Make us your home page
Instagram

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Federal judge raises questions about Florida's random drug-testing policy

MIAMI — A federal judge in Miami on Wednesday cast serious doubts about Gov. Rick Scott's order requiring thousands of state government employees to undergo a random drug test, suggesting his policy "sweeps too broadly."

U.S. District Judge Ursula Ungaro peppered a government lawyer with questions about the constitutionality of Scott's policy, saying she had "trouble understanding the circumstances under which the executive order would be valid."

Jesse Panuccio, deputy general counsel for Scott's office, did not provide specific examples but rather talked generally about the harm of drug use among state employees in the workplace. "Drugs are very harmful," he told the judge. "They're very dangerous."

Ungaro said she would soon make up her mind about the legal challenge to Scott's policy by the American Civil Liberties Union of Florida.

The group argues that his order violates the Fourth Amendment rights of state workers because the testing requirement is "suspicionless" and therefore an illegal search and seizure.

"For the consent (to the search) to be valid, it has to be voluntary," ACLU lawyer Shalini Goel Agarwal argued. "This blanket drug testing is unconstitutional."

The legal challenge to the governor's order, which has been placed on hold by Scott himself until the dispute is resolved, centers on whether the state has a constitutional right to require random drug tests of existing public workers and mandatory testing of all new employees. The governor issued his order last March.

Meanwhile, the Legislature is considering a proposed law that would mandate random drug tests of state employees every three months.

As it stands, Scott's order affects a pool of 80,000 state employees who work for agencies under the governor, but does not extend to agencies overseen jointly by the governor and Cabinet, such as the departments of Revenue and Education or the Public Service Commission.

Scott has defended the order as a policy the public wants, and a protection the state should have.

"Look, the private sector does this all the time," Scott said last June, when he suspended his order on drug testing while the federal court in Miami hears the ACLU challenge.

"Our taxpayers expect our state employees to be productive, and this is exactly what the private sector does," he said.

But the ACLU, which is representing the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, the nation's largest union for state workers, counters that random drug testing was ruled unconstitutional in a 2004 case against the Florida Department of Juvenile Justice.

Random drug testing is not allowed, a federal judge ruled in that case, except for those jobs that affect public safety and in instances where a reasonable suspicion of abuse exists.

Federal courts in Florida and other states have cited the Fourth Amendment right against unreasonable searches, concluding that governments cannot require job applicants to take drug tests absent a "special need," such as safety.

In October, a federal judge in Orlando echoed that legal view when she temporarily blocked Florida's controversial law requiring welfare applicants be drug tested to qualify for benefits.

Miami Herald staff writer Toluse Olorunnipa contributed to this story.

Federal judge raises questions about Florida's random drug-testing policy 02/22/12 [Last modified: Wednesday, February 22, 2012 6:35pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times

    

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

Loading...
  1. Man found dead in Dunedin canal identified as missing 63-year-old

    Public Safety

    DUNEDIN — Pinellas County sheriff's deputies on Tuesday identified the man found floating in a Dunedin canal as the man who was reported missing last week.

    Charles P. Morris, 63, was found dead in a canal in Dunedin behind Cedar Creek Mobile Home Park, at 605 Michigan Blvd. around 3:48 p.m. Monday. He was reported missing June 21 after he was last seen leaving his home the night before to walk his dog. [ Courtesy of the Pinellas County Sheriff's Office]
  2. A Time magazine with Trump on the cover hangs in his golf clubs. It's fake

    National

    The framed copy of Time magazine was hung up in at least four of President Trump's golf clubs, from South Florida to Scotland. Filling the entire cover was a photo of Donald Trump.

    A framed copy of Time magazine, dated March 1, 2009, that hangs in at least four of President Donald Trump's golf clubs, from South Florida to Scotland, is fake. There was no March 1, 2009, issue of Time. The real March 2, 2009, issue of Time featured actor Kate Winslet on the cover. But the issue makes no mention of Trump. [Left, Time; right, Angel Valentin for the Washington Post]
  3. Editorial: The human cost of slashing Medicaid

    Editorials

    Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell had no choice Tuesday but to postpone voting this week on a bill to repeal the Affordable Care Act that is just as devastating as the version passed by the House. The Congressional Budget Office's estimate that Senate bill would eliminate health care coverage for 22 million …

    Clay Bennett, Chattanooga Times Free Press
  4. Vince Young takes shot at Bucs' Ryan Fitzpatrick

    Blogs

    Former NFL quarterback Vince Young, out of the league since 2011 and complaining about not getting more opportunities to prolong his career, took a shot at new Bucs backup Ryan Fitzpatrick in a story posted at …

    Veteran quarterback Ryan Fitzpatrick, who signed with the Bucs to be Jameis Winston's backup this fall, has played for six other NFL teams in his 12 seasons in the league.
  5. Editorial: Scott's poor choice for CFO

    Editorials

    Gov. Rick Scott didn't reach too deeply into Florida's talent pool in appointing his friend Jimmy Patronis to fill a vacancy as the state's new chief financial officer. This is an exceptionally weak choice for a Cabinet post that requires a sophisticated understanding of banking and other financial services, and it …