Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Just one more question on Debra Lafave

Does anyone else's head hurt with this latest on Debra Lafave?

Though I admit my first thought at the news was: Oh happy day. She might finally go away.

Though not away-away. The notorious teacher whose blue-eyed-blonde looks sent the story of how she had sex with a 14-year-old student global managed to dodge the chance of going "away" through a plea deal in 2005 — one crafted to keep the teenager himself out of the media glare.

So here was Lafave back in court this week, cameras faithfully following, asking a judge to let her off probation four years early. Because it's darn inconvenient to be home by 10 p.m., much less to stay in Hillsborough County all the time. Though it's probably preferable to having your curfew determined by lights-out on the prison block and your travels limited by the bars of your cell.

But, hey, can't hurt to have your lawyer go in and ask, right? Worst case, the judge gives you the stink-eye and sends you home to finish your sentence like you were supposed to. And if you're really lucky, he modifies your probation to make life a little easier.

What happened was: None of the above. End your sentence years early? Sure, Circuit Judge Wayne Timmerman said. Why not?

So at first I thought: Well, hallelujah. No more national coverage of this distasteful case. No more snide asides about how "lucky" the kid was. No more Hot For Teacher references lodging Van Halen in your brain all day.

But then there was the matter of that plea deal Lafave agreed to.

Yes, she completed the strict requirements of her house arrest, and her sex offender classes and community service. Yes, judges everywhere routinely end probation early.

But here's the part Timmerman did not seem to hear, though prosecutor Michael Sinacore gave it his best shot: As part of the deal that potentially kept her out of prison, she specifically agreed to fully finish her probation.

"Basically," Sinacore said to the judge, "you've told the parties the agreement did not matter," which pretty much sums it up.

Lafave's lawyer John Fitzgibbons, who earned his wages and then some here, mentioned she is a new mother with preemie twins and the judge joked with her about it. He also verbally thumbed his nose at Nancy Grace, who criticized him on CNN for accepting the deal in the first place.

And instead of being relieved at the idea of no more Lafave, I'm thinking: What is he thinking?

Will teachers suddenly feel free to have sexual relationships with students because, hey, look at the break Debbie got? No. But isn't it in part the judge's job to make sure she completes requirements of the deal — the one the victim's family signed off on in good faith?

Fun fact: It appears Lafave still can't make money selling the story of her crimes. But off probation, she is no longer barred from benefitting from her notoriety, meaning she could potentially appear on commercials, in magazines or on, I don't know, Dancing With The Defendants.

Prosecutors will ask for a stay and an appeals court review of whether a judge's decision indeed trumps a plea agreement. It deserves an answer — even if it means more Van Halen, more snide asides and more Debra Lafave.

Just one more question on Debra Lafave 09/23/11 [Last modified: Friday, September 23, 2011 10:19pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. South Florida poaches debris pickup trucks once slotted for Tampa, officials say


    TAMPA — A week into the job of picking up an estimated 300,000 cubic yards of Hurricane Irma debris from its streets, Tampa City Hall is finding to its dismay that the challenge is more competitive than expected.

    A city of Tampa truck loaded with debris from Hurricane Irma pulls into a temporary storage yard on N Rome Avenue Friday morning. There, workers from Tetra Tech, the city's debris monitoring contractor, photograph and check the load from an elevated platform to create a record that the city can use later to seek reimbursement from the Federal Emergency Management Agency.
  2. Wisniewska: I protected our students and USFSP campus


    Throughout my tenure in academia, my focus has always been on putting students first.

    The USF St. Petersburg Campus, Thursday, June 19, 2014.
  3. Bucs defensive end Chris Baker (90) is seen during training camp last month at One Buc Place. [LOREN ELLIOTT   |   Times]
  4. Bucs' defensive attributes in opener included flexibility


    TAMPA — It's a blink-and-you-miss-it nuance, but in Sunday's opener against Chicago, on their very first defensive snap, the Bucs lined up in a 3-4 defense.

    Tampa Bay Buccaneers head coach Dirk Koetter shakes hands with cornerback Brent Grimes (24) before an NFL game between the Chicago Bears and Tampa Bay Buccaneers at Raymond James Stadium in Tampa, Fla., on Sunday, Sept. 17, 2017. LOREN ELLIOTT   |   Times 

  5. Along the Alafia River, the grateful extend a hand to the Irma-sodden weary (w/video)


    LITHIA — The things that make a house a home dried in the afternoon sun Thursday in a front yard on Williams Street.

    Volunteers from FishHawk Fellowship Church helped Brian Hood (left) clean up debris from his yard in Valrico, Fla. Last week the Alafia River reached a depth of almost 23 feet, about 10 feet above its flood stage. Many homes were damaged, some became uninhabitable. Hood's home is 6 inches above Lithia Pinecrest Road, and did not sustain flood damage, though not all of his neighbors were as lucky.   [MONICA HERNDON   |   Times]