Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Lawsuit questions accident victim's claim

TAMPA — No one disputes that two Marriott co-workers died after a speeding car struck them as they walked across a sidewalk along the Harbour Island Bridge.

But the lawyer for the driver is raising another question: Was a third Marriott worker injured by his client?

Lawyers for Matthew R. Moye want a judge to throw out the negligence lawsuit filed against Moye by former Marriott employee Joao Barbosa.

They say a hotel security camera that captured the moments just before the October 2010 crash shows Barbosa nowhere in sight.

"The video proves that plaintiff was never involved in this accident," according to court filings Wednesday by Moye's attorney, Brandon Scheele. "Plaintiff has perpetrated a fraud upon this court in an opportunistic attempt to capitalize upon a tragic event which claimed the lives of two people."

The motion asks a judge to throw out the case based on fraud.

Barbosa, who speaks little English, has said through an interpreter in depositions that he was walking within 6 feet of Douglas Kozar and Kate Kohlier in the moments leading up to the accident.

Police say Moye was speeding on the bridge in a 2001 Cadillac coupe at about 2 a.m. when he hit a curb and spun out of control.

Investigative reports show Moye reached 89 mph seconds just before striking and killing Kozar, 23, and Kohlier, 24. His blood alcohol was 0.13 percent, which exceeds the level at which the state presumes impairment.

Barbosa has said he managed to jump out of the way, injuring his ankle. He was treated at the scene.

Police charged Moye with two counts of vehicular homicide, two counts of DUI manslaughter and one count of driving under the influence with injury. A pretrial conference in the criminal case is scheduled for later this month.

Steve Romine, Moye's lawyer in the criminal case, said he's watching how the civil lawsuit plays out.

He said a blow to the credibility of Barbosa, a police witness, raises questions about the entire case.

"When you discover that evidence relied upon by law enforcement is untrue, then it does raise questions as to everything else in the investigation," he said.

The grainy Marriott video shows only two people on the sidewalk. About 30 seconds later, the video captures a car losing control.

"It appears conclusive to me," Romine said. "It is clear to me, and I think to any reasonable person looking at the video, there's no third person diving out of the way of the car. He's not there."

Mark Cox, a spokesman for the Prosecutor's Office, declined to comment on the civil case.

Barbosa's attorney, Jose Toledo, had not seen a copy of the new court filing and declined to comment on the allegations.

"I can't imagine that to be true," he said. "These are the same folks who alleged the seat belt defense."

Toledo was referring to one of Moye's original affirmative defenses, which said Barbosa — despite being on foot — failed "to use an available operational seat belt."

Scheele, Moye's civil attorney, called the case a tragedy.

"But it's offensive to think someone would inject themselves in an accident when they weren't involved," he said.

Reach Jodie Tillman at or (813) 226-3374.

Lawsuit questions accident victim's claim 09/07/11 [Last modified: Thursday, September 8, 2011 12:18am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Clearwater officer fired after investigation reveals use of unnecessary force on teen

    Public Safety

    A Clearwater police officer was fired after an internal investigation found he used unnecessary force on a teenager in custody, the agency said Wednesday.

  2. Meadowlawn Middle School teacher arrested on molestation charges


    ST. PETERSBURG — A Meadowlawn Middle School teacher was arrested Wednesday morning on charges that he molested three underage girls, police said.

    Joseph Zavalnak, 41, a Meadowlawn Middle School teacher, was arrested May 24, 2017on charges that he molested three underage girls, police said. He faces  five counts of lewd and lascivious molestation. The victims were between the ages of 12 and 18, police said. [Pinellas County Sheriff's Office]
  3. Letter from 'many' St. Petersburg High faculty, staff to Pinellas School Board pushes for assistant principal to be next principal


    A St. Petersburg High teacher sent a letter on the behalf of "many" school faculty and staff to the Pinellas County School Board and school district superintendent Mike Grego in support of appointing their assistant principal, Darlene Lebo, as principal.

    Darlene Lebo, an assistant principal at St. Petersburg High, is supported by "many" school faculty and staff to be the school's next principal, according to a letter sent to the Pinellas County School Board.
  4. 2017 Florida Theme Park Guide: A look at this summer's top attractions


    Florida's theme parks are getting ready for their busiest season with new rides, shows and perks, and we have rounded up a guide to the best new things to see.

    The newest fireworks presentation at Magic Kingdom uses lasers, lights, projections and pyrotechnics showing characters and scenes from more than 25 Disney films. [Walt Disney World]
  5. Meet 'rave pops,' the EDM-loving, hard-dancing 72-year-old who went viral via the Sunset Music Festival (w/video)

    Music & Concerts

    Alan Grofé is a 72-year-old, semi-retired entrepreneur and former tech executive with frost-white hair, two grown children and five grandchildren.

    Alan Grofe dances at the Electric Daisy Carnival festival in Orlando in 2016. [aLIVE Coverage for Insomniac]