Friday, September 21, 2018
News Roundup

Pasco mother's guilty plea to child abuse reopened amid competency questions

TAMPA — On Nov. 19, Violet Hinrichs shuffled into a Tampa courtroom, raised her right hand and pleaded guilty to charges that would put her in prison for five years.

She was a week shy of her 20th birthday and as she stood before the judge, her oversized jail-issued jacket hung from her 5-foot-2 frame. Did she understand the consequences of pleading guilty? the judge asked. "Yes sir," she said softly, giving the answer she is accustomed to giving. Tears rolled down her cheeks.

In April, authorities say, Hinrichs repeatedly tried to smother her 7-month-old son while he was hospitalized. She was caught on camera pressing on his chest until his skin turned blue.

Six months later, she did what most defendants do: She took a plea deal. But crucial information that neither her attorney nor the prosecutor revealed during that hearing could change the outcome of Hinrichs' case. It's unclear whether she had the mental capacity to understand her guilty plea, and Hinrichs now says she did not know what she was doing.

Records obtained by the Tampa Bay Times show that a psychologist who evaluated Hinrichs several months after her arrest reported her intellectual disability and IQ of 60, but her public defender never asked for more testing to determine competency.

After a lifetime of special education classes — she was classified as intellectually disabled and speech impaired at age 7 — she has the reading and math skills of a first- or second-grade student.

Ask Hinrichs to read a paragraph aloud and she can sound out basic words, but she doesn't understand most legal terminology. She can't read the plea agreement she signed.

Hinrichs also met the criteria for a rare condition in which people feign illness to get themselves or their children hospitalized.

"There is no suggestion that this defendant is malingering," the psychologist wrote.

•••

A typical day in Tampa's courthouse might include a dozen defendants like Hinrichs who have intellectual disabilities. Many of them are evaluated to determine if they are competent for trial. To meet that standard, they must have a clear understanding of the charges against them, be able to participate in their own defense, and make decisions about plea agreements.

Though Kasper's report was given to Hinrichs' attorney, Assistant Public Defender J. Kenneth Littman, it is unclear what he did with it. In cases where mental health is an issue, attorneys typically ask a judge to appoint a psychologist to evaluate the defendant for competency. But records show Littman did not make that request. And though the state was aware of Hinrichs' history, neither prosecutor Rita Peters nor Hillsborough Circuit Judge Chet Tharpe raised questions about her competency. So there was no hearing, as there often is, at which mental health experts could have weighed in on Hinrichs' status.

Littman did not respond to requests for comment. But two days after he was contacted by the Times, he filed a motion to withdraw Hinrichs' guilty plea.

"Since November 19, 2014, facts have come to light which raise a serious question as to whether Ms. Hinrichs was competent to enter her guilty plea," he wrote. A judge is expected to hear his request on Monday.

•••

"I was just not thinking at the time," Hinrichs says now. She was confused, as she often finds herself to be these days.

In interviews with a Times reporter, Hinrichs, of Port Richey, said she thought her case was headed for trial. Charged with five counts each of aggravated child abuse and second-degree attempted murder, she said Littman warned that she could face life in prison if a jury convicted her. He pushed her to take a plea deal, telling her the state had substantial evidence against her, she said.

That last claim does not appear to have been true. In court on Nov. 19, Peters agreed to drop the attempted murder charges and reduce the remaining five to child abuse. "Based on everything we have, including her post-Miranda statement, we cannot show that Ms. Hinrichs acted with intent to harm her child," Peters said.

Littman gave Hinrichs a plea form and read it to her, but he talked so fast, she said, that she couldn't keep up. She tried to read the form, but now says the words made little sense. It must be a document to tell the judge she wanted a trial, she reasoned. She signed it.

"He gave me the pen and I was just looking at him weird," she said. "I told him I wanted to think about taking a trial or going to prison for five years and he didn't give me the time to think about it."

Before she knew it, she was facing the judge. She remembers the judge asking if that was her signature on the form. Hinrichs answered yes to every question, as she admits she often does. It was her first time speaking in front of a large group.

"I just kept saying yes and I kept saying okay and everything," she said. "I really didn't know what was going on."

