Make us your home page
Instagram

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Florida's stand your ground lawSherdavia JenkinsTrayvon MartinGeorge ZimmermaTrevor DooleySarah Ludemann

'Stand your ground' claim by Trevor Dooley in fatal park shooting rejected by judge

TAMPA — A neighbor who fatally shot a 41-year-old father on a basketball court after they argued over a skateboarder is not entitled to immunity under Florida's "stand your ground" law, a judge has ruled.

When Trevor Dooley, then 69, shot his Valrico neighbor David James in the chest in 2010, "There was no reasonable belief that deadly force was required," Hillsborough Circuit Judge Ashley Moody wrote in her order released Monday.

Although James was younger and bigger than Dooley, the judge said, testimony showed James was trying only to get Dooley's gun away.

"The court finds that Mr. James was justified in grabbing (Dooley) because defendant had reached for and pulled out a gun to confront Mr. James," Moody wrote.

Her ruling means that Dooley will stand trial for manslaughter, unless her order is overturned on appeal. He is still entitled to present a "stand your ground" argument, or any other self-defense argument, to a jury. No trial date has been set. A status hearing will be held Thursday.

Dooley's attorney, Ronald Tulin of Plant City, had no comment on the order.

Other defense attorneys had predicted the judge would rule against immunity. "A jury ain't going to buy this one either," Tampa defense lawyer Rick Terrana said Monday.

The "stand your ground" law is the same law being invoked in the fatal shooting of Trayvon Martin in Sanford by George Zimmerman — a case with many similarities. There, lawyers also dispute which one was actually standing his ground.

Testimony for and against Dooley has been painful, including that of James' daughter, who was 8 years old when she saw her father shot. Danielle James, now 10, said she remembers little about the shooting. She remembers Dooley saying he didn't want to fight. She doesn't remember seeing a gun, or hearing threats. What she remembers most was a gunshot.

In his own testimony in February, Dooley admitted shooting James. He said he had no choice, that James had a hand around his throat. "He was killing me," Dooley testified. "My finger was on the trigger. I shot."

But three witnesses, including the 14-year-old skateboarder Dooley was trying to shoo away, testified that Dooley first flashed a gun at James, then pulled it from his pants when James stepped toward him. They said they didn't see James choke Dooley. They said James tried to wrest the gun away.

In her ruling, Moody accepted only one of Dooley's arguments — that he was legally entitled to be where he was, in a public park.

She said he failed to show that he was in fear for his life. No other witnesses saw James try to hurt him. Paramedics at the scene saw no injuries on him.

Moody also wrote that Dooley broke the law when, according to witnesses, he first flashed the gun. Even though he had a concealed weapons permit, Moody said, the state showed "prima facie evidence of unlawful activity, namely the crimes of improper exhibition of a dangerous weapon, or open carrying of weapons."

Other lawyers say Dooley's best option at this point is to continue to claim he fired in self-defense. He cannot claim the gun went off accidentally because he has already admitted in court to deliberately firing. But he can argue that, in his mind, he believed James would have killed him.

"The best approach is to create the impression in each juror's mind that the victim was an aggressor, that he made some kind of movement," Terrana said. "That's all he can do."

Tampa lawyer Ronald Kurpiers, who lost a "stand your ground" argument with a judge in April, but then won acquittal for his client last week on an attempted murder charge, said the Dooley case will probably turn on whether a jury believes Dooley flashed his gun at James before they fought.

Kurpiers last week defended a teenager who admitted shooting a drug dealer, claiming he thought his life was in danger. Hillsborough Circuit Judge Gregory Holder refused to grant immunity under the "stand your ground" law, partly because the teenager was breaking the law by trying to buy drugs. But a jury refused to call the shooting attempted murder.

Lawyers don't suggest that Moody or Holder was swayed by the Trayvon Martin case, but they do believe the law, which was passed in 2005, has been misapplied in many cases and is now under intense scrutiny.

Said Kurpiers, "Judges are being careful."

John Barry can be reached at (813) 226-3383 or jbarry@tampabay.com.

'Stand your ground' claim by Trevor Dooley in fatal park shooting rejected by judge 05/14/12 [Last modified: Friday, November 16, 2012 4:58pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times

    

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

Loading...
  1. Restaurant review: Features Gastropub in Riverview is fine as movie theater fare, but unimpressive otherwise

    Food & Dining

    By Laura Reiley

    Times Food Critic

    Movies aren't exactly dying. Despite all the sturm und drang of predictions that Netflix and streaming videos would kill the cinema, global box office receipts hit $38.6 billion in 2016, a 1 percent gain over the previous year. But that doesn't mean going to the …

  2. JFK's last birthday: Gifts, champagne and wandering hands on the presidential yacht

    Nation

    It has been 100 years since John F. Kennedy's birth on May 29, 1917, at his parents' home in Brookline, Mass., just outside Boston. Over the course of his life, Kennedy enjoyed lavish birthday celebrations, the most famous being a Democratic fundraising bash at Madison Square Garden on May 19, 1962, when a sequined …

    President John F. Kennedy aboard the Sequoia in 1963 opening birthday presents. [Robert Knudsen | John F. Kennedy Presidential Library and Museum]
  3. 1 in 4 Florida adults aren't registered to vote, according to non-partisan group

    Legislature

    TALLAHASSEE — Five million people in Florida who are eligible to vote aren't registered, according to a nationwide non-partisan group that helps improve the accuracy of state voter rolls.

    Voters line up in front of the Coliseum Ballroom in St. Petersburg on Nov. 8. A non-partisan group estimates that more than a quarter of Florida's adult-age population isn't registered to vote. [SCOTT KEELER | Tampa Bay Times]
  4. Rays morning after: A lot that went into a marathon win

    Blogs

    Rays manager Kevin Cash had a simple strategy when Fox Sports Sun's Alex Corddry asked him how the team would move on from Sunday's marathon win and get ready to face the Rangers tonight in Texas:

    Kevin Kiermaier of the Rays celebrates as teammate Michael Martinez slides safely into home plate to score a run against the Minnesota Twins during the 14th inning.
  5. Navy parachutist dies during demonstration over Hudson River

    Military

    JERSEY CITY, N.J. — In the shadow of the Statue of Liberty, a Navy Seal team member fell to his death Sunday after his parachute failed to open during a Fleet Week demonstration over the Hudson River.

    Officials surround a U.S. Navy Seal's parachute that landed in a parking lot after the parachutist fell into the Hudson River when his parachute failed to open during a Fleet Week demonstration over the river in Jersey City, N.J. The Navy said the parachutist was pronounced dead at Jersey City Medical Center. [Joe Shine | Jersey Journal via AP]