Monday, December 18, 2017
News Roundup

How Gov. Rick Scott's noncitizen voter purge started

Florida's latest elections controversy began in the smallest of ways: a five-minute chat last year between Gov. Rick Scott and his top election official.

At the time, about February 2011, the newly elected governor was touring the office run by then-Secretary of State Kurt Browning, who put on a presentation about Florida's voting rolls and elections issues for the political newcomer.

That's when Scott — a Republican who campaigned as an immigration hard-liner — asked: How do we know everyone on the rolls is a U.S. citizen?

"I said it was an honor system," Browning recalls. "That's how it's always been done."

"People don't always tell the truth," Browning recalled Scott saying.

So Browning decided to find out how many noncitizens were actually on the rolls.

Now, more than a year later, the effort has produced three federal lawsuits, widespread suspicion and bitter partisanship, echoing the recriminations of Florida's controversial 2000 elections that still haunt the state.

The latest suit was filed Tuesday by the U.S. Department of Justice, which claims Florida's purge program violates two federal voting laws. Florida denies the charges.

To those on the political left, the voter purge looks like a concerted effort by Republicans to get an edge at the ballot box. But in the words and deeds of Browning, Scott and elections officials in Florida, the purge looks like a poorly managed program that became unexpectedly controversial to an administration filled with political newcomers.

Browning was one of the few seasoned Florida officials on Scott's leadership team. He served for 26 years as Pasco County's elections supervisor. He then became Florida's secretary of state and oversaw two major elections in 2006 and 2008 without much controversy — a rarity in Florida — before Scott called him back to Tallahassee.

In Washington, President Barack Obama's administration was suspicious of Scott's effort to spot noncitizens and remove them from the rolls. The request came around the same time Scott signed a law cracking down on voter-registration drives and eliminating early voting on the Sunday before Election Day. As part of its noncitizen program, Florida wanted the U.S. Department of Homeland Security to give the state access to a mammoth immigration database called SAVE. DHS has refused since October 2011.

Browning's elections division then relied on another state agency, the Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles, which had limited and often-outdated citizenship information that carried a high risk of making lawful voters look like noncitizens.

The first list came back: 182,000 potential noncitizens on the voter rolls.

After more work and reshaping, the elections division produced a second list of nearly 25,000 potential voters.

The numbers were high. Too high for Browning.

Browning knew the programmatic, political and legal pitfalls of the noncitizen voter-purge program. He knew the voter rolls — like any massive database — has errors. And comparing the rolls to another database can compound those errors.

So if the state sent elections supervisors a list that wasn't vetted enough, it would cause an uproar. And, because the noncitizen effort by definition targeted immigrants, it would disproportionately hit Hispanics and Haitians.

Lastly, the frontline officials in charge of each county's voting rolls — the 67 election supervisors, the overwhelming majority of them elected — would balk.

Browning refused to release the list.

"I consciously decided not to get them in the loop," Browning said. "I didn't feel comfortable rolling this initiative out. Something was telling me this isn't going to fly."

Browning called it his "Spidey sense," and said he was not just concerned with the numbers, but how they were obtained. His agency wasn't doing the checking. Instead, it shipped names to the highway department, which performed the checks.

"We were not getting first-hand data," he said. "I wanted to make sure we are 99.9 percent certain. I wanted to make sure the data was good if it went out under my name."

Browning said there's a good chance the names would never have been released. It wasn't a "front-burner issue. Rick Scott didn't order me to do this."

All of that appeared to change by coincidence in February.

Browning was leaving office. At the same time, a television reporter at NBC2 in Fort Myers decided to match Lee County voter rolls with a list of people who were excused from jury service after they said they were noncitizens. NBC2 reported finding nearly 100 noncitizens on the rolls. The local elections supervisor has found more than 40.

Republicans, long concerned that phony voters were on the rolls, started wondering what the state was doing about noncitizen voters. Scott and Browning's successor, Secretary of State Ken Detzner, felt pressured to release the list, which the state did in April, Browning said.

"I would not have sent the list to the counties," Browning said, adding he "cannot second-guess Secretary Detzner because I wasn't up there."

The Scott administration figured that legitimate citizens listed as potential noncitizens weren't really in danger of having their voting rights removed. After all, they would have up to 60 days to prove their citizenship and remain on the rolls. And even if they were removed, they could be reinstated easily or even cast provisional ballots on Election Day in worst-case scenarios.

