Make us your home page
Instagram

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Sue Carlton: Gov. Rick Scott should veto confusing 'warning shot' bill

Three words on the "warning shot'' legislation about to hit the governor's desk: What a mess.

It doesn't matter whether you favor Florida's controversial "stand your ground'' law or think it dangerous. The most recent tweak to it from Tallahassee has something for everyone.

For starters, there's the potential weakening of the law even though legislators who voted "yay" surely intended to expand it. There's also, as always, a nifty gift or two for the powerful gun lobby, like the part about expunging court records in "stand your ground'' cases.

Hopefully, there's enough confusion written in —- heck, even the legislator who originally drafted "stand your ground'' is having doubts — to give Gov. Rick Scott serious pause before signing.

The law that polarized us over the infamous shooting death of an unarmed black teenager was up for changes during the legislative session — including a well-intended one in the name of Marissa Alexander of Jacksonville, sentenced to 20 years for firing what she said was a warning shot in an altercation with her estranged husband. This does seem striking when you consider no one was hit — and Trayvon Martin is dead, and George Zimmerman a free man.

A judge declined to grant Alexander "stand your ground'' immunity and a jury convicted her in 12 minutes. She has since won a new trial because of jury instruction problems.

But the idea that someone who claimed she was standing her ground and did not shoot anyone could get that kind of prison time stuck with legislators.

Somehow, the effort to tweak "stand your ground'' to protect those who fire legitimate warning shots or threaten force got twisted in the final version awaiting the governor's pen. It appears, in certain circumstances, to add a requirement that the person who uses deadly force reasonably believed it necessary to prevent not just death or great bodily harm, but "imminent" death or great bodily harm. As in, something just about to happen to them. Which would seem to narrow the law rather than expand its protection.

Now, if you are someone who already believed that "stand your ground'' was unnecessary, that self-defense already worked in Florida and that this swag for the National Rifle Association has been applied unevenly across the state since, maybe you don't object to the addition of "imminent."

But this bill is almost dizzyingly written. Pinellas County Sheriff Bob Gualtieri — a lawyer, by the way, who generally supports "stand your ground'' protections with some exceptions — called it confusing even for people who regularly deal with this. "Legislation should be direct. It should be straightforward," Gualtieri told me. "It should be easily understood so people will know what the rules are."

This law would also allow the expunging of court records when charges are dropped in "stand your ground'' cases, alarming to those of us who believe the public record ought to be both complete and, well, public.

Now it's up to Scott. And in the thick of a tough re-election battle against Charlie Crist, it's politically dicey for him to veto anything with the fighting words "stand your ground" attached. But rejecting legislation that confuses an already intensely complex issue seems a no-brainer, no matter where you stand on "stand your ground.''

Sue Carlton: Gov. Rick Scott should veto confusing 'warning shot' bill 05/23/14 [Last modified: Friday, May 23, 2014 8:18pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times

    

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

Loading...
  1. A Taste of Tampa Bay: Noble Crust in St. Petersburg

    Food & Dining

    Noble Crust opened on north 4th Street in St. Petersburg, an area light on ambitious restaurants, in 2015. Chef Rob Reinsmith and his team are serving up a blend of southern cuisine and Italian-style cooking, including the restaurant's signature fried chicken. The Noble Crust brand recently expanded beyond its St. …

    Pizza at Noble Crust. [Photo by MONICA HERNDON | TIMES]
  2. HomeTeam 100: Players 11-20

    Footballpreps

    Armwood wide receiver Warren Thompson is seen during the spring football jamboree at Plant City High School in Plant City, Fla., on Thursday, May 19, 2016.
  3. Bar review: Cheap drinks do fine at the Joint in St. Petersburg

    Bars & Spirits

    The Tyrone area of St. Petersburg is a little light on drinking spots, so the locals must have been happy when a long-running neighborhood spot — formerly Donk's Sports Tavern and Double J's Sports Bar — reopened earlier this year as the Joint.

    Patrons sit at the bar in the Joint in St. Petersburg.
  4. Local Craft Beer of the Week: Fireberry Tea Ale, Sea Dog Brewing Co.

    Bars & Spirits

    Clearwater's Sea Dog Brewing Co. doesn't get enough credit. Most craft beer drinkers familiar with the near-ubiquitous Sea Dog and Shipyard brands, which have been brewed in Maine since the early '90s, erroneously conclude that the Clearwater location is more of the same. But this location, opened in 2013, features its …

    Justin Grant/Special to tbt*
  5. Jeff Bezos tops Bill Gates as world's richest person — for now

    Corporate

    A surge in Amazon.com Inc. shares Thursday morning in advance of the online retailer's earnings report has propelled founder Jeff Bezos past Bill Gates as the world's richest person, according to a Bloomberg report.

    Jeff Bezos, the founder of Amazon, discusses his Blue Origin reusable rocket project in Colorado Springs in April. A bump in the price of Amazon shares in July of 2017 was enough to move  Bezos above Bill Gates, the Microsoft co-founder, who has topped Forbes' billionaires list 18 out of the last 23 years. 
(Nick Cote | The New York Times]