Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Prosecutors weigh whether to try Cortnee Brantley again

TAMPA — A judge declared a mistrial Wednesday when a jury deadlocked in the case of a woman who fled and then refused to identify her boyfriend after prosecutors say she saw him "execute" two Tampa police officers.

The 12 federal jurors deliberated more than eight hours over two days before telling the judge they were unable to reach a verdict in the trial of Cortnee Brantley, 24, of Seffner.

The late-afternoon impasse was actually the second time jurors told U.S. District Court Judge James Moody they were deadlocked. The first time, Moody told them to try again.

But less than three hours later, jurors sent a note to Moody saying they were still unable to agree on a unanimous verdict.

"This is a difficult case," Moody told the jurors, never asking them how many had voted for conviction or acquittal. "This can certainly happen."

The widows of slain Officers David Curtis and Jeffrey Kocab sat in the courtroom among family members and supporters as the mistrial was declared, then left the courthouse without comment.

Brantley, whose boyfriend, Dontae Morris, is charged with the killings, stared straight ahead without saying a word as she left the building and reporters peppered her with questions. She got into a waiting car and drove off.

Her attorney, Grady Irvin Jr., said simply, "The case is not over."

Indeed, it may be far from finished. Prosecutor James Preston Jr. refused to tell reporters if Brantley will be retried. But a retrial appeared likely, given Preston's quick answer when the judge asked how much time he needed to make a decision.

"I don't need any time, judge," said Preston.

Moody gave him until Monday anyway. U.S. Attorney Robert O'Neill later said his office was evaluating the case.

None of the jurors would speak with reporters as they left the federal courthouse in downtown Tampa. So details of their deliberations and the reasons for the deadlock remain unclear.

Jurors included two nurses, a doctor at a veterans hospital, a construction worker and a baker, among others. They were selected as the trial opened Monday with warnings that their job would include the unsettling task of watching a police cruiser's dashboard camera video of the shooting.

Brantley was never accused of any foreknowledge of that June 29, 2010, shooting and is not charged in the officers' deaths. But that haunting video was nonetheless the focus of the trial.

It shows Curtis stopping Brantley as she drove a Toyota Camry with no license plate. As the officers tried to arrest Morris, her passenger, on a bad check warrant, police said, he shot and killed them, running away as Brantley sped off in the car.

Her attorney said she did not know Morris had a gun, and suggested she fled because she was afraid of him. Prosecutors said that was untrue, noting she called Morris' cellphone less than a minute after the killings.

Jurors began deliberations Wednesday with their second viewing of the video in a cleared and locked courtroom.

The video is tightly controlled and filed as evidence under seal. Prosecutors have said the family is concerned that it does not appear on the news or YouTube.

But as clear-cut as the video appears, at least some jurors appeared confused by the obscure charge Brantley faced — misprision of a felony. It involves a failure to report a crime.

They asked the judge several questions in deliberations about the charge, including which crime she is accused of not reporting.

The answer surprises many — it is not the shooting. It is that Morris was a felon in possession of a gun and ammunition.

To convict Brantley, prosecutors must show she knew Morris was a felon with a gun and ammunition and failed to report that to authorities. But she also must have taken steps to conceal the information from police.

Prosecutors point to several acts of concealment:

Brantley fled the scene of the shootings, which disturbed the crime scene and deprived investigators of evidence. They said she also refused to identify Morris as the shooter to detectives.

In October 2010, Judge Moody had dismissed the charge, saying, "These acts do not demonstrate that Brantley concealed anything having to do with the crime of Morris' possession of a firearm and ammunition."

But an appeals court sent the case back for trial, saying it was improper to dismiss the charge before the judge heard any evidence at trial.

On Tuesday, Moody appeared ready to dismiss the case again after testimony ended. The judge had some of the same reservations he had expressed in 2010.

But Moody delayed a ruling, allowing the jury to deliberate. He said the removal of the car from the scene is the only act that might allow her conviction.

That is because there is testimony that by removing the car, a police dog was denied a scent of Morris that could have been obtained from a car seat, thereby possibly allowing his escape. Morris was captured after a four-day manhunt.

Even with the mistrial, Moody could still grant a motion to acquit Brantley, now that he has heard the evidence.

Staff writers Sue Carlton and Caitlin Johnston contributed to this report.

Prosecutors weigh whether to try Cortnee Brantley again 07/18/12 [Last modified: Wednesday, July 18, 2012 11:34pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. President Trump: Nation's culture being 'ripped apart' by Civil War statue removals


    WASHINGTON — Showing his characteristic refusal to back down in the face of criticism, President Donald Trump deepened his defense of Confederate war memorials Thursday, sending out a series of messages on Twitter that adopted the language and arguments of white nationalists who have opposed their removal.

    President Donald Trump points to members of the media as he answers questions in the lobby of Trump Tower in New York on Tuesday. Republican leaders on Wednesday tiptoed around Trump's extraordinary comments on white supremacists.  [Associated Press]
  2. With election heating up, Bill Nelson floods Tampa Bay


    Sen. Bill Nelson seems to have set up a residency in Tampa Bay, a crucial area for his upcoming re-election campaign.

    Nelson campaigns with his wife in Orlando in 2012
  3. Martinez Middle School evacuated after bomb threat


    LUTZ — Bob Martinez Middle School has been evacuated after someone called in a bomb threat, the Hillsborough County Sheriff's Office said.

  4. Another local Confederate display sparks division, this one over name of the war


    TAMPA — While the Hillsborough County commission was wrestling over the future of Confederate monument at the county courthouse, a lawsuit has been playing out in court over how best to represent the Civil War across town at Veterans Memorial Park.

    Supporters of a Civil War display at Veterans Memorial Park and Museum had a brochure made to attract donations. They argue in a lawsuit that their efforts were thwarted when the park's executive committee changed their plans.
  5. Myrtle Avenue closed, man hospitalized after Clearwater bike crash


    CLEARWATER — Myrtle Avenue is closed in both directions following a bicycle crash that hospitalized a man with serious injuries.