Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Mandatory retirement is forcing out Florida judges

Circuit Judge J. Rogers Padgett, 70, will retire at the end of the year, after 34 years on the bench. Padgett is being forced to retire because of age limitations for judges in Florida.


Circuit Judge J. Rogers Padgett, 70, will retire at the end of the year, after 34 years on the bench. Padgett is being forced to retire because of age limitations for judges in Florida.

TAMPA — When judges in Hillsborough have questions about judging, they are as likely to seek guidance from Circuit Judge J. Rogers Padgett as a law book.

Padgett, the county's longest sitting jurist, has served 34 years on the bench and presided over an estimated 900 jury trials. But come January, courthouses around the area will lose decades' worth of that institutional wisdom when he and other veteran robed colleagues are forced into mandatory retirement.

John McCain can run for president at 72, but judges in Florida have to give up their offices when they hit 70. Jokingly referred to as "constitutional senility," the requirement doesn't always sit well with the nimble-minded elders.

"I'm really not ready to go," said Hillsborough Circuit Judge Frank Gomez, another outgoing judge.

Also departing are Judges Marion Fleming in Pinellas and Wayne Cobb in Pasco, that county's most veteran judge with 31 years on the circuit bench. Florida Supreme Court Justices Harry Anstead and Charles Wells face mandatory retirement next year.

State judges aren't alone. Federal law protects most workers from being ousted due to age, but exceptions are made for airline pilots and people in public safety jobs. Some corporate executives and board members, including those at the St. Petersburg Times, are expected to retire at 65.

Florida adopted its retire-at-70 provision in 1972, when the average life expectancy was 70.8 years. Though people can expect to live for 77.8 years as of 2005, the mandatory retirement age for judges hasn't budged.

Legislators who wanted to get more black and female judges on the bench batted down a recommendation in the mid 1990s to either remove the requirement or raise the age limit, said Dexter Douglass, a Tallahassee lawyer and constitutional expert who served on the task force that reviewed the part of the Constitution that deals with the judiciary.

The idea got tossed around again but never gained traction during the Constitution Revision Commission that Douglass chaired in 1997.

He remains in favor of no mandatory retirement age, preferring instead a system by which the Judicial Qualifications Commission would conduct a review of older judges whose abilities are called into question.

"You've got to find when somebody really flunks out that they don't stick around like they do in the federal court sometime," Douglass said. Federal judges are allowed to serve for life.

Judges may fill in after they retire

Already, there is a process in place for judges who apply to serve in a senior capacity after their retirement. Applicants older than 70 are reviewed annually to determine whether they are still fit to serve.

Judge Chris Altenbernd, who sits on the 2nd District Court of Appeal and oversees the committee that serves Hillsborough, Pinellas and Pasco counties, says the current rule allows good judges to continue serving in a limited capacity and helps avoid the awkward situation of involuntary removal.

"It prevents us from having to deal with people who become senile or have other problems and the great difficulty of having to go up to them and say, 'it's just time to quit,' " he said. "That's a very difficult thing to do."

But allowing judges older than 70 to serve at all undermines the rationale behind the "arbitrary" mandatory retirement age, said Larry Polivka, associate director of the School of Aging Studies at the University of South Florida.

In certain fields, people get better with age, he said. He cites U.S. Supreme Court justices who have had the most productive periods in their careers after 70. One of Polivka's favorite jazz musicians, Hank Jones, is performing at his peak at 90.

"It's an antiquated notion, and it's unfortunate that it's embedded still in a few places," Polivka said. "There's no justification for it."

Judges Gomez and Fleming haven't turned 70 yet. Florida judges can finish a term as long as it is halfway over before they reach 70. But both would have become septuagenarians before the midpoint of their terms, meaning the governor would appoint a replacement.

If they had run for their seats and lost, they would have been ineligible to serve as senior judges, who fill in for sitting judges when they are ill or at conferences. Both opted to call it quits instead.

