Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Lawyer argues for new trial in '87 Lakeland slaying

Appellate attorneys Richard Bartmon, left, and Scott Cupp, center, talk with Leo Schofield’s wife, Crissie Schofield, after a hearing Wednesday at the 2nd District Court of Appeal. Judges listened to arguments but have no deadline to make a decision in the case.


Appellate attorneys Richard Bartmon, left, and Scott Cupp, center, talk with Leo Schofield’s wife, Crissie Schofield, after a hearing Wednesday at the 2nd District Court of Appeal. Judges listened to arguments but have no deadline to make a decision in the case.

TAMPA — Appellate judges considering whether a man serving a life sentence for murdering his wife should get a new trial had pointed questions Wednesday for his lawyers.

Leo Schofield's attorneys want to raise the violent history of another suspect in the murder, but judges from the 2nd District Court of Appeal questioned whether that evidence would even be admissible in court.

The judges noted that a lower court judge knew about that history — and about fingerprint evidence Schofield's lawyers are asking them to look at — but still wouldn't grant a new trial. So why, the appellate judges asked, should they be any more impressed?

In early 1987, Schofield's wife, Michelle, was found stabbed to death, floating in a Lakeland canal. Her abandoned red Mazda was found 7 miles away, with her blood in it.

Schofield's murder trial was based entirely on circumstantial evidence.

Witnesses said they saw Schofield hit his wife in the months before her death. A neighbor said she heard the couple arguing in their trailer on the night Michelle disappeared and saw Leo carry something resembling a sleeping child to the Mazda.

The prosecution said Leo stabbed Michelle 26 times in the trailer — even though no blood was found there — and took her body to the canal in the Mazda. Other witnesses questioned the neighbor's version of events, but a jury convicted Schofield.

Then, in 2004, mysterious fingerprints in the Mazda were identified as belonging to Jeremy Scott, who was serving a life sentence for murder and had a history of violent crimes. Scott lived a few miles from the canal where Michelle's body was found.

But a lower court judge ruled against a new trial because he said the evidence against Scott was trumped by the evidence against Schofield.

At Wednesday's hearing appellate judge Craig Villanti told Schofield's attorney: "Your presumption … is that all of the new evidence (about Scott's violence) is admissible. … Without that evidence, your case is a loser. With it, it's debatable."

Schofield attorney Richard Bartmon replied, "The state is arguing … that Schofield was a violent guy, which opens the door for Scott's violent history."

Bartmon added: "It would pervert the truth-seeking function of the court not to allow (all of the Scott evidence). … The reason to allow it is fairness — to give the jury the whole story."

Prosecutor Patricia McCarthy countered: "The prints alone don't establish that (Scott) had any contact with the victim. … The (lower court) judge saw that the evidence against Schofield was overwhelming."

The appellate panel has no deadline for its ruling.

Meanwhile, Leo Schofield is 22 years into his life sentence and Jeremy Scott is 23 years into his, for a different murder.

Meg Laughlin can be reached at

Lawyer argues for new trial in '87 Lakeland slaying 06/08/11 [Last modified: Wednesday, June 8, 2011 11:43pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. USF eliminated by UCF in AAC baseball; Florida, FSU, Miami win


    CLEARWATER — Roughly 16 hours after a ninth-inning collapse against East Carolina in the American Athletic Conference's double-elimination baseball tournament, USF returned to Spectrum Field presumably set for a reboot.

    It simply got booted instead.

    ’NOLES win: Tyler Holton gets a hug from Drew Carlton after his strong eight innings help Florida State beat Louisville.
  2. Pinellas licensing board executive director settled hundreds of cases without getting his board's approval

    Local Government

    By Mark Puente

    Times Staff Writer

    Eleanor Morrison complained to the Pinellas licensing board in 2015 that her contractor installed crooked walls and windows and poured too much concrete for her carport.

    Eleanor Morrison poses at her home in Treasure Island, 5/26/17. Morrison filed a complaint with the Pinellas County Construction Licensing Board and later learned that its former Executive Director, Rodney Fischer, dismissed the case in a private meeting with the contractor.
  3. Report: Kusher wanted secret communications channel with Kremlin


    Jared Kushner and Russia's ambassador to Washington discussed the possibility of setting up a secret and secure communications channel between Donald Trump's transition team and the Kremlin, using Russian diplomatic facilities in an apparent move to shield their pre-inauguration discussions from monitoring, U.S. …

    The name of Jared Kushner, President Donald Trump's White House senior adviser, has come up as part of the Russia investigation. [Associated Press]
  4. Rays pitchers rave about Twins pitching coach, ex-mentor Neil Allen

    The Heater

    MINNEAPOLIS — There have been a lot of coaches who have had a hand in helping Chris Archer get to the big leagues and to the front of the Rays rotation, and as he took the mound Friday night at Target Field, he had reason to nod appreciatively toward the home dugout.

    In their third year with pitching coach Neil Allen, the Twins have been one of the surprises of the American League.
  5. Swan sculpture deputies say was stolen by naked man found near Lakeland pond


    A $25,000 swan sculpture that Polk County sheriff's deputies say was stolen by a naked man last weekend was found near a pond in Lakeland on Thursday.

    A swan sculpture that was stolen in Lakeland on May 19 was recovered by the Polk Sheriff’s Office on Friday.