Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Carlton: If Schenecker is too crazy to execute, is she too crazy to convict?

Julie Schenecker was in court for a disposition hearing on Oct. 11, 2013. Barring delays, the case is set for trial April 28.


Julie Schenecker was in court for a disposition hearing on Oct. 11, 2013. Barring delays, the case is set for trial April 28.

To do what she did to her children three years ago, Julie Schenecker must have been insane. Out of her mind. Unable to know right from wrong.

Or, the evidence will show, she wasn't.

The case is stunning in how little sense it makes even now: 13-year-old Beau, shot in the family van, his 16-year-old sister, Calyx, killed with the same .38-caliber pistol as she did her homework in their upscale Tampa Palms home.

So there was TV legal mouthpiece Nancy Grace this month, in full howling outrage after Hillsborough County prosecutors took the death penalty off the table, seeking a life sentence for Schenecker instead.

"Now mommy claims she's" — air quotes here — " 'crazy!' " Grace told viewers. "Crazy like a fox! And the state backs off the death penalty. Tonight, no justice for Calyx and Beau!"

That high-volume and incendiary rhetoric aside, it's a reasonable question.

Why no death penalty for crimes this horrendous?

Another one: If Schenecker — trembling, wild-eyed and looking crazy as crazy gets when she was arrested — is too mentally ill to execute, is she also not guilty by reason of insanity, as her attorneys will argue?

Even in an imperfect court system, we may be able to find measured answers to both.

Prosecutors can have differing philosophies. Some tend to tee up the highest charges in the worst cases and let jurors, and later appeals courts, sort them out.

Others make the tough calls before going to trial — because it's their job, and because it could spare everyone the hell of retrying — and reliving — a terrible case.

Did Schenecker's case have any aggravating circumstances on which to base a death sentence? Yes — one of them being that the victims, her children, were particularly vulnerable because she had authority over them as their mother.

But would a death sentence survive the close review these kinds of cases get from the Florida Supreme Court?

Prosecutors considered reports from their own experts and determined that the mitigating evidence — Schenecker's extensive mental health issues — was "overwhelming."

And no death penalty makes sense.

But being mentally ill is not the same as being not guilty by reason of insanity.

Schenecker told detectives she was taking perhaps a dozen medications and had spent weeks in bed. She was being treated for bipolar disorder, depression and substance abuse.

And there's the center of this case: Mentally ill or not, did she know right from wrong?

What will a jury make of police recordings afterward in which she asks, "Hey, you guys, are you leaving the kids where they lay?"

But also, "Are my kids coming in later?"

We can expect to see the strange, sometimes incoherent Schenecker after her arrest juxtaposed with the fact that she bought the gun days before the shooting, indicating a plan. And that police say she reported that her children had been talking back and mouthy, and that she indicated she planned to kill them and then herself.

Barring delay, the fate of Julie Schenecker falls to a jury beginning April 28 — a decision you hope can be made with neither outrage nor naivete, but for what justice turns out to be.

Carlton: If Schenecker is too crazy to execute, is she too crazy to convict? 04/11/14 [Last modified: Monday, May 5, 2014 11:41am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Shakeup on Adam Putnam campaign


    In a sign of unsteadiness for what  had  looked like a strong-out-of-the-gate Adam Putnam campaign, the Republican frontrunner suddenly fired his campaign manager and political director. Hard-charging Campaign manager Kristin Davis and political director Jared Small were two of the three outsiders to join …

    Putnam campaigning in Destin the other day as part of his 22-city bus tour
  2. Rays let early lead get away again in loss to Angels (w/video)

    The Heater

    ST. PETERSBURG — As pleased as the Rays were to win consecutive series against the contending Red Sox, Indians and Yankees and to get briefly back over .500, there was a lot of talk in the clubhouse before Monday's game against the Angels that it was time to do better.

    Tampa Bay Rays third base coach Charlie Montoyo (25) high fives designated hitter Corey Dickerson (10) as he rounds third on his lead off home run in the first inning of the game between the Tampa Bay Rays and the Los Angeles Angels at Tropicana Field in St. Petersburg, Fla. on Monday, May 22, 2017.
  3. Tampa man arrested for killing man in his USF-area home


    TAMPA — A Tampa man was arrested Monday in the death of man found killed at a home in the University of South Florida area last week, according to the Hillsborough County Sheriff's Office.

    Kadeem Dareem Archibald, 26, was arrested Monday on a  second degree murder charge in the University Area killing of Khando Kerr. [Hillsborough County Sheriff's Office]
  4. Report: Trump asked intel chiefs to push back against FBI collusion probe after Comey revealed its existence


    President Donald Trump asked two of the nation's top intelligence officials in March to help him push back against an FBI investigation into possible coordination between his campaign and the Russian government, the Washington Post reports, citing current and former officials.

    From  left, CIA Director Mike Pompeo; Director of National Intelligence Dan Coats; and National Security Agency Director Adm. Michael Rogers take their seats on Capitol Hill on May 11 before  testifying before the Senate Intelligence Committee hearing on major threats facing the U.S. [Associated Press]
  5. For Gov. Rick Scott, 'fighting' could mean vetoing entire state budget

    State Roundup

    Every day, Gov. Rick Scott is getting a lot of advice.

    The last time a Florida governor vetoed the education portion of the state budget was in 1983. Gov. Bob Graham blasted fellow Democrats for their “willing acceptance of mediocrity.”