Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Man who claimed self-defense gets probation for manslaughter

TAMPA — James Behanna fatally stabbed a man in the heart with a pocketknife on Dec. 7, 2005.

On Thursday, after pleading guilty to manslaughter, he was sentenced to 42 months of probation.

It was a quiet end to a 5-year-old case in which the Tampa paralegal originally was convicted and sentenced to 15 years in prison before an appellate court decided he deserved a new trial.

The missing piece that made all the difference:

The state of mind of the victim, a 21-year-old Robert Mears Jr., who had recently moved from Pittsburgh to Tampa to get away from bad influences.

A young man whose family admits he was quick to fight, but did not deserve to die.

• • •

Mears lived in an apartment down the street from the Florida Avenue law firm of Behanna's wife, Aida Rodriguez, within sight of the Sulphur Springs river tower.

This is what witnesses who testified said happened:

After 6 p.m. that day, Mears trespassed on the law firm property. Firm employees saw him coming out of his apartment agitated and angry, waving his arms, pounding his fist into his hand. They told him to stay away. Behanna testified he gave a warning from the window, but said Mears replied, "I'm not going anywhere."

So Behanna said he grabbed a shovel and went downstairs to find an intoxicated Mears yelling at Behanna's wife. Mears attacked him, Behanna testified. He grabbed Behanna, threw him onto the ground, took away the shovel and faced Behanna's wife. Behanna ran between them to try to get the shovel, but Mears threw it in the wife's direction and slammed Behanna against a post.

Behanna said he blacked out, but when he came to, he saw Mears running away. At the trial, prosecutors said Behanna should have gone into the office for safety. Instead, he followed Mears in what he called an attempt to detain him for police.

What happened 150 feet away from the initial fight was the crux of the criminal case: The defendant said Mears grabbed him by the throat and threatened to kill him. But one witness for the prosecution said Mears only pushed Behanna back.

Behanna, known by friends as MacGyver because he carried a pocketknife, pulled out his knife and stabbed Mears twice. The second time, he pierced his heart.

A jury considered, then rejected, the "stand your ground" law of self-defense.

This is what the jury didn't hear before it convicted Behanna:

Just before he stormed out of his apartment, police said Mears had beaten up his roommate and kicked him in the head.

In an appeal, Behanna argued that the jury should have known that. The 2nd District Court of Appeal agreed.

Behanna, who missed the birth of his son while in jail, bailed out a year after his conviction.

He tried to get the case dismissed again on the basis of self-defense, but Circuit Judge Daniel Sleet denied that request.

Ultimately, Behanna's attorney entered into negotiations with the state, which led to the probation deal.

• • •

On Thursday, Robert Mears, Sr. talked about what happened before his son stormed out of that apartment.

Growing up in Pittsburgh, his son was a smart kid who liked making people laugh and didn't like being told what to do. He ran away and dropped out of high school, but came home and got his GED. He never went to college, but worked.

He moved to Tampa to work at the Port Authority as a welder, his father said. He was trying to get his life together.

But he didn't keep good company.

Mears had trouble with his roommate, his father said. There was drinking and fighting. Mears was known to fight if he or his friends were threatened.

That day, the father said, his roommate had trashed his stuff and smashed his guitar. Mears was walking toward the Hillsborough River after the fight. The law firm was on the way.

"All he wanted to do was be left alone," the father said.

The father called the plea deal an "insult" and said Behanna has still not apologized to his family.

"There's nothing I can say to them that's going to make the situation any better," Behanna said after the hearing.

He said he was happy to be going home to his little boy.

Alexandra Zayas can be reached at or (813) 226-3354.

Man who claimed self-defense gets probation for manslaughter 04/08/10 [Last modified: Thursday, April 8, 2010 11:29pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. 'Sharknado' coming to Tampa Theatre with director Q&A


    A movie about a tornado filled with man-eating sharks has to be better on the big screen, right? You'll have a chance to find out for yourself when the Syfy network's original Sharknado screens at Tampa Theatre.

    The original 'Sharknado,' which premiered in 2013, will screen at Tampa Theatre.
  2. Coast Guard airlifts man from fishing boat in Gulf of Mexico

    Public Safety

    A 27-year-old man was evacuated from a fishing boat in the Gulf of Mexico by a U.S. Coast Guard helicopter Saturday night, authorities said.

  3. Trump: Not 'that far off' from passing health overhaul


    WASHINGTON — Making a final push, President Donald Trump said he doesn't think congressional Republicans are "that far off" on a health overhaul to replace "the dead carcass of Obamacare." Expressing frustration, he complained about "the level of hostility" in government and wondered why both parties can't work …

    President Donald Trump speaks during a bill signing event for the "Department of Veterans Affairs Accountability and Whistleblower Protection Act of 2017" in the East Room of the White House, Friday, June 23, 2017, in Washington. (AP Photo/Evan Vucci) DCEV208
  4. Erin Andrews, ex-NHL player Jarret Stoll marry in Montana


    NEW YORK — Sportscaster Erin Andrews and former NHL player Jarret Stoll have tied the knot.

    FILE - In this Oct. 30, 2016 file photo, Fox Sports broadcaster Erin Andrews, left, speaks with Atlanta Falcons wide receiver Julio Jones after an NFL football game against the Green Bay Packers in Atlanta. Jennifer Allen, a publicist for Andrews, confirms Sunday, June 25, 2017, that the 38-year-old Fox Sports sideline reporter and ???‚??“Dancing with the Stars???‚?? co-host married the 35-year-old Stoll over the weekend.  (AP Photo/David Goldman, File) NYSP103
  5. Amid FBI probe of Tallahassee, Gillum says GOP trying to 'put as much dirt on me as they can'


    Tallahassee mayor and candidate for governor Andrew Gillum might like his supporters to think a federal investigation into development deals in his city is political – but …

    Andrew Gillum