The retiring judges seem resigned, if not enthused, about their fate. They plan to apply to serve as senior judges, though squeezed budgets have cut back the funding for those positions.

Disinclined to sit at home, Padgett, who enjoys traveling to far-flung places like Malta, Gibraltar and the Panama Canal, is considering going abroad to teach English.

Others take a more critical view of the brain drain.

"It's just a waste of talent," said Brandon attorney Robert Fraser.

Times researcher John Martin contributed to this story. Colleen Jenkins can be reached at or (813) 226-3337.

. fast facts

How Florida compares

Some states have no mandatory retirement age for judges. Vermont allows judges to serve until age 90. A majority of states, including Florida, require judges to retire between ages 70 and 75.

Source: National Center for State Courts

Retiring judges

Florida requires judges to retire between ages 70 and 75. A few who will have to step down within the next year:

Mandatory retirement is forcing out Florida judges 09/21/08 [Last modified: Tuesday, September 23, 2008 5:44pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. GOP's new repeal bill would likely leave millions more uninsured, analyses suggest


    WASHINGTON — The latest Republican bid to roll back the Affordable Care Act would likely leave millions of currently insured Americans without health coverage in the coming decades, and strip benefits and protections from millions more, a growing number of independent studies suggest.

    Vice President Mike Pence listens as President Donald Trump talks to reporters about the Graham-Cassidy health care bill during a meeting with Egyptian President Abdel-Fattah el-Sissi at the Palace Hotel during the United Nations General Assembly, Wednesday, Sept. 20, 2017, in New York. [Evan Vucci | Associated Press]
  2. Mueller casts broad net in requesting extensive records from Trump White House


    WASHINGTON — The special counsel investigating Russian election meddling has requested extensive records and email correspondence from the White House, covering the president's private discussions about firing his FBI director and his response to news that the then-national security adviser was under …

    In a photograph provided by the Russian foreign ministry, President Donald Trump meets with Sergei Lavrov, left, the Russian foreign minister, and Sergey Kislyak, the Russian ambassador, in the Oval Office of the White House in Washington, May 10, 2017. Special counsel Robert Mueller is interested in this meeting, where Trump said dismissing FBI Director James Comey had relieved "great pressure" on him, the New York Times reported on Sept. 20. [Russian Foreign Ministry via  New York Times]
  3. 'We will find our island destroyed': Hurricane Maria demolishes Puerto Rico


    SAN JUAN — Sleepless Puerto Ricans awoke Wednesday knowing to expect a thrashing from the most ferocious storm to strike the island in at least 85 years. They met nightfall confronting the ruin Hurricane Maria left behind: engorged rivers, blown-out windows, sheared roofs, toppled trees and an obliterated electric …

    Rescue vehicles from the Emergency Management Agency stand trapped under an awning during the impact of Hurricane Maria, after the storm  hit the eastern region of the island, in Humacao, Puerto Rico, Wednesday, Sept. 20, 2017. The U.S. National Hurricane Center says Maria has lost its major hurricane status, after raking Puerto Rico. But forecasters say some strengthening is in the forecast and Maria could again become a major hurricane by Thursday. [Carlos Giusti | Associated Press]
  4. Obamacare repeal bill offers flexibility and uncertainty


    The latest Republican proposal to undo the Affordable Care Act would grant states much greater flexibility and all but guarantee much greater uncertainty for tens of millions of people.

  5. Manafort offered to give Russian billionaire 'private briefings' on 2016 campaign, report says


    Less than two weeks before Donald Trump accepted the Republican presidential nomination, his campaign chairman offered to provide briefings on the race to a Russian billionaire closely aligned with the Kremlin, the Washington Post reports.

    Paul Manafort, then Donald Trump's campaign chairman, talks to reporters on the floor of the Republican National Convention at Quicken Loans Arena in Cleveland. [Associated Press]