It was not until the judge pronounced Hinrichs' sentence that she realized what she had done. Then the tears came.

Contact Anna M. Phillips at [email protected] or (813) 226-3354. Follow her @annamphillips.

   
Comments
'Divorce Court' woman accused of sex with boy, 15; he says he may have fathered her newborn

'Divorce Court' woman accused of sex with boy, 15; he says he may have fathered her newborn

HUDSON — A 26-year-old woman has been charged with three counts of lewd and lascivious battery after a 15-year-old boy told deputies he could be father of her newborn child, the Pasco County Sheriff's Office said. The boy, who has not been nam...
Updated: 8 minutes ago
For starters: Rays at Blue Jays, trying to bounce back

For starters: Rays at Blue Jays, trying to bounce back

After Thursday's crushing loss in which they blew a six-run lead in the ninth, the Rays will try to bounce back and keep their even longer-shot playoff hopes in play.RHP Diego Castillo will serve as the opener again today, with LHP Jalen Beeks likely...
Updated: 18 minutes ago
Carlton: The siege of Red Tide: No walk on the beach

Carlton: The siege of Red Tide: No walk on the beach

This week, on one of the last mornings of summer, I went walking on one of our Gulf beaches, the sunrise warming my back. It could not have been prettier — the sky cloudless, the water a quiet blue, a lone Brown Pelican skimming the surface.If you co...
Updated: 26 minutes ago
Hillsborough school district releases list of referendum purchase items

Hillsborough school district releases list of referendum purchase items

TAMPA --- Anderson Elementary School will get two new playgrounds. Chiles Elementary will get carpets and floors. Madison Middle School will get new stage lights and a repaved parking lot.All that, and air conditioning overhauls throughout the school...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Watch: A southern white rhinoceros calf just a week after being born at ZooTampa

Watch: A southern white rhinoceros calf just a week after being born at ZooTampa

TAMPA — A southern white rhinoceros gave birth to a calf at ZooTampa on Sept. 12, marking the sixth successful birth of the species in the zoo's history. In a news release, ZooTampa said southern white rhinoceroses are a nearly threatened spec...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Deputies: Spring Hill man set fire to ex-girlfriend’s home in July

Deputies: Spring Hill man set fire to ex-girlfriend’s home in July

SPRING HILL — A 27-year-old man was arrested Thursday in connection with a July building fire, according to the Hernando County Sheriff’s Office.Christopher Lamar Jamison of Spring Hill faces 10 counts of attempted murder and charges of arson and agg...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Ryan Fitzpatrick said his only goal was to go 3-0 while Jameis Winston was suspended

Ryan Fitzpatrick said his only goal was to go 3-0 while Jameis Winston was suspended

Before Ryan Fitzpatrick filled the sky with footballs, connecting on deep passes and touchdowns, he was just the guy standing between the Bucs and what looked like a long losing streak after the suspension to quarterback Jameis Winston.But following ...
Updated: 1 hour ago
The guys who brought you Tampa’s Armature Works plan high-end offices next door

The guys who brought you Tampa’s Armature Works plan high-end offices next door

TAMPA — Coming soon from the developers who brought you the Armature Works: Heights Union, two high-end office buildings next door to the trendy food hall, event space and co-working complex overlooking the Hillsborough River.Developers said Friday t...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Franklin on Twiggs restaurant opens in former downtown Tampa Pita Pit location

Franklin on Twiggs restaurant opens in former downtown Tampa Pita Pit location

DOWNTOWN — After a falling out with the Pita Pit corporate offices, Andrew Turek, the former owner of the SoHo location sold the property to Shula Burger and decided to open a new eatery and market called Franklin on Twiggs in the former downt...
Updated: 2 hours ago
Lightning journal: Adam Erne looks to stick in Tampa

Lightning journal: Adam Erne looks to stick in Tampa

Forward Adam Erne flicks the puck into the net, but he has no time to celebrate.He flips around. Crunch, crunch, crunch. Snow flies off his skates. Erne then squares his body as he arrives in the defensive zone, steps away from the net.Within a secon...
Updated: 2 hours ago