Saturday, June 23, 2018
News Roundup

Port Richey man serving life in prison gets new trial — his third

A man serving life in prison has been granted a new trial — his third — by an appeals court that said the prosecutor repeated the very error that had caused the first mistrial.

Robert Geissler, 59, was convicted in 2009 of sexually abusing a 6-year-old girl. In a ruling issued June 22, the Florida 2nd District Court of Appeal said Geissler's trial was tainted by repeated references to the fact that he declined to speak to detectives. A defendant has the right to remain silent, and prosecutors cannot use that person's silence to imply guilt. In fact, courts have said the prosecution cannot even bring it up.

During the course of Geissler's one-day trial, prosecutor Eva Vergos "hammered the point home again and again" that Geissler cut off his jailhouse interview with detectives, according to the appellate court ruling.

Vergos told jurors that Geissler told detectives: "I can't say any more because if I do, I'll get in more trouble."

Vergos, now a candidate for county judge, said she "certainly did not intend to violate this man's rights."

She viewed his jailhouse statement as an "implication of his guilt — not an invocation of his rights," she said.

But the appeals court said Vergos and Circuit Judge Michael Andrews, who allowed the statements, should have known not to mention it. Andrews declared a mistrial in Geissler's first trial in 2008 when a detective testified that Geissler invoked his rights and cut off questioning.

"The State used Mr. Geissler's exercise of his right to remain silent to challenge his credibility and to suggest that he was guilty of the alleged sexual abuse," the appellate court's ruling stated.

Vergos also was the prosecutor in the first trial. After the detective's statement about Geissler invoking his rights, she said, she argued for a mistrial because that "was a clear error." She said she didn't see his jailhouse comment used in the second trial as treading on the same ground. But the appellate court did.

"They have made a ruling and we will abide by that ruling," Vergos said.

The appellate panel cited another error in the 2009 retrial that occurred during the testimony of Julie Nadkarni, a child protection team member and registered nurse who examines children for physical signs of abuse. She testified that she had "no physical findings supporting the allegation that sexual abuse had occurred," but said she believed the girl has been sexually abused.

That statement gave "the jury the clear impression that the expert believed that the child victim was telling the truth," the ruling states. Expert testimony cannot be used to bolster the credibility of another witness.

The child was 6 at the time of the alleged abuse. She is now 10. In giving a history of the case, the appellate ruling said the girl's parents were friends of Geissler's wife and lived in West Virginia. When the child's parents lost their parental rights in 2005, the girl, then 4, came to Florida live with the Geisslers in Port Richey.

The child's father also moved to Pasco County. He "was apparently homeless, and he lived in a tent pitched in various locations," the ruling states. Mrs. Geissler sometimes took the child to visit her biological father.

From September 2007 until April 2008, Geissler worked on a construction project in West Palm Beach and was only home on weekends, the ruling states. His wife worked on Saturdays, so Geissler was alone in watching the girl until his wife came home.

On April 19, 2008, Mrs. Geissler came home and the girl told her that Geissler had been sexually abusing her for months, the document states. Mrs. Geissler confronted her husband and "began packing to leave the house" with the child, the ruling states.

Geissler went outside and shot himself in the chin. He later claimed it was an accident.

He was arrested July 14, 2008, and charged with capital sexual battery on a victim younger than 12. Geissler has been incarcerated since that date.

The child recanted during the 2009 trial and said she made up the sexual abuse allegations because she was angry with Geissler for disciplining her and because she wanted to live with her biological dad. Then, in later questioning, she said she actually was telling the truth about being sexually abused.

"I'm disappointed that this little girl is going to have to go through it again," Vergos said.

Vergos said a new trial date will be set.

If she has to retry Geissler to "ensure he pays for his crime," she said, "then that is what we are going to do."

Erin Sullivan can be reached at [email protected] or (727) 869-6229.

Comments
Rays team up to beat Yankees again 4-0

Rays team up to beat Yankees again 4-0

ST. PETERSBURG — With all that's been said, tweeted, ranted and written on these pages and elsewhere about the Rays' odd, unorthodox, weird and some days downright wacky pitching plan, this might be the craziest thing yet:It's working.Like, rea...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Greg Auman answers your questions about NFL’s investigation into Jameis Winston

Greg Auman answers your questions about NFL’s investigation into Jameis Winston

There are many unanswered questions and discrepancies about the story of Bucs quarterback Jameis Winston and the March 2016 Uber ride in Arizona that has led to his upcoming three-game suspension for violating the NFL's conduct policy.The Bucs won't ...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Will this be Jameis Winston’s last season in a Bucs uniform?

Will this be Jameis Winston’s last season in a Bucs uniform?

A t his introductory news conference after being drafted No. 1 overall by the Bucs in 2015, Jameis Winston said to judge him on his actions moving forward."Actions speak so much louder than words, or what they may have read or what they may have hear...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Rays Tales: Why ‘trades’ and ‘prospects’ are always in same conversation

Rays Tales: Why ‘trades’ and ‘prospects’ are always in same conversation

Besides the continual evolution of their intriguing pitching plan, the primary topics of conversation for the Rays over the next several weeks will be trades and prospects. And not mutually exclusively.Some sooner than others, the Rays are going to c...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Former Mitchell High player Nathan Smith taken in NHL draft by Jets

Former Mitchell High player Nathan Smith taken in NHL draft by Jets

It's rare to see an NHL draft pick with Tampa Bay ties, but the Jets used a third-round pick Saturday on center Nathan Smith, 19, who played for Mitchell High School in Trinity and most recently for the Cedar Rapids RoughRiders of the USHL.Smith was ...
Updated: 2 hours ago
Report: Lightning to talk to John Tavares during free-agent courting period

Report: Lightning to talk to John Tavares during free-agent courting period

Despite limited salary-cap room, the Lightning is among at least five teams expected to talk with Islanders All-Star center John Tavares, who can be a free agent July 1, when the courting period begins Sunday, ESPN reported.Tavares also is expected t...
Updated: 2 hours ago

Strangers are coming together to honor two killed in Bayshore crash

TAMPA — John Reisinger has seen miracles since his niece and 21-month-old grand-niece were killed while trying to cross Bayshore Boulevard 30 days ago. Some, he says, are too painful to talk about. Others he’s still trying to make sense of, such as h...
Updated: 2 hours ago
Rays journal: New confidence carries over for Willy Adames

Rays journal: New confidence carries over for Willy Adames

ST. PETERSBURG — The key to SS Willy Adames rapping two of the biggest hits in the Rays' 4-0 win Saturday actually took place the night before.An RBI single that snapped an 0-for-12 and a second hit two winnings later in Friday's game restored ...
Updated: 2 hours ago
Another small, quick forward headlines Lightning’s draft picks

Another small, quick forward headlines Lightning’s draft picks

Even without a first-round pick, the Lightning wrapped up its draft with seven picks Saturday, starting with Gabriel Fortier, an undersized 18-year-old forward from Quebec in the second round."They were guys that we really wanted," Lightning director...
Updated: 2 hours ago
Marc Topkin’s takeaways from Saturday’s Rays-Yankees game

Marc Topkin’s takeaways from Saturday’s Rays-Yankees game

INF Daniel Robertson has only played two games after a short DL stint, but it seems like he has already made a half dozen great plays. Willy Adames and Jake Bauers get the attention, but Robertson has the skills to steal the show any night.It is obvi...
Updated: 2 hours ago