Make us your home page
Instagram

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Hillsborough judge recuses himself from DUI case

Judge Ronald Ficarrotta
said he wanted
“to avoid even the appearance of impropriety.”

Judge Ronald Ficarrotta said he wanted “to avoid even the appearance of impropriety.”

In 14 years on the bench, Hillsborough Circuit Judge Ronald Ficarrotta has heard countless alcohol-related cases.

But a mention of Mothers Against Drunk Driving on his judicial Web page recently made one defendant question how fair Ficarrotta could be.

The man, accused of drinking before a crash that killed his passenger, worried that Ficarrotta might be swayed by his connection to MADD. He wanted the judge off his case.

It might sound like a fine point — who isn't against drunken driving? — but legal experts say the unusual request raised a legitimate concern about judges' off-duty affiliations.

"You've just got to be real circumspect about the things that you're engaged in," Pinellas Circuit Judge Philip J. Federico said. "When you're making decisions about someone's liberty, that tends to make them a little more sensitive to what your thought process is."

While judges are supposed to avoid activities that cast doubt on their impartiality, the authors of judicial canons realized it was "neither possible nor wise" for members of the bench to live in isolation.

Non-binding ethics opinions demonstrate how tricky it can be for judges to navigate community involvement. Yes, they can serve as celebrity waiters for charity. But, no, they can't sit on a domestic violence council that becomes an advocacy group.

Questions often arise over MADD, now the nation's largest victim's advocacy organization.

National MADD rules prohibit the organization from contributing to judges' political campaigns. But members lobby lawmakers for stiffer DUI penalties and attend court hearings to support victims.

Attorney Stephen Romine doesn't have a problem with MADD's mission or Ficarrotta.

But when he took over Anthony Urso's alcohol-related vehicular homicide case last month, the Tampa attorney and his client noticed a worrisome combination:

On the bench sat the felony judge whose Web page mentioned MADD involvement.

In court with the victim's family sat Becky Gage, a widely known MADD advocate who monitors such hearings.

Romine filed a motion to disqualify Ficarrotta.

"I'm sure he didn't have any intent when he put it in there," Romine said of the Web reference. "But the fact of the matter is it's extremely reasonable for a person facing this kind of charge to be concerned."

The state's Judicial Ethics Advisory Committee considers MADD an "advocacy group" but has never called for an absolute ban of judicial participation. Advisory opinions have approved of judges participating in a panel discussion about underage drinking and attending candlelight vigils for victims of impaired drivers as long as the judges did not get special recognition.

The committee stopped short of saying no judges could serve on MADD's board of directors, but cautioned that the leadership role could be problematic for county judges who routinely hear drunken driving cases.

"It would be virtually impossible for a judge to lock themselves in a box outside the courtroom and not have any involvement with any community activities," said Don Murray, state director for MADD. "That's why the process for recusal is there."

Judges can voluntarily remove themselves from cases where they see a conflict.

Assistant State Attorney Kim Seace, who is prosecuting Urso's case, argued in a motion that he had not demonstrated a well-founded fear of actual bias.

But on March 11, Ficarrotta found Romine's motion legally sufficient and removed himself from the case.

The judge also deleted MADD and all his other community activities, including the Kiwanis Club and United Way, from his judicial Web page.

Why?

"To avoid even the appearance of impropriety," Ficarrotta said. "I can certainly see why a defendant would be concerned about that."

He said he never had much contact with MADD, which the organization confirms. Years ago, he attended a couple of memorial vigils and dinners honoring law enforcement. Like many of his other community listings, the MADD item was outdated, the judge said.

No criminal judges in Pinellas, Pasco or Hernando counties are actively involved with MADD.

If they were, Pinellas-Pasco Public Defender Bob Dillinger would be quick to protest. As a private attorney in the early 1990s, he questioned why Pinellas County used taxpayer money to send MADD official notice of all felony DUI cases, a practice that continues today.

"You cannot be a member of a group that advocates a certain position and then you're supposed to be a neutral arbitrator," Dillinger said. "Judges need to be neutral."

Circuit Judge Gregory Holder, Hillsborough's only other jurist with a known MADD connection, cut ties after learning of Romine's motion.

Holder, who also hears felony cases, writes a monthly column in a biker magazine and had said publicly that he donated the $50 check for each column to MADD. He made four donations but won't make any more.

"I don't want to provide any basis that's grounds for disqualification," he said.

Gage, MADD's victim advocate in Hillsborough, doesn't think all the fuss is necessary.

She has never seen Ficarrotta or Holder demonstrate bias against accused impaired drivers, she said. She called the motion to disqualify Ficarrotta "a shame."

"No matter what division they're in, they will have their personal feelings and opinions about things," Gage said. "I think that they can put their personal feelings aside and do what's right."

Colleen Jenkins can be reached at [email protected] or (813) 226-3337.

Hillsborough judge recuses himself from DUI case 03/21/08 [Last modified: Tuesday, March 25, 2008 1:03pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times

    

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

Loading...
  1. Editorial: UF shows how to preserve free speech

    Editorials

    The University of Florida was forced to navigate a treacherous terrain of constitutional concerns and public safety this week, all in a glaring public spotlight. In the end, Thursday's appearance by Richard Spencer was a success — as much as an unwelcome visit from a notorious white nationalist can be. The …

  2. Blake High grad Taylor Trensch lands lead role in 'Dear Evan Hansen' on Broadway

    Stage

    For those who saw Taylor Trensch grow up in Tampa, his rise from promising student to star is heartwarming and entirely predictable. In January, Trensch, 28, will be moving into the title role of Dear Evan Hansen on Broadway, one of the hottest tickets in theater.

    Taylor Trensch, a 2007 Blake High graduate, will play the title role in Broadway's Dear Evan Hansen. Courtesy of Frank Trensch.
  3. Editorial: When protest leads to understanding

    Editorials

    The protests against racial injustice by professional athletes across the country include examples of communities where it has not been handled well. And then there is the example set in Tampa Bay.

  4. Why it's too early to give up on the Bucs

    Bucs

    Don't panic. It's not too late for the Bucs.

    Tampa Bay Buccaneers quarterback Jameis Winston (3) and wide receiver Mike Evans (13) celebrate after the defense recovered a fumble during the second half of an NFL game between the Tampa Bay Buccaneers and Arizona Cardinals at University of Phoenix Stadium in Glendale, Ariz., on Sunday, Oct. 15, 2017. LOREN ELLIOTT   |   Times 

  5. Backlog of immigration cases under Trump stymies immigrants in Florida

    Courts

    It was supposed to be a routine green card renewal for a Thai woman who has called Central Florida home for years.

    Immigration lawyers such as Gerald P. Seipp of Clearwater worry that their clients' circumstances will change with long delays in their immigration court appeals, hurting their chances of staying in the country. [SCOTT KEELER   |   Times]