Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Man gets 15 years for leaving scene of crash that killed UT student

TAMPA — Until Tuesday, Cree Riley had never been face-to-face with the man who hit her and a friend with his car and then drove away.

When she finally saw Andres Trujillo in a courtroom, the 20-year-old with a scarred body and dashed dreams had one question.

"I just want to know why," she asked through tears. "How could you leave two people in the road? You just left us there like we were nothing."

Riley was hospitalized for weeks after the November 2009 crash with severe injuries to her leg, arm, hip, eye socket, shoulder, collar bone, chin and jaw. To this day, her jaw barely opens and she suffers from symptoms of traumatic brain injury.

Erik Nicoletti, a 20-year-old University of Tampa film student, didn't survive his injuries.

His mother, father and teenage sister — still ravaged with grief — traveled from New York for Trujillo's sentencing.

"I miss the life we had when Erik was in it," his mother, Dorothy Nicoletti, said. "Our house feels like an abysmal void."

Trujillo, 29, pleaded guilty in December to leaving the scene of an accident with injury and death and accepted a plea offer of 15 years in prison and 15 years of probation. As part of the agreement, he will permanently lose his driver's license and must perform 100 hours of community service.

The Nicolettis said it wasn't enough.

"It's obvious he has no respect for life, no morality in him, and absolutely no remorse for murdering my son Erik," Dorothy Nicoletti said. "He's only sorry he was caught."

Trujillo, the father of two young girls, said he felt remorse but didn't expect the families' forgiveness.

"You are wrong," he said. "I turned myself in because I know that justice should be doled out."

Trujillo told police he reached down to pick up a dropped, lit cigarette when he hit something on Kennedy Boulevard near North Boulevard.

At the time, he worked as a sous chef in a downtown restaurant and was serving probation for the fraudulent use of a credit card and petty theft. His arrest record dated back to 2003.

He said he fled out of panic. He said he wasn't drinking.

Riley met Erik Nicoletti only a few hours before the crash but was instantly smitten.

"I had a huge crush on him," she said.

A softball player and engineering student at Penn State University, she had just arrived in Tampa to visit a friend. She was introduced to Nicoletti at a bar and thought he was gorgeous.

They were hit after walking to the Metro Food Mart for an early-morning snack.

She battles ongoing physical pain, no longer able to snowboard or play softball and unlikely to ever fulfill her goal of becoming a firefighter.

She thinks about Nicoletti often. She feels guilty that she lived and he didn't.

She was angry Tuesday that Trujillo didn't look at her when she spoke to him in court.

She said she didn't feel any closure.

Colleen Jenkins can be reached at or (813) 226-3337.

.Fast facts

How to help

Efforts have begun to build a broadcast studio in Erik Nicoletti's name at his former high school. Donations may be sent to North Salem Middle/High School, in the name of Erik Nicoletti Film and Broadcast Studio and Scholarship, 230 June Road, North Salem, NY 10560.

Man gets 15 years for leaving scene of crash that killed UT student 02/08/11 [Last modified: Wednesday, February 9, 2011 6:51am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Muslim faith greater than fear for Wharton's Rania Samhouri (w/video)


    TAMPA — Rania Samhouri graduated Monday night from Wharton High School, and many times throughout the ceremony she flashed back to a moment that changed her life.

     Rania Samhouri stretches after track practice on Monday April 24, 2017 at Wharton High School in Tampa, Florida. Rania, who is Muslim, recently started wearing her hijab during track competitions. She graduates from Wharton this year and will attend University of South Florida on scholarship next year.
  2. Deputies seek two men in attempted armed home invasion robbery in Seminole


    Detectives are searching for two men they say broke into a home in Seminole Thursday night in an attempted armed robbery.

  3. Forecast: A sunny, dry Memorial Day weekend ahead in Tampa Bay


    Tampa Bay residents can expect to see a sunny, rain-free Memorial Day weekend with clear skies and temperatures hovering in the upper 80s and low 90s.

    Tampa Bay's 7 day forecast. [WTSP]
  4. Man dies after he was found in Largo motel parking lot shot multiple times


    Detectives from the Pinellas County Sheriff's Office are investigating a fatal shooting that occurred overnight in the parking lot of a motel in Largo.

  5. Florida education news: Sales tax, school buses, a Civil War prop and more


    BACK-TO-SCHOOL: Gov. Rick Scott authorizes a three-day sales tax holiday for back-to-school shopping.