Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Florida Supreme Court justice calls politics a threat to legal system

TAMPA — Another Florida Supreme Court justice targeted by the Republican Party in this year's merit retention election pleaded with Tampa attorneys Friday to help keep partisan politics out of the judiciary.

"No fair, impartial court means no justice, no freedom," said Justice Peggy Quince, speaking to the Young Lawyers Division of the Hillsborough County Bar Association.

It's the latest direct pitch to Tampa lawyers for support from a state Supreme Court justice since the state GOP's executive board announced in September it opposed three justices up for merit retention on the Nov. 6 ballot. Until now, a political party has never formally involved itself in merit retention since it was adopted in the 1970s to reform a corrupt judiciary.

But in this election Justices Quince, R. Fred Lewis and Barbara Pariente are all opposed by the Republican Party of Florida because of their "activist" and liberal views.

Three weeks ago, Lewis told the Hillsborough Bar Association that the election "is the most stressful time I've ever experienced in my life. There is an entire branch of government to protect and defend. We cannot sacrifice fairness and impartiality and the court system to political whims."

On Friday, Quince, who has passed merit retention twice, reminded lawyers that the process was made a part of the state constitution in 1976 after two justices resigned amid a corruption scandal.

"Merit retention is not about whether you agree with every decision," she said. "If that was the case, we'd be constantly changing judges. The real criteria are character, fitness and demeanor."

Quince said she feared politicization could work its way through the judiciary down to the local trial courts.

"This is about whether the judiciary will survive."

Supporters and opponents of the justices have begun airing television ads — another first in the history of merit retention.

John Barry can be reached at (813) 226-3383 or

Florida Supreme Court justice calls politics a threat to legal system 10/12/12 [Last modified: Friday, October 12, 2012 9:14pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Miami woman, 74, admits to voter fraud. Does jail await, or will she go free?

    State Roundup

    MIAMI — An 74-year-old woman pleaded guilty Monday to filling out other people's mail-in ballots while working at Miami-Dade's elections department.

    Gladys Coego
  2. In Twitter rant, Bucs' Gerald McCoy says he's unappreciated


    Gerald McCoy is feeling underappreciated again. He says somebody has crossed the line this time. He's speaking out and suggesting he might be gone "soon enough" from Tampa Bay.

    Photo Illustration RON BORRESEN   |   Photo by LOREN ELLIOTT   |   Times 
Gerald McCoy may be upset that Ronde Barber said a defensive leader “has to have a huge personality’’ like Warren Sapp’s. Monday, Barber walked that back.
  3. Bigger ships carry Georgia ports to record cargo volumes

    Economic Development

    SAVANNAH, Ga. — Bigger ships arriving through an expanded Panama Canal pushed cargo volumes at Georgia's seaports to record levels in fiscal 2017, the Georgia Ports Authority announced Monday.

    The Port of Savannah moved a record 3.85 million container units in fiscal 2017, the state said, benefiting from the larger ships that can now pass through an expanded Panama Canal.
  4. Photo gallery: Nine years later, library attack victim Queena works at learning to walk again


    Slowly, Queena Phu is learning the act of walking again through exercises in locomotion, strength and balance.
    She practiced her steps once again Monday afternoon with trainer-technician Mike Lopez at the nonprofit Stay In Step Spinal Cord Injury Recovery Center near the University of South Florida.
    Queena …

    Activity based exercise trainer George Palang, 33, and trainer technician Mike Lopez, 22, help Queena Phu during physical therapy at the Stay In Step Spinal Cord Injury Recovery Center on Monday, July 24, 2017, in Tampa, Fla.
  5. Rays' Evan Longoria: "We have all the belief in the world in here"


    The weekend sweep by Texas and four-game overall losing streak has some Rays fans - based on their tweets and emails - questioning the team's ability to make the playoffs and suggesting they might as well trade away their key parts.