and charged Wednesday in a hit-and-run crash that killed a bicyclist earlier in the day.

    Christopher Jerimiah Cole, 44, of Tampa was driving this silver Mercedes on Wednesday when it struck a bicyclist on the exit ramp from eastbound Interstate 4 to southbound U.S. 301, according to the Florida Highway Patrol. Cole kept driving, troopers said. The bicyclist, a 45-year-old Brandon man, died at the scene. His name was not immediately released because troopers were working to notify his family. [Florida Highway Patrol]
  3. Quarterbacks, head coach targeting Vernon Hargreaves; 'I'm not producing,' he says


    Eli Manning gathered his receivers together during the Giants' Week 4 game against the Bucs and informed them of the weakest link of the secondary he planned to target that afternoon.

    Quarterbacks this season have a 128.7 rating when targeting Vernon Hargreaves. [LOREN ELLIOTT   |   Times]
  4. Rick Baker's radio ad said Rick Kriseman missed NAACP event---but he didn't.


    A radio ad narrated by St. Petersburg civil rights activist Sevell Brown and paid for by a political-action committee supporting Rick Baker asserts that Mayor Rick Kriseman "couldn't be bothered to show up" for a recent NAACP event.

    Rick Kriseman didn't skip recent NAACP event, but Rick Baker radio ad claims he did
  5. Demolition begins on wing of Channelside Bay Plaza, making way for Water Street Tampa (w/video)


    TAMPA — The original developers of Channelside Bay Plaza at first wanted the name of the complex to include the word "Garrison." That would have fit, because the center turned out to be fort-like, inwardly focused and unwelcoming.

    A pedestrian bridge in the southwest wing of Channelside Bay Plaza was demolished in Tampa on Wednesday, Oct. 18, 2017. [Gabriella Angotti-Jones  | Times]