Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Pasco man claims self-defense in 2005 roommate shooting

NEW PORT RICHEY — James Reynolds came home one day in July 2005 to discover his roommate, Jeffrey Fix, waiving around Reynolds' .357 handgun.

Fix fired a shot, and a tussle ensued, defense attorney Keith Hammond said Monday. Then Reynolds got ahold of the gun and fatally shot his roommate in the back of the head.

Hammond told jurors it was self-defense. Reynolds, 64, is on trial this week for manslaughter.

Assistant State Attorney Eric Rosario told jurors the shooting could have been an accident, but Reynolds didn't dial 911, and he didn't report the incident.

Instead, Fix's body was found two days later, on July 17, 2005, near Old Dixie Highway in Aripeka, wrapped in blue carpet from Reynolds' boat.

Detectives identified the body as Fix, a 48-year-old transient from Michigan who had been convicted three times for indecent exposure, among other charges. Then they visited the home at 6633 Candice Lane in New Port Richey, where Fix and Reynolds both lived.

Authorities found blood had soaked into the plywood floor, which had just been repainted.

Reynolds had fled to Baltimore, Rosario said, where he took apart the handgun and disposed of the pieces in different garbage bins around the city. Detectives went to Baltimore to interrogate Reynolds, who said he knew nothing about the blood.

He wasn't charged until 2009, when he admitted pulling the trigger.

Hammond argued Reynolds was in fear for his life: Fix had been drinking, and he fired the first shot, Hammond said.

Jurors heard Monday from Robert Morgan, who found Fix's body while he was out in the woods hunting with his son.

"My son saw it first and suggested we stop because it could be a dead deer," Morgan said. "I flipped the carpet with a stick, and I didn't want to touch anything. I saw it was a leg."

The trial is expected to continue today.

Pasco man claims self-defense in 2005 roommate shooting 10/24/11 [Last modified: Monday, October 24, 2011 11:10pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Letter from 'many' St. Petersburg High faculty, staff to Pinellas School Board pushes for assistant principal to be next principal


    A St. Petersburg High teacher sent a letter on the behalf of "many" school faculty and staff to the Pinellas County School Board and school district superintendent Mike Grego in support of appointing their assistant principal, Darlene Lebo, as principal.

    Darlene Lebo, an assistant principal at St. Petersburg High, is supported by "many" school faculty and staff to be the school's next principal, according to a letter sent to the Pinellas County School Board.
  2. 2017 Florida Theme Park Guide: A look at this summer's top attractions


    Florida's theme parks are getting ready for their busiest season with new rides, shows and perks, and we have rounded up a guide to the best new things to see.

    The newest fireworks presentation at Magic Kingdom uses lasers, lights, projections and pyrotechnics showing characters and scenes from more than 25 Disney films. [Walt Disney World]
  3. Meet 'rave pops,' the EDM-loving, hard-dancing 72-year-old who went viral via the Sunset Music Festival (w/video)

    Music & Concerts

    Alan Grofé is a 72-year-old, semi-retired entrepreneur and former tech executive with frost-white hair, two grown children and five grandchildren.

    Alan Grofe dances at the Electric Daisy Carnival festival in Orlando in 2016. [aLIVE Coverage for Insomniac]
  4. Humana adding 200 telemarketing jobs in Tampa Bay

    Economic Development

    TAMPA — Health insurance company Humana Inc. is hiring more than 200 workers in Tampa Bay. The Louisville, Ky.-based company said Wednesday that the new positions will focus on phone sales for Humana's direct marketing services department.

    Humana is adding 200 positions to its Tampa office. Theo Sai, chief medical officer for seniro products at Humana, is pictured in the company's Tampa executive office in 2015. | Rachel Crosby, Times
  5. Congressman wants Trump to pay for Mar-a-Lago travel


    WASHINGTON -- This bill won’t go anywhere, but give Rep. Alcee Hastings creative points with the TRUMPED Act, aka Taxpayers Require Urgent Mandatory Protection from Egregious Debt Act of 2017: