Monday, November 20, 2017
News Roundup

Sue Carlton: Heartening news — Judge says facts must be facts

RECOMMENDED READING


The case currently playing out in Tampa's federal court looked like a done deal, like a thousand done deals before and a thousand more to come.

Not that the allegations aren't incendiary.

A 28-year-old son of a gynecologist is accused of tricking his pregnant ex into taking an abortion pill disguised as a common antibiotic. She miscarried.

So yes, there are plenty of life-versus-choice implications in this one.

But a proposed plea deal hashed out between the lawyers to end this prior to trial was pretty much dime a dozen. As is the nature of such deals, neither side would get everything, and everyone gets something.

John Andrew Welden would no longer face the prospect of life in prison with the charge of murder under the 2004 Unborn Victims of Violence Act dropped.

And prosecutors would get to put him away for a not-insignificant 13 years and 8 months for product tampering causing serious bodily injury plus mail fraud.

And everyone could avoid the big gamble of what a jury of regular folk might make of this ugly tale.

Done deal, right? Except for a judge who was paying attention.

In an unusual move days before sentencing, U.S. District Judge Richard Lazzara officially noted what he saw as a serious problem. The judge pointed to a lack of evidence as to whether the single Cytotec pill Remee Jo Lee took indeed "caused her to suffer serious bodily injury and caused the death of her unborn embryo."

All of which could seriously affect how much time Welden faces under sentencing guidelines — and could even knock that range down as low as 3 years and three months to 5 years and three months.

Defense experts — whose resumes the judge describes as "impressive" — have already opined there is no way to say for sure that one pill did this.

But prosecutors did not trot out counter-experts prior to the plea deal. And so the judge has "grave concerns" about "whether there exists a true factual basis" for the plea agreement.

Now: Wouldn't it be easier for him to rubber stamp this and move on to the next case, since both sides already agreed?

Except for that part about the justice system being only as strong as the rules that form it.

It's no secret that appointed federal judges seem at times able to act outside the influence of public outrage. U.S. District Judge James Moody initially threw out a case against the girlfriend of the killer of two Tampa police officers, charges that seemed a tad contrived no matter how much you disliked her actions that night. How much more difficult would it have been for an elected state judge to do the same in a case so emotional?

Speaking of state court, this week a Hillsborough teacher was sentenced to 38 years in prison for lewd acts on a 12-year-old boy. What she did was reprehensible and deserving of punishment. But, and I will be stoned in the public square for this one, is she a criminal who needs to be imprisoned for nearly four decades? When, for perspective, a drunken driver who killed two pedestrians — killed them — recently got a plea deal for less than a third of that?

Prosecutors now must prove their case against Welden "by a preponderance of the evidence." (Program note: One of their experts is Dr. Cathy Lynch of USF's Morsani College of Medicine, and also wife of Tampa Mayor Bob Buckhorn.)

Prosecutors may well accomplish that and the deal can go down, or this ending could change. Either way, it's heartening to hear a judge say facts have to be actual facts, and getting it right for the record matters.

Comments
How did UCF go from 0-12 to unbeaten? Coaching and chemistry

How did UCF go from 0-12 to unbeaten? Coaching and chemistry

ORLANDO — The marvel of Space Mountain dissipated decades ago. Doctor Doom’s Fearfall at Universal, while a nifty defiance of gravity, has its ups and downs. Big Thunder Mountain Railroad? Please. To many locals, Orlando’s most dizzying experience — ...
Updated: 20 minutes ago
‘I tried,’ mother of killer Adam Matos says at sentencing

‘I tried,’ mother of killer Adam Matos says at sentencing

NEW PORT RICHEY — His family described him as a loving, kind-hearted father. His neighbors regarded him as quiet and respectful. His friends recalled him as "happy-go-lucky," a "laid-back, fun guy."Thirteen witnesses told of a softer side of Adam Mat...
Updated: 25 minutes ago
Bucs journal: Dirk Koetter says Doug Martin’s not at fault for struggling running game

Bucs journal: Dirk Koetter says Doug Martin’s not at fault for struggling running game

TAMPA — RB Doug Martin had just 38 yards on 19 carries in Sunday’s win against the Dolphins, but coach Dirk Koetter said his team’s struggles running the ball shouldn’t go squarely on his running back."In my opinion, he is not the reason we’re not mo...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Sex assault reports declining at MacDill despite increase militarywide

Sex assault reports declining at MacDill despite increase militarywide

TAMPA — The number of sexual assaults reported to officials at MacDill Air Force Base has decreased dramatically during the past three years even as reports across the military have increased slightly, new Pentagon statistics show.Officials at MacDil...
Updated: 1 hour ago
UF has little to say after meeting with Kelly

UF has little to say after meeting with Kelly

GAINESVILLE — At last, there’s some actual smoke to the Chip Kelly-Florida rumors.The Gators sent a group — including president Kent Fuchs and athletic director Scott Stricklin — to New Hampshire on Sunday to talk with the former Oregon coach about U...
Updated: 1 hour ago
NTSB report details steep turns and dives preceding Roy Halladay’s fatal crash

NTSB report details steep turns and dives preceding Roy Halladay’s fatal crash

Before he crashed, Roy Halladay flew within 75 feet of houses and skimmed the surface of the Gulf of Mexico, according to a report published Monday by the National Transportation Safety Board.The report, which did not address the cause of the crash, ...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Debunking some theories about why the Bucs are keeping Jameis Winston on the shelf

Debunking some theories about why the Bucs are keeping Jameis Winston on the shelf

TAMPA — The Bucs are sticking with Ryan Two and Oh Fitzpatrick at quarterback for Sunday’s game in Atlanta.But this isn’t a case of just riding the guy who has the cool head and hot hand.Doctors would not clear starter Jameis Winston to begin throwin...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Top 5 at noon: Adam Matos sentencing begins; Seminole Heights thanks first responders; and more

Top 5 at noon: Adam Matos sentencing begins; Seminole Heights thanks first responders; and more

Here are the latest headlines and updates on tampabay.com:SENTENCING PHASE CONTINUES IN TRIAL OF ADAM MATOS, FOUND GUILTY IN MURDER OF FOURThe sentencing phase begins Monday in the trial of Adam Matos, convicted Friday of first degree murder in the ...
Updated: 2 hours ago
UPDATED: Crocodile spotted lurking on Florida beach has been captured (w/video)

UPDATED: Crocodile spotted lurking on Florida beach has been captured (w/video)

HOLLYWOOD, Fla. — Authorities say they’ve captured a 6-foot (2-meter) crocodile that came ashore on a Florida beach.News outlets report that wildlife officers caught the large reptile Monday afternoon on Hollywood Beach.Hollywood spokeswoman Joann Hu...
Updated: 2 hours ago
HomeTeam Hot Shot winners: Nick Ferrini and Kellyn Trowse

HomeTeam Hot Shot winners: Nick Ferrini and Kellyn Trowse

HomeTeam Hot Shots Nick Ferrini, MitchellOn Monday, Ferrini embarked on a five-day cruise with 30 family members. "Parents, grandparents, uncles, aunts, cousins, you name it," he said. Destinations during the trip include Key West, The Bahamas and a...
Updated: 2 hours ago