So in April, after checking and rechecking its list, the state sent supervisors nearly 2,700 names.

It was filled with the high level of false positives that Browning feared. So far, more than 500 people on the list have been identified as citizens. More than 140 have been identified as noncitizens and about 50 may have unlawfully cast a ballot, Scott said Monday.

When asked about Browning's recollection of events and why the state decided to release the list when it did, Scott didn't answer.

"What I'm focused on is making sure that no U.S. citizen — no Florida citizen's — vote is diluted by noncitizens," he said Tuesday.

"The debate is over about whether people are out there that are non-U.S. citizens who registered to vote. They have," Scott said. "There's no debate about whether they've voted. They have. There's no debate that they can impact elections. They can."

Atlanta airport power outage cancels 1,000 flights; more Delta cancellations Monday

Atlanta airport power outage cancels 1,000 flights; more Delta cancellations Monday

ATLANTA — A sudden power outage brought the world’s busiest airport to a standstill Sunday, grounding more than 1,000 flights in Atlanta just days before the start of the Christmas travel rush. Authorities announced that electricity would be restored...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Bucs-Falcons: Things to watch in Monday’s 8:30 p.m. game

Bucs-Falcons: Things to watch in Monday’s 8:30 p.m. game

TAMPA — The Bucs and Falcons have each won three straight games on Monday nights as they face each other on a national platform tonight at Raymond James Stadium.How can Tampa Bay continue its streak and stop Atlanta’s? It won’t be easy, but given the...
Updated: 2 hours ago

Bitcoin futures begin trading on CME, price little changed

NEW YORK — Another security based on the price of bitcoin, the digital currency that has soared in value and volatility this year, began trading on the Chicago Mercantile Exchange on Sunday. The CME Group, which owns the exchange, opened up bitcoin f...
Updated: 2 hours ago

Woman shot and killed in apparent drive-by shooting in Clearwater

CLEARWATER — A woman was shot to death Sunday night in an apparent drive-by shooting, according to Clearwater police.Authorities said they received an initial call at 8:19 p.m. originating from 800 Belleair Road. The shooting is believed to have occu...
Updated: 2 hours ago
Bucs fans call for Jon Gruden — why was he fired to begin with?

Bucs fans call for Jon Gruden — why was he fired to begin with?

TAMPA — The beers and the "love ya, bros" were flowing Saturday night at the Hooters in Tampa. Jon Gruden, who will be inducted into the Bucs Ring of Honor at halftime of tonight’s home game against the Falcons, worked the room, greeting family, frie...
Updated: 2 hours ago
Fennelly: Jon Gruden was one hard-working bro

Fennelly: Jon Gruden was one hard-working bro

TAMPA — It’s ridiculous that it took this long to give Jon Gruden a night all his own, given the nights he gave Bucs fans. But it will happen this evening at Raymond James Stadium, a salute to the thermonuclear source of that Super Bowl season, that ...
Updated: 3 hours ago
Massachusetts rolls 100-foot-long joint; McCain likely to miss tax bill vote; Cherokee Nation’s fear of losing heritage drives opioid lawsuit; more in U.S. news

Massachusetts rolls 100-foot-long joint; McCain likely to miss tax bill vote; Cherokee Nation’s fear of losing heritage drives opioid lawsuit; more in U.S. news

Massachusetts Rolling a fat one — 100 feet longMarijuana aficionados have rolled a 100-foot-long joint. The effort was led by Boston-based cannabis club and advocacy group Beantown Greentown during an exhibition of pro-marijuana vendors and supporter...
Updated: 4 hours ago
Trump says he isn’t considering firing Mueller

Trump says he isn’t considering firing Mueller

WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump said Sunday that he is not considering firing special counsel Robert Mueller even as his administration was again forced to grapple with the growing Russia inquiry that has shadowed the White House for much of his ...
Updated: 4 hours ago
Friendly competition

Friendly competition

Updated: 4 hours ago

More than 300 cruise passengers fall ill with stomach virus

PORT EVERGLADES — More than 300 passengers on a cruise ship that docked at Port Everglades fell ill with a stomach virus. The Naples Daily News reported that the Royal Caribbean Cruises Limited’s ship Independence docked Saturday in Florida reported ...
Updated: 5 hours ago