Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Tamra Leasure testifies in Tampa murder trial that she was fighting for her life

Tamra Leasure describes the second of third shots she fired in quick succession, killing Arthur Tilley in 2009 in her home. Leasure is on trial for second-degree murder.


Tamra Leasure describes the second of third shots she fired in quick succession, killing Arthur Tilley in 2009 in her home. Leasure is on trial for second-degree murder.

TAMPA — The way Tamra Leasure sees it, her house guest got too cozy when he started calling her Riverview home "our house."

They had known each other just two months, Leasure and her friend Arthur Tilley, but the argument the night of March 5, 2009, quickly escalated from "this isn't 'our' house" to a fight about jealousy, control and marriage.

It ended with Leasure killing Tilley with three gunshots.

"All I know is he had those crazy eyes," Leasure, 45, testified Wednesday in her trial on a second-degree murder charge.

Prosecutors say stripping away the lies from her changing story will show she wasn't acting in self-defense. Among them: Leasure initially told investigators it was Tilley's gun and that he shot himself in the head before she took the gun from him.

Leasure testified Wednesday in Hillsborough County court that she was standing her ground.

"Why, why would I do that," Leasure asked jurors, "unless he was going to kill me?"

On the second day of testimonies, jurors learned more about the complicated relationship Leasure said never went beyond a peck-on-the-cheek friendship.

Leasure met Tilley in Orlando two months before the shooting. On the first day they knew each other, Tilley gave her a ring to wear on her thumb.

They stayed in the same hotel suite, talking all night.

But they parted ways the next morning when Tilley, 57, of Maine bit a waitress on the shoulder at the hotel restaurant.

He was drunk and was arrested, subsequently charged with battery of a law enforcement officer.

From there, Tilley and Leasure spoke on the phone four or five times a week. He sent her a Valentine's Day gift: pink shoes with flowers in them.

Tilley, who was an alcoholic, visited Tampa a month later, alternating staying at Leasure's house and an airport hotel.

"He wanted to marry her," Leasure's daughter, Raquel Pauley, 16, testified Wednesday. "He was getting really possessive and trying to control our family."

He woke up Raquel the night before the shooting, she said, demanding names of nearby hospitals and jails when Leasure didn't come home.

Leasure had spent the night with a boyfriend, but told Tilley her car broke down.

The next morning, Leasure said, Tilley held a plastic bag over his head, saying he would end his misery over her.

Later that evening, Leasure woke up from a nap to a phone call from one of the hospitals Tilley had checked.

She went to ask Tilley about it, who said he was cleaning "their" house. They were wearing matching blue manatee pajama pants — by coincidence, Leasure said.

He was drunk again. He wanted to know where she had been and started yelling about marrying her, she said.

"Stay away from me," Leasure said. And later, "Get out!"

He shoved her. Pointed at her bed and said it would be their bed. Told her when her daughter came home, she'd find them in body bags, she said.

"He had nothing to live for," Leasure testified.

She ran for her gun: a .38-caliber revolver tucked under her mattress. When he wrestled with her for the gun, Leasure fired a grazing shot to his head, she said.

"I knew if he got that gun, he'd kill me," she said. He came at her, which she later described as flailing his arms.

"I backed up some and just went, bam bam!" she said.

Leasure tearfully recounted this for the jurors, words pouring wildly out of her mouth between tears and gasps.

But then the Hillsborough State Attorney's Office began its cross-examination:

Tilley scared Leasure, but she left her then-14-year-old daughter alone with him overnight.

He scared her, but she could escape to get her gun.

He scared her, but he didn't pick up a knife on the kitchen counter during the fight.

Closing arguments begin this morning.

Stephanie Wang can be reached at or (813) 661-2443.

Tamra Leasure testifies in Tampa murder trial that she was fighting for her life 02/09/11 [Last modified: Thursday, February 10, 2011 7:11am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Kriseman and Baker cash race continues as campaigns officially reset


    The mayoral campaign, mostly operating in stealth mode during the two weeks of Hurricane Irma's build-up, arrival and recovery, has entered its stretch run, a compressed schedule of ten days before ballots are mailed to tens of thousands of voters in the Sunshine City.

    Mayor Rick Kriseman and former mayor Rick Baker are emerging from Hurricane Irma mode and getting back into campaign form
  2. Bucs have chance to beat Vikings in their third stadium


    Here's a cool sign that the Bucs are getting up there as an NFL franchise: If Tampa Bay can win Sunday at U.S. Bank Stadium, it will mark the first time the Bucs have posted road wins against the same NFL opponent in three different stadiums.

    TIMES ARCHIVES (2012) | Bucs RB Doug Martin runs during Tampa Bay's 36-17 win at the Vikings in 2012, in what was then called Mall of America Field. If Tampa Bay wins Sunday, it will mark the first time they have road wins against the same NFL opponent in three different stadiums.
  3. Memorial for Snooty the manatee, postponed because of Irma, to be held Sunday


    A public memorial to celebrate the life of 69-year-old Snooty the manatee will be held at the South Florida Museum on Sunday from noon to 5 p.m.

    Snooty , the world's most celebrated manatee, begs for another slice of apple in his pool in the Parker Manatee Aquarium at the South Florida Museum in Bradenton in 2008. Snooty was 60 then. [Times 2008]
  4. Residents wade through a flooded road after the passing of Hurricane Maria, in Toa Baja, Puerto Rico, Friday, September 22, 2017. Because of the heavy rains brought by Maria, thousands of people were evacuated from Toa Baja after the municipal government opened the gates of the Rio La Plata Dam. [Associated Press]
  5. NFL commissioner, players' union angrily denounce Trump comments on national anthem


    SOMERSET, N.J. — The National Football League and its players' union on Saturday angrily denounced President Donald Trump for suggesting that owners fire players who kneel during the national …

    President Donald Trump walks off the stage after he speaks at campaign rally in support of Sen. Luther Strange, Friday, Sept. 22, 2017, in Huntsville, Ala. [Associated Press]