Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Legal experts split on whether judge will sentence cop killer to death

TAMPA — When a judge decides today between life and death for the convicted killer of a Tampa police corporal, he will look out on a roomful of blue uniforms — all fellow officers waiting for the judge to impose the ultimate punishment.

The view shouldn't amount to "a hill of beans," death penalty experts say. The blue uniforms should have no more bearing on the decision than the red jail jumpsuit worn by Humberto Delgado, the killer of Tampa police Cpl. Mike Roberts in 2009.

The possibility of public or political pressure brought against elected judges is always there. But Emmett Battles, the circuit judge who will decide, has made unpopular rulings before — including his decision to spare hit-and-run driver Jennifer Porter prison after she killed two children in 2004. He was re-elected without opposition six years later.

This time, many legal observers — but not all — believe Delgado will not die for his crime, that he does not meet the death penalty standard of "worst of the worst." If Battles gives him death, they say, it likely won't stand up.

"If he imposes the death sentence, I wouldn't be surprised at all if the state Supreme Court reverses it," says Robert Batey, professor of criminal law at the Stetson University College of Law in Gulfport.

"There's a strong argument that it is unconstitutional."

Rick Terrana, a death-case attorney in Tampa, says there's also a strong argument that the death penalty is a good possibility. "I think this judge can impose the death penalty without appellate scrutiny," Terrana says. "And if he can, he will."

Predictions of a life sentence rather than death are partly based on the evidence and partly on Florida's stature as a death penalty "outlier."

Florida death penalty rules are looser than anywhere else in the country. The state's own Supreme Court has urged the Legislature to reform them, to bring them in line with other states. Lawmakers so far have refused.

Delgado himself is another argument against a death sentence, the experts say. Psychiatrists and psychologists for both the state and defense nearly unanimously agreed that Delgado experienced an "extreme mental disturbance" on the night he killed Roberts. Under the law, that's a "mitigating factor" that could excuse him from the death penalty. Veteran death penalty attorney Lyann Goudie says she has never seen a more powerful mitigating factor than Delgado's documented lifelong mental illness, his previous service as a policeman in the Virgin Islands and his delusional state at the time of the killing.

In the penalty phase of Delgado's trial last year, prosecutors presented the jury two aggravating factors: one that he killed a police officer who was performing his duties, the other that he committed aggravated battery on another officer who responded to the scene.

Missing in the state's argument was the most prevalent aggravating factor in death cases — that the killing was "especially heinous, atrocious, cruel, or depraved."

Weighed against that was the mitigating factor that Delgado, homeless and without his pyschotropic medications, had an "extreme mental disturbance" when he killed Roberts.

The jury recommended death by an 8-4 vote.

Attorney Goudie said the vote surprised her. But under Florida law, a jury is not required to explain its vote or cite the aggravating factor it most preferred. Each juror can choose his or her own preferred aggravator.

The way Florida juries consider those factors was ruled unconstitutional by a U.S. district judge last year, but the ruling is under appeal. Florida is the only state in which a jury can recommend a death sentence by simple majority.

"We go the furthest in not requiring unanimity," says Batey, the Stetson professor.

He also noted that Florida leads the United States in reversals of death sentences, with 23.

For the second year, state Sen. Thad Altman, R-Viera, has filed a bill to require that a jury recommendation of death must be by all 12 jurors. It also would require juries to agree unanimously on aggravating factors. Altman calls it "inconsistent and illogical" that the law requires a unanimous verdict of guilt to convict somebody of a crime, but not to recommend that someone be put to death. The bill has long odds of passage.

Nevertheless, attorney Terrana says the judge is required by law to give great weight to the jury's vote — even an 8-4 vote. "If it were 7-5, he pretty much might have to go with life, but 8-4 is not close enough to negate a death penalty. Only under rare circumstances can he, or should he, overrule a jury's recommendation." Terrana says the judge also can consider the harm done to Roberts' widow and children, even if it is not an aggravating factor.

Today, Judge Battles will make the call alone. That's how it was with Jennifer Porter.

In March 2004, Porter struck four children on a dark street as they returned home from playing at a local community center. Two children died, and two were seriously injured. If Porter had stayed at the scene, she likely would not have faced charges. Instead, she drove away and called an attorney instead of authorities.

Prosecutors wanted prison time for Porter, who pleaded guilty to leaving the scene of a crash involving a death. But after hearing evidence about the psychiatric trauma she had endured immediately after the accident, Battles sentenced her to two years of house arrest and three years of probation. His decision was widely criticized.

Today's decision could again be criticized. But legal experts say only the law matters. "He'll have to back up his findings with evidence," says retired Hillsborough Circuit Judge J. Rogers Padgett.

"It's not easy."

John Barry can be reached at

Legal experts split on whether judge will sentence cop killer to death 02/09/12 [Last modified: Thursday, February 9, 2012 10:29pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. No toll lanes north of downtown Tampa in three of four interstate proposals


    TAMPA — Express lanes may not be coming to downtown Tampa after all. Or at least not to the stretch of Interstate 275 that goes north through Bearss Avenue.

    Seminole Heights resident Kimberly Overman discusses the new interstate options with V.M. Ybor resident Chris Vela (left), Hillsborough County Commissioner Pat Kemp and HNTB consultant Chloe Coney during a Tampa Bay Express meeting Monday night at the Barrymore Hotel. [CAITLIN JOHNSTON  |  Times]
  2. No lack of issues facing St. Petersburg's six council candidates


    ST. PETERSBURG — The six candidates for City Council gathered Monday evening in the very chamber to which they aspire to serve.

    St. Petersburg City Council candidates (from left)  Brandi Gabbard and Barclay Harless in District 2; Jerick Johnston and incumbent council member Darden Rice in District 4; and Justin Bean and Gina Driscoll of District 6. All six candidates appeared at Monday night's forum at City Hall sponsored by the League of Women Voters. [CHERIE DIEZ   |   Times]

  3. Iraq's Kurds vote on independence, raising regional fears


    IRBIL, Iraq — Iraqi Kurds voted Monday in a landmark referendum on supporting independence, a move billed by the Kurdish leadership as an exercise in self-determination but viewed as a hostile act by Iraq's central government. Neighboring Turkey even threatened a military response.

    People celebrate Monday after voting closed in a referendum on independence in Irbil, Iraq.
  4. North Korean diplomat says Trump has 'declared war'


    UNITED NATIONS — North Korea's top diplomat said Monday that President Donald Trump's weekend tweet was a "declaration of war" and North Korea has the right to retaliate by shooting down U.S. bombers, even in international airspace.

    North Korean Foreign Minister Ri Yong Ho, center, speaks outside the U.N. Plaza Hotel in New York on Monday.
  5. Pinellas grants St. Pete's request to add millions to pier budget

    Local Government

    Times Staff Writer

    The Pinellas County Commission has granted St. Petersburg Mayor Rick Kriseman's request to dedicate millions more toward the city's new pier.

    The St. Petersburg City Council on Thursday  voted 7-1 to appropriate $17.6 million for the over-water portion of the Pier District. This is a rendering of what the new Pier District could look like. [Courtesy of St. Petersburg]