Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Judge Paul M. Hawkes should have disqualified himself from St. Joe case, lawyers say

TALLAHASSEE — Lawyers for 75 property owners fighting the St. Joe Co. over paper mill waste dumped on their land asked the Florida Supreme Court on Friday to set aside a 1st District Court of Appeal decision against them.

The petition says Judge Paul M. Hawkes, who wrote the decision, should have disqualified himself from hearing the case or at least disclosed his potential conflict of interest: He was the driving force behind the effort to build a new courthouse for the appellate court and needed concessions from St. Joe to build it at Southwood, a St. Joe development.

"Any reasonable person should have known that recusal was called for," attorney Robert C. Kerrigan wrote in the petition. "Disclosure was clearly required in this case.

"Had the information about the court's relationship with St. Joe (and certainly Judge Hawkes' relationship) been disclosed, the petitioners would have promptly, though respectfully, requested the entire court to recuse so that disinterested judges from another district could decide the fate of the company that would decide whether the courthouse could be built in Southwood."

Officials at the district court said late Friday that they had not received a copy of the petition and could not comment.

The residents and their lawyers didn't learn of the relationship between the company and the 1st DCA judges until August, Kerrigan wrote, from articles about the opulent new courthouse published in the St. Petersburg Times.

Nearing completion in Southwood, about 6 miles east of the state Capitol, the courthouse has been dubbed the "Taj Mahal" or "Taj MaHawkes" by critics who contend that in tough economic times, there is no place for a $48 million state building with granite countertops, miles of African mahogany and personal bathrooms and kitchens for the judges.

Kerrigan's petition says Hawkes also should have disclosed that he had moved to Southwood and that he had a personal relationship with Chris Corr, a St. Joe vice president who served as a reference for Hawkes when Gov. Jeb Bush appointed him to the court in 2003. Hawkes became the court's point person on courthouse negotiations conducted directly with Corr, the petition states.

The residents of Millview contend that pollution from the old St. Joe paper mill, including lead, arsenic and mercury, are in the soil and in the groundwater of their neighborhood.

A circuit judge had agreed to let the residents consolidate their lawsuits into a class action. But in 2005, a three-judge panel of the 1st DCA, led by Hawkes, overturned the decision and said the cases had to be filed individually.

Now Kerrigan wants the Supreme Court to set aside that ruling and let judges from another of the state's appellate courts hear the case.

"Petitioners do not intend in any way to cast aspersions on the character of any judge on the court," Kerrigan wrote. "But it is clear that there has been a breakdown when it comes to that court's dealings with the new courthouse project planning and construction, and that Judge Hawkes was a key player who exercised an unusual level of control."

The residents of Millview, he wrote, are entitled to the "cold neutrality an impartial judge."

Judge Paul M. Hawkes should have disqualified himself from St. Joe case, lawyers say 11/19/10 [Last modified: Saturday, November 20, 2010 12:42am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. 'Free speech rally' cut short after massive counterprotest


    BOSTON — Thousands of demonstrators chanting anti-Nazi slogans converged Saturday on downtown Boston in a boisterous repudiation of white nationalism, dwarfing a small group of conservatives who cut short their planned "free speech rally" a week after a gathering of hate groups led to bloodshed in Virginia.

    Thousands of people march against a “free speech rally” planned Saturday in Boston. About 40,000 people were in attendance.
  2. Police pull unconscious New Port Richey man from SUV in Cotee River


    NEW PORT RICHEY — Police rescued an unconscious driver whose sport utility vehicle plunged into the Cotee River on Saturday.

  3. Analysis: Bannon is out, but his agenda may live on


    WASHINGTON — In his West Wing office, Stephen Bannon kept a chart listing trade actions — on China, steel and autos — that the Trump White House planned to roll out, week by week, through the fall. Now that Bannon, the president's chief strategist, has been pushed out, the question is whether his …

    Steve Bannon thinks he could be more effective influencing policy from outside the White House.
  4. Trump to skip Kennedy Center Honors awards program


    BRIDGEWATER, N.J. — Acknowledging that he has become a "political distraction," President Donald Trump has decided to skip the festivities surrounding the annual Kennedy Center Honors arts awards later this year, the White House announced Saturday amid the continuing fallout over Trump's stance on last weekend's …

  5. Bucs' annual Women of RED preseason party attracts nearly 2,000


    TAMPA — Theresa Jones is primarily a college football fan, but she wanted to get a taste of the Bucs. So the 46-year-old Tampa resident bought a ticket for the team's Women of RED Ultimate Football Party at Raymond James Stadium on Friday.

    Lee White of Seminole tries on a helmet at Raymond James Stadium in Tampa, Fla. on Friday, August 18, 2017.

Tampa Bay Buccaneers female fans descended upon Raymond James Stadium for the ultimate football party, the 2017 Women of RED: The Takeover, supported by Moffitt Cancer Center. CHARLIE KAIJO   |   Times